Marvi Sirmed, a traitor to liberal causes in Pakistan – by Rusty Walker


A year ago, I read a thought provoking interview of leading Pakistani political commentator and civilian-military analyst Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa in which she explains the increasing influence of Pakistani establishment on right-wing and (fake) liberal voices in the media.

In Dr. Siddiqa’s words:

Today, we face a state of military hegemony: political, economic and intellectual control. Today, there is not a single university in Pakistan or a young scholar who is not on the military’s payroll or network. They open shops called think-tanks for their young clients. A journalist, who does not take directions from the military, is a rarity in today’s Pakistan. Institutionally, this outreach is done through the ISPR and the ISI. But there are other informal channels as well such as the army chief himself.

In the last two decades, Pakistan’s military establishment has successfully cultivated its influence not only in the right-wing dominated Urdu media but also in the (fake) liberal dominated English media. Both groups (right-wing and fake liberals) often work in subtle coordination to promote agendas and goals of the military establishment. A case in point is the promotion of “Taliban are our brothers” discourse by the Jamaat-e-Islami and PML-N influenced Nawaiwaqt and “Taliban are our strategic assets and partners” discourse by the fake-liberal dominated Jinnah Institute. Similarly, promotion of Tahir Ashrafi and Ahmed Ludhianvi as progressive clerics by certain (fake) liberals (one of them currently heads a pro-establishment think tank) shows the extent to which fake liberals and their right wing Islamist partners cooperate with each other in the service of ISI/ISPR.

Given that LUBP blog has positioned itself as alternative media in Pakistan, a true voice of citizen journalism on issues of human rights, minority and women’s rights, it was clear that not only right-wing Takfiri Islamists but also pro-establishment fake liberals were annoyed by the LUBP blog and its various editors and authors.

It is, therefore, only natural to see pro-establishment fake liberals and Takfiri Islamists united against LUBP blog with the sole aim of terrorizing and silencing anti-establishment liberal voices.

This is where Marvi Sirmed, an NGO official currently working on various projects funded by the United Nations and the US government etc, who promotes herself as a champion of liberal values and human rights, fully exposed herself by close cooperation with Takfiri Islamists to physically harass and threaten a liberal blogger’s family.

In Marvi Sirmed, we see a traitor to liberal causes in Pakistan. She emulates the hateful ideology and tactics of Taliban. To disclose a home address of a liberal blogger to a pro-ASWJ Deobandi cleric makes her a co-conspirator to anyone who comes to harm there. Her seditious scheme forced Abdul Nishapuri, founder-editor of LUBP blog, to resign from the blog, the only reasonable course of action for any person to keep women and children in his family safe from the likes of LeJ Takfiri Deobandi militants, owing to the cruel hearted deception of Marvi Sirmed.

Stunningly, she gave out Abdul’s address to a pro-ASWJ Deobandi cleric intentionally to render him harm. This has denuded her of her cloak of liberalism revealing the naked truth: she is a Takfiri-Deobandi Salafist sympathizer. Why engage in such a seditious and treacherous act upon the honest progressive (former) editor of a pro-pluralist and human rights blog?

Strangely, I have noticed this degrading of moral fibre and the move from liberal to fake liberal in Marvi Sirmed and several of her colleagues and a number of the mainstream Pakistani press over the years. Years prior, they wrote liberal articles that seemed to be pro-human rights and balanced. What has happened to her? What has happened to the mainstream press in Pakistan? Has the ISI-ISPR been successful in hijacking the seemingly liberal voices?

I have read Marvi’s recent coarse tweets, and she only comes off as arrogant and jeering with a decided lack of class. Now, by divulging personal, private and confidential information about a blogger’s family’s whereabouts, she has put an innocent family’s lives in danger, including women and children. This reveals her true nature.

What kind of hateful person does it take to give out information knowing full well it could have brought harm to Adbul Nishapuri’s family! Perhaps the answer lies within recent connections she has made within the Jihadist community of Takfiri Deobandis. Marvi Sirmed is no friend to true progressives or true liberalism in Pakistan.

It does not matter who her relatives are, she did not choose them, but when she starts to behave like her notorious relatives and still professes to be a liberal, that is a serious cause for concern. It is also a reflection on her peers who claim to be champions the liberal agenda.

According to Shazia Najmi,

“Akram Lahori along with Malik Ishaq and Riaz Basra created Lashkar-e-Jhangvi (known as the Accursed Three) which has been carrying out the Shia genocide in Pakistan.”

What a poisonous snake with toxic venom is Marvi Sirmed, who slithers around as a Liberal, but hides in the shadows of the jagged rocks of like-minded Salafist-Deobandi conspirators.

Those she would align with are the Takfiri Deobandis who are really powerless, even with their Saudi-funded money. It is only the powerless in the world that resort to their tactics, such as the use of suicide bombers. I believe they are leech-like opportunists, and so are the establishment press, as it is money, power and influence for which they sell their soul..

Blatant assassinations, of Salmaan Taseer and kidnapping of his son, Shahbaz Taseer, and assassination of Shahbaz Bhatti, shooting of Malala Yusufzai, murder of ANP’s Bilour, got world attention, and yet with the ASWJ-LeJ-LeT killers freed, what has changed within Pakistan? These events, and the genocide of Shia Muslims has silenced the current government, but, the Marvi Sirmed type and pro-establishment press is far from silenced, with their smug tweets; they are proselytizing extremism, and the centerpiece of this essay: brought out the worst in sordid acts such as Marvi Sirmed disclosing addresses of anti-establishment activists, to LeJ. Honest press in Pakistan, and honest government cannot be protected…who could blame them for fleeing to safe havens?

Until someone with the courage and conviction of Benazir Bhutto or someone from the top military brass joins the real liberals, the Army will hold the country hostage to its fear of coup, its Strategic Depth Frankenstein, and fund more and more fake liberals to move over and hold the Jihadist mindset…like that of Marvi Sirmed.


Rusty Walker is an educator, author, political analyst, ex-military, from a military family, retired college professor, former Provost (Collins College, U.S.A.), artist, musician and family man. Rusty Walker is an ardent supporter of Pakistan. Here is a link to Mr. Walker’s other articles published on LUBP:

50 responses to “Marvi Sirmed, a traitor to liberal causes in Pakistan – by Rusty Walker”

  1. Thank you Mr. Walker for your courageous words and exposing the life-style liberal and “moderate” Mullah —- they are pro-9/11 terrorists Your solidarity with the Mujahid NishaPuri is heartening.

  2. Great article! One cannot believe that the ISI can be so evil and so cynical. They raise both opposing sides and people are fooled into allying themselves with one. In either case it is win-win for the ISI. Shame on you Pak Army, which in any case is an illegal institution!

  3. What else we could expect from a person whose:

    – father was in charge of official pro-Islamist propaganda as a humble servant of General Zia-ul-Haq and Nawaz Sharif (as Director of Information Department Punjab)

    – husband was leader of Islami Jamiat-e-Tulba, the student militant of Islamofascist Jamaat Islami

    – family is strictly sectarian Takfiri Deobandi

    – uncle co-founded Lashkar-e-Jhangvi

    She herself has been tasked to capture and hijack the liberal causes in Pakistan on the behest of the ISI and the LeJ.

    Thank you, Mr. Walker, for exposing the fake liberal hypocrite, a Takfiri Deobandi in disguise.

  4. Balanced article and showed great courage, in pakistan it is a hurrculian task to exposed such type of fake liberals.

  5. Thank you, Ayesha!
    It can be dangerous, for one or a handful to speak out. If the majority of liberals/ progressives spoke out against those playing both sides, or playing up to the establishment in order to sabotage liberal goals from within, the more others will be encouraged to speak out. Were this phenonenon to increase and the Ummah spoke out against those aligned with the Takfiri Wahhabi Deobandi, as numbers increased among the civil society speaking out about what many know, but are fearful to publically disclaim, the dangers of speaking the truth might lessen.
    As fear decreases, more speak out, until we have a movement of the people. Perhaps numbers in such strength that submits pressure on the military, pressure that holds authorities to expected standards, or they are fired, lose their credibility, or are voted out of office; and law and order prevails over questionable C.J. decisions; pressure could become great enough on Saudi-funded terrorists in our midst, that we could start to make a difference.
    “If there is no struggle, there is no progress. Those who profess to favor freedom, and deprecate agitation, are men who want crops without plowing up the ground, they want rain without thunder and lightning.” “…Without a struggle, there can be no progress.”

    -Frederick Douglass


  6. 56 year-old Mechanical Engineer Mike from Hanover, likes to spend some time jewelry making, nike free and tv. Has toured since childhood and has traveled to numerous destinations, for example Lhasa.