Noam Chomsky: General Zia ul Haq and Saudi Arabia destroyed Pakistan’s public education – by Dr. Abbas Zaidi

 

images

Pakistan’s right wing journalists and educated classes proudly claim that it was because of General Zia ul Haq that Pakistan’s top educational institutions like the Lahore Grammar School and Beacon House came into existence. The argument they give is that the General liberalized education. By “liberalize,” they mean, “privatize”. The argument further says that Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto nationalized education, which blighted Pakistan’s education.

The facts, however, are contrary to the claim. Before Bhutto nationalized education, very few parents were able to send their children to school because education was a private sector of society. When Bhutto nationalized education, all changed. It is important to note here that those denouncing Bhutto for nationalizing education do not tell their interlocutors that the nationalization of education meant free education. By bringing education into the public sector, Bhutto enabled all Pakistanis to send their children to school without having to pay anything.

Before the General overthrew Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto’s democratically elected government in 1977, Pakistan’s public education was not only free, but was of high standard too. Most of the top positions in secondary and intermediate levels used to be bagged by government/Urdu medium schools, and not by expensive, privately owned schools. Today, the majority of those who are educators, scientists, bankers, doctors engineers, etc., are beneficiaries of the free education which Bhutto gifted them. I personally know a number of highly educated people, myself included, who could not have been able to go to school if education was not free.

But General Zia diverted all money to madrassas and defense, and the government schools were left with only enough money to pay off teachers and administrative staff. Saudi Arabia pumped in billions of dollars to create a parallel education system in Pakistan that severely undermined public education and created Deobandi Islamofascist mobsters, murderers, and suicide bombers. Thus, what we see today is that public education is still there, but few like to send their children to government schools. Public education has become a stigma: The very question, “Does your child go to a government school?” will be answered with a rude “No!”

images

 

Certainly, there is no debate about this in Pakistan because the people are busy destroying their society’s indigenous cultural-intellectual foundations as they bulldozes their way to al-Bakistanization of their society. But those who worry about the future of humanity, do study Pakistan, yes even Pakistan! The other day, I was reading Chomsky’s What we say goes: Conversations on US power in a changing world, and came across a significant passage about Pakistan. Below I reproduce what he has to say about how General Zia and Saudi Arabia destroyed Pakistan’s public education.

“In Pakistan, which is now a major centre for radical Islamism, the movement began with the former president Muhammad Zia ul-Haq, who was strongly supported by the Reagan administration. In fact, all through his tenure, the Reagan administration pretended that Zia wasn’t developing nuclear weapons. Of course they knew that he was. But every year they would religiously certify that Pakistan was not developing nuclear weapons because they wanted to support their radical, extremist, fundamentalist friend. They knew perfectly well that Saudi Arabia was funding the extremist madrassas, the religious schools that undermined the Pakistani educational system, which had been pretty good beforehand. People like Pervez Hoodbhoy, a Pakistani nuclear physicist, now deplore that you can’t get students to study the sciences because schools only teach the Koran. That wasn’t true in the past.

Source: Chomsky, Noam. (2007). What we say goes: Conversations on US power in a changing world. Crows Nest, NSW, Australia: Allen & Unwin, p. 26.

 

Comments

comments

Latest Comments
  1. anam tariq
    Reply -
    • S. Waqar Hasan
      Reply -
  2. Qamar Abbas Kumali
    Reply -
  3. Timberland Homme
    Reply -
  4. http://www.mycnfrtn.com
    Reply -
  5. zendesk.com
    Reply -
  6. https://northmarion.zendesk.com
    Reply -
  7. louis vuitton outlet
    Reply -
  8. montres guess homme
    Reply -
  9. nike air max 90 white
    Reply -
  10. cheap nike air max
    Reply -
  11. nike air max 1 sale
    Reply -
  12. cheap ray ban sunglasses
    Reply -
  13. ray ban outlet
    Reply -
  14. ray ban rb3025
    Reply -
  15. ray ban rb2132
    Reply -
  16. nike air max 1
    Reply -
  17. nike air max hyperfuse
    Reply -
  18. cchnwnoqf
    Reply -
  19. Tracey
    Reply -
  20. safest wow gold
    Reply -
  21. payday loan
    Reply -
  22. ray ban 3183
    Reply -
  23. ray ban polarized
    Reply -
  24. ray ban sunglasses outlet
    Reply -
  25. ray ban polarized
    Reply -
  26. nike air max pink
    Reply -
  27. nike air max 2014
    Reply -
  28. nike air max 1 premium
    Reply -
  29. nike air max classic bw
    Reply -
  30. garcinia cambogia free trial nz
    Reply -
  31. Esperanza
    Reply -
  32. http://j12designs.Com
    Reply -
  33. Www.bawden.info
    Reply -
  34. nike air max 97
    Reply -
  35. womens nike air max
    Reply -
  36. Oliva
    Reply -
  37. Terrie
    Reply -
  38. Academyctims.Zp.Ua
    Reply -
  39. http://j.itesin.cz/subdom/j/index.php/tv-movies/entertainment/item/705-fast-Furious-6/contact.php
    Reply -
  40. ray ban rb3025
    Reply -
  41. ray ban shades
    Reply -
  42. Www.explicitsupplements.com
    Reply -
  43. ray ban glasses frames
    Reply -
  44. cheap ray ban sunglasses
    Reply -
  45. ray ban sale
    Reply -
  46. ray ban caravan
    Reply -
  47. Jada
    Reply -
  48. ray ban sunglasses
    Reply -
  49. http://toothpastehq.drupalgardens.com
    Reply -
  50. ray ban rb2132
    Reply -
  51. ray ban 2132
    Reply -
  52. Leif
    Reply -
  53. Janie
    Reply -
  54. nike air max 97
    Reply -
  55. nike air max outlet
    Reply -
  56. Jerome
    Reply -
  57. ray ban sunglasses outlet
    Reply -
  58. ray ban caravan
    Reply -
  59. ray ban clubmaster
    Reply -
  60. ray ban 3447
    Reply -
  61. ray ban wayfarer
    Reply -
  62. Coach Factory Outlet
    Reply -
  63. ray ban 2140
    Reply -
  64. Maxwell
    Reply -
  65. nike air max ltd
    Reply -
  66. nike air max pink
    Reply -
  67. nike air max 90 black
    Reply -
  68. nike air max white
    Reply -
  69. cheap michael kors purses
    Reply -
  70. Qtrace.Org
    Reply -
  71. Freeman
    Reply -
  72. womens nike air max
    Reply -
  73. Bikelights.drupalgardens.com
    Reply -
  74. michael kors makeup bag
    Reply -
  75. ray ban glasses frames
    Reply -
  76. michael kors baby bag
    Reply -
  77. ray ban 3025
    Reply -
  78. ray ban 3025
    Reply -
  79. michael kors clearance
    Reply -
  80. cheap ray ban sunglasses
    Reply -
  81. ray ban caravan
    Reply -
  82. guarantor loans
    Reply -
  83. ray ban sunglasses outlet
    Reply -
  84. ray ban glasses
    Reply -
  85. ray ban glasses
    Reply -
  86. ray ban canada
    Reply -
  87. helpmesn
    Reply -
  88. ray ban rb4147
    Reply -
  89. Leona
    Reply -
  90. Hassan
    Reply -
  91. Beatris
    Reply -
  92. Rod
    Reply -
  93. ray ban shades
    Reply -
  94. pure garcinia cambogia dr oz free trial
    Reply -
  95. nike air max 1 premium
    Reply -
  96. nike air max 90 white
    Reply -
  97. Www.Onlineyesilcam.com
    Reply -
  98. http://www.navelclips.com/profile.php?u=RosettaPrew
    Reply -
  99. http://mybandsaw.drupalgardens.com/
    Reply -
  100. michael kors baby bag
    Reply -
  101. Joycelyn
    Reply -
  102. Tiffani
    Reply -
  103. pure garcinia cambogia dr oz free trial
    Reply -
  104. sodastream.drupalgardens.com
    Reply -
  105. ray ban uk
    Reply -
  106. ray ban outlet
    Reply -
  107. http://Www.kuustom.com/
    Reply -
  108. radioactivecontroller.com
    Reply -
  109. Verena
    Reply -
  110. Www.The-Wallpapers.Com
    Reply -
  111. Andrew
    Reply -
  112. nike air max white
    Reply -
  113. Http://Myelectrickettle.Drupalgardens.Com
    Reply -
  114. ray ban glasses frames
    Reply -
  115. Florene
    Reply -
  116. http://cromz.endoftheinternet.org/Member.php?action=profile&uid=66422
    Reply -
  117. Tatiana
    Reply -
  118. ray ban uk
    Reply -
  119. ray ban cockpit
    Reply -
  120. Auieoerp.com
    Reply -
  121. Adriene
    Reply -
  122. www.bidcirus.com
    Reply -
  123. kitchenfaucetshub.drupalgardens.com
    Reply -
  124. Kiara
    Reply -
  125. Drusilla
    Reply -
  126. ray ban 3016
    Reply -
  127. ray ban rb2132
    Reply -

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


*