Home  »  Newspaper Articles • Original Articles   »   Terrorism: is media a watchdog or lapdog? On Sethi-Rumi mollycoddling ASWJ’s Ludhianvi — by Dr Mohammad Taqi

Terrorism: is media a watchdog or lapdog? On Sethi-Rumi mollycoddling ASWJ’s Ludhianvi — by Dr Mohammad Taqi

posted by SK | March 20, 2013 | In Newspaper Articles, Original Articles

generals-1024x680

Source: Daily Times

The ostensibly liberal publication gave space quite liberally to Ludhianvi to bash the Shia without a single challenging question being asked

Pakistan finally saw democratically elected national and provincial assemblies plod past the five-year finish line — a first in the country’s history. Despite many flaws the outgoing parliamentarians added several constitutional feathers to their caps. From restoration of the judges made dysfunctional by a tin pot dictator to the president giving up his powers to send the assemblies packing, there are many constitutional achievements that lawmakers and indeed President Asif Zardari, as the co-chairman of the ruling Pakistan People’s Party (PPP), can be rightly proud of.

But it is most unfortunate that the parliament, which had come into being within months after Benazir Bhutto was martyred by terrorists, delayed passing the Anti-Terrorism Bill till its last few hours. The ruling PPP did not let out as much as a peep, let alone amend the blasphemy laws, when one of its own leaders, and the governor of the country’s largest province, Salmaan Taseer, was mowed down by his guard in the federal capital. The rulers at the centre and in the provinces presided over the systematic slaughter of the Ahmedis and Christians without letting the stench of the corpses interfere with their opulent daily routines. Ethnic cleansing of the Baloch in their homeland continued unabated throughout the democratic rule while an ethnic Baloch held the presidency. The Pashtun and Afghan blood became even cheaper in the past five years than it had been over the last four decades. The Pashtun mosque, hujra, homes, shrine, jirga and even funeral remained under unrelenting terrorist assaults in the name of religion.

While the death toll from the indiscriminate acts of terrorism over the last five is in tens of thousands, one community that faced a systematic targeted extermination that reached the genocide proportions during the democratic rule is the Shia of Pakistan. Starting with the siege and slaughter of the Kurram Shia for years, it morphed through the massacres like the one at Babusar Top into pogroms of the Hazara and non-Hazara Shia of Quetta and Karachi by way of car bombings. The mass killings of the Shia make headlines in the national and international media for a few days before being relegated into collective oblivion but the hundreds of targeted killings of the Shia individuals hardly make but a news ticker on the tele-media or a blurb on the newspapers’ city pages. In the last five years, Shia doctors, engineers, teachers, lawyers, government employees and artisans were targeted and killed on a daily basis while the others lived in fear or tried to leave the communities that had been their home for centuries.

The latest Shia professional to be killed is Professor Sibte Jafar Zaidi, a poet and former principal of the Liquatabad College, Karachi. But he was no ordinary teacher or poet. While known for writing and reciting marsiyah, nauha and manqibat, Professor Zaidi truly was the foremost exponent of soz-khwani (soz literally means ‘burning’, a form of poetic lament recited in a melodic tune ‘lehn’ at the Shiite mourning gatherings or Majalis) in Pakistan. It would perhaps take a book to fully describe the martyred Professor and his art but suffice it to say that the brutal assassination of such a cultural icon would have caused a collective national mourning elsewhere. But save a few token condemnations let’s not expect anything more in Pakistan. In fact, Professor Zaidi’s death came at a time when efforts to sanitise the narrative against the Shia genocide took an ugly turn.

For all its faults, the outgoing democratic government had put no leash whatsoever on the media. From Kerry-Lugar-Berman act to the Rental Power Plant cases the media dragged the politicians over the coals and kept the government on its toes. But one area where the media either remained mum and worse underreported or misreported the events was the ongoing Shia genocide in Pakistan. Initially, the media self-censored and did not report identity of the victims as Shia being killed solely for their faith. But when the killings rose exponentially, media, and even human rights activists, squabbled over whether the magnitude of extermination of the Shia ‘justifies’ calling it as genocide. When finally the international media started taking cognizance of the Shia genocide in Pakistan, the apologists of the killers in the local media sprang into action presenting the vicious hatemongers as some benign reformists seeking reconciliation.

The English press was relatively immune to this affliction but one English weekly [The Friday Times, edited by Najam Sethi and Raza Roomi] hit a new low last week, publishing an interview of the Ahle-Sunnat-wal-Jamaat (ASWJ) — another name for the banned terrorist group Sipah-e-Sahaba Pakistan (SSP) — leader Muhammad Ahmad Ludhianvi. The weekly asked the rabblerousing cleric that his outfit is known for chanting the slogan ‘Kafir, Kafir Shia Kafir (apostate, apostate, the Shia are apostate)’ in public rallies but does it not provoke the people to attack the Shia? Ludhianvi’s response was: “Kafir, Kafir Shia Kafir is just a slogan, like any other, such as Roti, Kapra aur Makaan (bread, clothing and shelter). It does not tell anyone to kill Shias. Speeches of Haq Nawaz Jhangvi are available online and in the market. He used this slogan throughout his life but never said Shias should be killed. We call Shias kafir on the basis of a unanimous edict issued by highly reputable jurists of Deoband. This slogan is not the reason behind the killing of Shias, and we don’t force people to chant the slogan in our rallies.”

A slogan like Roti, Kapra aur Makaan? Give me a break, dear editors. No follow up questions were asked about what right does an individual or a seminary — even Deoband — has to ostracise and condemn a community as apostates. Ludhianvi was not confronted with the content from the hundreds of speeches in which he and his cohorts have pledged to make the life miserable for the Shia, made barely concealed calls to arms against the Shia and innuendo about exterminating them. The ostensibly liberal publication gave space quite liberally to Ludhianvi to bash the Shia without a single challenging question being asked. Granted that journalists have to deal with all manner of unsavoury characters but giving projection with such kid-glove treatment to ranting clerics who openly and/or off-the-record threaten the very existence of the Shia seriously impugns the liberal credentials of the editors of the weekly. While politicians are rightly chastised for a spineless and toothless stint but puff interviews like Ludhianvi’s make one wonder if the media has served as a watchdog or lapdog of terrorists.

The writer can be reached at mazdaki@me.com and he tweets @mazdaki

http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2013\03\21\story_21-3-2013_pg3_2

rr

Comments

comments

About The Author

SK

Latest Comments
  1. Hasnain Walji

    Sethi-Rumi duo’s Newsspeak has sunk to a new low. I an reminded of the quote by Don Watson “When journalists ignore abuses of the public language by people of influence and power, and reproduce without comment words that are intended to deceive and manipulate … when this happens journalism ceases to be journalism and becomes a kind of propaganda.”

    He also said “Awareness is the only defence against (this) creeping plague … (of abuse and manipulation of public language).’

    Dr. Taki – Thank you for continuously creating awareness.

    -
  2. Mamdot

    Barely has history bred the pseudo-liberals of Najam Sethi ilk. Rightly described as “lapdog”. Of high breed.

    -
  3. Shoaib Mumtaz

    How can one compare kafir kafir slogan with roti kapara aur makan? I am deoband Muslim and I think it is my duty to respect the beliefs of others and Islam never allows us to even disrespect non muslims with infidel labels how can we do it to one of sect that is representing fair amount of muslims across the globe

    -
  4. free tv for

    I just saw something about this on tv. It talked the same things you wrote about.

    I go to university in Canada and we just learned about this in the classroom.
    Thanks for helping me with the final part of my report.

    Thanks for the outline of television stuff.
    I totally think that cable television is going to go
    away. Or at least have to change with the times.

    Online tv is totally the wave of the future. As broadband
    speeds get faster, everyone will be watching
    their shows on sites like this.
    What does anybody know about this? I don’t think there’s a lot more
    to the concept
    I was just watching this on TV last week. They discussed the same things you wrote about.

    my webpage free tv for

    -
  5. https://twitter.com/

    Those shelves could be best for my basement. I am going to utilize the desing for organizing my
    boxes.

    Here is my website Heavy Duty Shelf (https://twitter.com/)

    -
  6. ray ban a specchio

    Puis-je appliquer une couche d’eau 脿 base de polyur茅thane sur une couche de base de l’huile 脿 base de polyur茅thane? Je dois finir quelques portes en bois qui ont tache et une couche d’huile 脿 base de polyur茅thane.

    -
  7. www.winhotelsolution.com/?id=84

    Marilyn Monroe: Marilyn Monroe is known for her sultry screen image, but when it came to her wedding attire for her marriage to baseball legend Joe DiMaggio, she chose a dark brown suit accented by an ermine collar and embellished by a delicate corsage of white orchids. The couple exchanged vows in a judge’s chambers in San Francisco City Hall on January 14th, 1954.

    -
  9. トートバッグ ブラック

    Most people Previously Laugh at the japan – Now We laugh at all of them

    -
  10. Louis Vuitton Handväskor på Sale utlopp

    I’m not sure where you are getting your info, but good topic. I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding more. Thanks for great info I was looking for this information for my mission.
    Louis Vuitton Handväskor på Sale utlopp http://www.goevent.se/omgevent.cfm

    -
  11. otnleqiq

    Terrorism: is media a watchdog or lapdog? On Sethi-Rumi mollycoddling ASWJ’s Ludhianvi — by Dr Mohammad Taqi
    aotnleqiq
    [url=http://www.ga2vjv1t240w7yx0d1zg64898ur6i64vs.org/]uotnleqiq[/url]
    otnleqiq http://www.ga2vjv1t240w7yx0d1zg64898ur6i64vs.org/

    -
  18. strettonclimatecare.org.uk/?id=316

    Today we enter the dressing room of Khloe Kardashian Which, of the sisters became famous for a reality traits kitsch is that which has been shown to have a real talent in accumulating all kinds of shoes, so to send to the

    -
  20. Cheap Michael Kors Handbags

    https://gitorious.org/+2eq1f3rn another or
    saving some money so which is really affordable https://gitorious.org/+ux4eypfj Doublet resulted to me to
    be able to change a little something fashion specific got https://gitorious.org/+vxnfnckm rewards
    costs you, disability coming from all a good reputation, disability with many years was living property and assets https://gitorious.org/+g2dod3iub and 4) that sometimes joined as
    time pass thereafter pretty much

    Also visit my site: Cheap Michael Kors Handbags

    -
  21. ブラック トートバッグ

    japan will help every one of us by simply including a lot of exclusive functions and characteristics. Its a unvaluable item for all fan of japan.

    -
  24. Cheap Michael Kors Handbags

    chicago electric tile saw parts classic unrequited
    love songs My latest
    book is Newton’s karate: technology Behind America’s Game,
    shared by Ballantine in November 2013. My other books add some
    Billion Dollar Game: behind the scenes at the Super
    Bowl and Clapton’s Guitar: Watching Wayne Henderson Build a great Instrument.

    For five years I wrote the By the Numbers sports business results column for the Wall Street Journal.
    fashion since 1940 vw beetle cheap louis vuitton outlet online http://www.arknursingstudents.com/?index=cheap-louis-vuitton-outlet-online

    Also visit my blog: Cheap Michael Kors Handbags

    -
  25. celine luggage

    Definine votre style personnel

    -
  26. nosqprcnbe

    Il sera s?rement disponible à 9h du matin sur le Nikestore au prix de 120€.http://sneakersnewsfr.blogspot.fr/2015/04/nike-huarache-nike-huarache-femme-nike.html – nike huarache 2013 pas cher
    marron habillé par une fine sangle doublée à la cheville.J’ai personnellement beaucoup gagné à simplifier ma vie de la sorte et je vous invite à en faire tout autant.http://sneakersnewsfr.blogspot.fr/2015/05/roshe-run-roshe-run-femme-roshe-run-noir.html – nike roshe run noir
    caractéristiques de caoutchouc de polyuréthane – bonnes performances anti-usure.La Air Jordan IV Red Suede est entièrement en daim rouge contrasté par des accents de noir, de blanc et de cement grey.http://sneakersnewsfr.blogspot.fr/2015/04/basket-free-run-femme-jusqu-82-moins.html – nike free 2.0
    cette partie des principales considérations sont: respirant.http://sneakersnewsfr.blogspot.fr/2015/04/basket-free-run-femme-jusqu-82-moins.html – free run prix
    Budget de 2500€ commission incluse pour :Un complet AMIUn cardigan AMIUne chemise AMIUn manteau AMIUne cravate SmaltoUne paire de brogues Paul SmithUne ceinture Galeries LafayetteVous pouvez également commenter ce relooking sur le sujet dédié du forum.Et symbolise plus que jamais le mâle viril et séducteur auquel tous les hommes ont envie de ressembler.http://sneakersnewsfr.blogspot.fr/2015/04/nike-free-run-2-noir-jusqu-82-moins.html – nike free flyknit
    Caoutchouc dur peut être utilisé pour la fabrication de produits d’isolation électrique.pronation chaussures de course cas de secousse avec un choix ou un à un.http://sneakersnewsfr.blogspot.fr/2015/04/free-run-femme-pas-cher-jusqu-48-moins.html – nike free run prix

    -
  27. Oakley Juliet Sunglasses Loose

    I love it when I hit the jackpot and get this great information
    Oakley Juliet Sunglasses Loose

    -
  28. Shauna

    Have you ever thought about creating an ebook or guezt authoring on other websites?
    I have a blog based upon on the same topics you discuss and would love to
    have you share some stories/information. I know my readers
    would value your work. If you are even remotely interested,
    feel free to shoot me an email.

    my web page: web page (Shauna)

    -
  29. Ray Ban Rb3429

    I can report for certain this will make a huge difference.
    Ray Ban Rb3429

    -
  31. Oakley Sunglasses In Nottingham

    oh cool, this information is really useful and definately is comment worthy! hehe. I’ll see if I can try to use some of this information for my own blog. Thanks!
    Oakley Sunglasses In Nottingham

    -
  32. consolidate payday loans

    Hello there! This is my 1st comment here so I just
    wanted to give a quick shout out and tell you I really enjoy reading
    through your posts. Can you recommend any other blogs/websites/forums that
    cover the same topics? Appreciate it!

    -
  33. wow gold

    They were my own initially wow gold and I will have to proclaim When i treasured these products!

    -
  34. buy wow gold

    This approach buy wow gold is actually effective along with of course sweet! Before i got these i used to be considering or thinking about driving these away. When i had it we were holding truly giant in the calf along with held on to slipping downward without having to cozy for instance i had produced supposed.

    -
  35. Oakley Eyepatch Polarized Lens Replacement

    Oakley Sunglasses have always played a defining role in the evolution of eyewear. The company also manages to stay in the news with contributions to society and great sunglass designs. Cheap Oakley sunglasses also filter out 100% of all the harmful UV rays of the sun. Oakley sunglasses lenses block 100% of all UVA, UVB, UVC and harmful blue light. Meanwhile, the clarity will not be affected at all. Another innovation rests with strict tests of Oakley sunglasses. Before being marketed, Oakley glasses must pass two tests.

    -
  36. wow gold

    Bel wow gold – Moi recommande vivement

    -
  37. Custom Cabinets

    One more waay to conserve iss to ggo for stone ceramic tiles, which
    could crate the abundant stone appearance with half thhe expense.

    Also visit my weblog; Custom Cabinets

    -
  38. www.callupcontact.Com

    Next, pay for the right injury attorney (http://www.callupcontact.Com) aand connect and
    coperate with them.

    -
  39. SEO Services Vaughan

    You don’t have to be a dazzling computer hacer too realize SEO Services Vaughan aand how you can go about it – among my most valuable takeaways to this day.

    -
  40. san antonio iphone repair

    Visit our locations or our licensed technicians can involve you ass well as mend your apple san antonio iphone repair,
    iPad or iPodd in just mins.

    -
  41. Charlesbout

    1. Structure de la chaussure: supérieure, semelle, semelle intermédiaire, semelle, coussin d’air.Avec le médicament tant attendu Feng II chaussures de football date de sortie approche, porte-parole de Nike chef Feng a également mis à empoisonner la prochaine génération de chaussures de football drogue feng. série avant de Poison présentera collier ajustement dynamique, ce qui en fait rejoint l’assassin Superfly IV et cartes fant?mes camp Obra, tandis que Neymar est vêtue d’une version très personnalisée de l’avant de la drogue.2. Tige: fournir un soutien et une protection pour le pied, la chaussure apparences, le verrouillage de la semelle intermédiaire et la semelle extérieure de la couche externe.PHYLON est un matériau moussant après la mousse comprimée, léger et peut continuer à fournir amortir le pied. NIKE semelle intermédiaire est aujourd’hui le plus couramment utilisé.CUIR (cuir): sens de valeur, respirante, résistance à l’abrasion, une bonne résistance à la déchirure, de déformation, de concours, d’entretien facile.
    http://www.superflynike.fr/pic/Nike-Mercurial/Mercurial-Glide/Crampons-Foot-Nike-Noir-Blanc-Mauve-Superflynike-Fr.jpg
    http://www.superflynike.fr/pic/Nike-Mercurial/Mercurial-Glide/Chaussures-Foot-Enfant-Nike-Mercurial-Noir-Vert-Superflynike-Fr.jpg

    -
  42. safest wow gold

    I adore some of these safest wow gold they are going all right with anything attract. It is suggested any of these buy wow gold to all of of my buddies.

    -
  43. Lawerence

    What’s up it’s me, I am also visiting this web site daily,
    this site is genuinely pleasant and the visitors are truly sharing good thoughts.

    Feel free to surf to my web site: garcinia cambogia burn free trial (Lawerence)

    -
  44. Jordan fusions

    The Jordan 11 Low Bred could just be the most highly anticipated sneaker release of summer, and it’s not all that difficult to see why. Jordan Brand could have given us a standard lowtop of the classic Air Jordan 11 Bred aesthetic much like they did with the Concord Lows last year, but instead they delved deeper into their history to bring us something truly special during their 30th summer. The shoe features a red lining as a call back to the PEs that Jordan wore during the summer of 1996. The brand has already confessed to bringing back a number of early samples as new colorways this year, from the Air Jordan 5 Pre-Grape to those mysterious Rare Air’ Air Jordan 1s without the Wings logo. The Cordura nylon construction returns featuring the staple black patent leather in this Air Jordan 11 Low Bred release.

    -
  45. safest wow gold

    My spouse and i prescribed 1/2 more compact as several asked for and desire these days I just resolved to go 1/2 bigger. I convey 9 1/2 and may also make use of a Hunting for. I ‘m having safest wow gold contribute to I’m going on vacation and in addition they physically fit o . k . simply just close and need help get cheap wow gold out! Otherwise all are I was expecting, just adore safest wow gold!

    -
  46. jordan 4 for sale

    I’m among the fortunate few who has had the pleasure in Indulging on thiss tantalizing dessert!

    It was delightful!

    Feeel free to visit my website: jordan 4 for sale

    -
  47. Charlesbout

    2015 nouveaux vêtements pour femmes en gros le moins cher des magasins d’usine de gros cette année, où les vêtements vêtements en gros fourniture en gros plus à la mode où moins cher? Nouveau coton T-shirt à manches courtes Mode d’été des femmes gros vêtements d’été Zigong vêtements en gros marché de gros est encore loin encore sorties vêtements en gros usine directe d’usine, l’entreprise depuis sa création, a accumulé une riche expérience dans le marketing commercial, accueillir les nouveaux et les anciens clients ainsi le développement des plus bas prix de 5 yuans de la subvention, la version européenne du Japon et la Corée du Sud modèles féminins jeans, de bonne qualité, non défectueux, des prix bas. Divers vêtements du commerce extérieur? Hommes? Les femmes? En raison autant, classique et élégant, cru, modèles de mode, porter du blanc chaux, pantalons de crayon, pantalons de tubes, pantalons fuselés Version de type. Nous nous félicitons de la mise en place de long terme, amical, gagnant-gagnant partenariat avec tous les secteurs de l’entreprise! Qian Baihui élégante
    pour la beauté de vous , trouver votre propre personnalisé exclusif et belle. Une seule pièce. Style européen et américain. Beauté discrète est pas le même que ?de luxe? et de l’expérience ‘personnalisé’! Notre femme de magasin, pas de distinction d’age, seule la mentalité de distinction. En raison de notre marque à une femme de l’intérieur vraiment belle, si notre mentalité est toujours libre, jeunesse, pleine de vitalité et de la force et de la sagesse! \\ U003ca href = ‘/ produit / 2014100210623352.html ‘\\ u003e
    http://www.itclicks.be/pic/Surv-c3-aatement-Jordan-Homme/Surv-c3-aatement-Jordan-Homme-Pas-Cher-Survetement-1443-0.jpg
    gros
    des femmes d’hiver Louis Vuitton hiver de 2014 femmes de Louis Vuitton 2014 de
    http://www.itclicks.be/pic/Surv-c3-aatement-Ed-Hardy-Femme/Surv-c3-aatement-Ed-Hardy-Femme-Pas-Cher-Survetement-2501-0.jpg
    Mansi bord pour un spectacle d’automne depuis 13 ans, offre abondante. Ceux qui ont besoin de grandes (plusieurs milliers ou dizaines de milliers de pièces) s’il vous pla?t appelez-nous directement: 18268822272. Vous pouvez également vous connecter directement à notre site Web ou les commandes de la station Taobao:
    pour la beauté de vous, de trouver votre propre personnalisé exclusif et belle. Une seule pièce. Style européen et américain. Beauté discrète est pas le même que ?de luxe? et de l’expérience ‘personnalisé’! Notre femme de magasin, pas de distinction d’age, seule la mentalité de distinction. En raison de notre marque à une femme de l’intérieur vraiment belle, si notre mentalité est toujours libre, jeunesse, pleine de vitalité et de la force et de la sagesse! Blouses élevés de l’Etat

    -
  48. MichaelGag

    Chaussures de sport est basé sur les caractéristiques des personnes qui participent à des sports ou conception et la fabrication du tourisme. Semelles de chaussures de sport et des chaussures ordinaires, des chaussures différentes sont généralement doux et souple. Peut jouer un r?le de tampon. L’exercice peut améliorer la flexibilité, et certains peuvent prévenir les blessures à la cheville. Par conséquent, lors d’activités sportives, la plupart portent des chaussures de sport, tels que: le basket-ball, en cours d’exécution.éditeurmax air nike
    Upper (aide)
    basket nike femme pas cher
    Après plus de 30 années de développement rapide et importante, l’industrie de la chaussure de la Chine a accumulé beaucoup de contradictions, industrie de la chaussure orientée vers l’exportation, face à la diminution marché international, mais aussi de grands marchés couplées avec des mesures de protection commerciale antidumping et autres du pays chaussures de l’industrie chinoise de pression à la baisse, tandis que la taille de l’entreprise semble, un certain nombre de faillites de petites entreprises.De l’extérieur, combinée avec l’état de la périphérie extérieure du fond devrait être étroitement adhérence et pas d’écart, la surface inférieure doit être plat.

    -
  49. MichaelGag

    Le détail de la collection : quelques pantalons portés assez courts, bien au-dessus de la cheville.Larges, ceux-ci peuvent se plier et se transformer à volonté ou presque.Vêtement aussi chic que décontracté, il caractérise bien l’esprit Diesel.com mais c’est bien au SIHH que la maison Jaeger-LeCoultre va officiellement dévoiler la nouvelle version de sa Grande Reverso Ultra Thin, cette fois habillée dun boîtier en or rose 18 carats et dun cadran chocolat. basket montant adidas Plutôt que le 501 bleu, tournez-vous pour une fois vers le jean noir.Il s’agit de palmes pour les mains qui rendent l’entrainement des nageurs plus efficace.Non, les poches doivent être vides, ou contenir au maximum un brin de monnaie.Il avait déjà par le passé travaillé pour Guy Laroche et Hubert de Givenchy avant de retourner dans son pays natal. destockage chaussures adidas Les chaussures concernées par l’opération sont les suivantes : Superstar, Stan Smith, Samba, Nizza et Forum.Le colorama met plus en avant les teintes de violet et bleu qui se mélangent parfaitement avec les teintes d’orangé-rouge qui feront de notre future saison un renouveau de la mode.Le choix illusoire?: la plus efficace des méthodes pour effectivement obtenir un rendez-vous, c’est de laisser penser à votre interlocutrice qu’elle a le contr?le de la situation, que le fait de vous revoir s’inscrit dans une logique qui lui bénéficie..

    -
  50. Faraz

    This means there is a very good chance of it helping you to slim down but it may not work in any way.
    Fantasy Festival Images 2017

    Fantasy Fest

    -