Maligning Shaheed Benazir Bhutto on Nusrat Bhutto’s death
My attention to Murtaza Razvi’s piece on Begum Nusrat Bhutto was drawn by a fellow Tweep (@Darveshh) who referred to the article (A remarkable life story) published in Indian Express with the following comment: “No, it’s not Ansar Abbasi, it is Murtaza Razvi.”
I have read the said article twice and can confidently say it is replete of intellectual and factual inaccuracies and misrepresentations.
According to his profile on Wikipedia: Murtaza Razvi is a senior journalist with Dawn, served as Resident Editor, Dawn (2005–2007), columnist and political analyst for Indian Express.
Usually we would not expect multiple intellectual and factual misrepresentations in a single article from someone who has worked as resident editor at Pakistan’s leading English newspaper. Well, everything is possible in the land of the pure!
Sadly, Razvi has used Begum Bhutto’s death to malign her own daughter Benazir Bhutto and husband Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. Let me explain in further detail.
In the very first paragraph, Razvi refers to ‘the fact’ that Begum Bhutto was forcefully stripped of PPP’s chairpersonship by none else than her daughter, Benazir Bhutto.
Begum Nusrat Bhutto’s posthumous crowning as “Mother of Democracy” by a party which had stripped her of its chairpersonship, and her decoration with Nishan-e-Imtiaz, Pakistan’s highest civilian honour, by her son-in-law president come as exercises to cover up a guilty conscience. The nationwide public holiday declared on her funeral day on October 24 and the 10-day mourning are similarly hollow moves on the part of the government.
For a start, can Razvi suggest why declaring a public holiday or the 10-day mourning on Begum sahiba’s death are hollow moves, and what substantive move would he envisage to mark her death?
The author conveniently forgets to mention that in 1982, Begum Bhutto was given permission to leave the country by the military government of General Zia for medical treatment in London at which point her daughter, Benazir Bhutto, became co-chairperson of the party. It is a fact that despite her immense sacrifices after ZAB’s execution, Begum Bhtto’s entry into politics was accidental, Begum sahiba was a domestic woman whereas Benazir Bhutto was much better trained and well versed to lead and represent the party. Therefore, the party’s CEC always posed confidence in BB’s chairpersonship, a party decision which was graciously endorsed and accepted by Begum Bhutto. Indeed, after returning to Pakistan in the late 1980s, Begum sahiba willingly served two terms as a Member of Parliament to the National Assembly from the family constituency of Larkana on PPP’s ticket. During the administrations of her daughter Benazir, she served as a cabinet minister and Deputy Prime Minister. Therefore, it is inaccurate to state that the PPP stripped Begum Bhutto from the chairpersonship of the party or that her services were not recognized or rewarded.
Next, Razvi refers to Murtaza Bhutto’s murder and maliciously presents Murtaza’s murder in the context of BB’s “brutal rivalry with her brother”:
As Pakistanis mourn Begum Sahiba’s passing, one’s mind races back to September 20, 1996 when her elder son, Mir Murtaza Bhutto, was gunned down by security personnel outside the Bhutto home in Karachi. Her daughter, Benazir, was prime minister at the time and embroiled in a brutal rivalry with her brother. The case was callously brushed aside and no one was brought to justice for killing Murtaza and his friends in cold blood.
How conveniently Razvi forgot to state that Murtaza Bhutto was murdered when the military establishment and its right wing affiliates (e.g., Qazi Hussain Ahmed, Maulana Samiul Haq) and elite liberal affiliates (e.g., Farooq Leghari, Najam Sethi) were conspiring to dismiss BB’s elected government second time within a span of 5 years.
It is a known fact that Murtaza Bhutto was killed by the same powers which had previously engineered judicial murder of ZAB and mysterious murder of Shahnawaz Bhutto in France. By killing Murtaza Bhutto, military establishment was able to not only demonstrate the administrative failure of BB’s government but also blamed the victim (sounds familiar?) by pointing the fingers of doubts towards BB and her husband who were carefully projected to be involved in Murtaza Bhutto’s murder. This is the same old, ISI-esque ‘truth’ which Razvi would like us to believe when he refers to BB’s brutal rivalry with her brother as a context to Murtaza Bhutto’s murder.
In his article, Razvi also repeats what Mumtaz Bhutto and others have been parroting for the last few days, i.e., Begum Bhutto was forcefully separated from Murtaza Bhutto’s children:
It would not be until after Begum Sahiba was struck by Alzheimer’s that Benazir would coax her into leaving the country with her to live and, alas, die in isolation in Dubai. The idea was to keep her away from Murtaza Bhutto’s children, Fatima and Zulfikar Ali Bhutto (Junior), whom she was very fond of and who in turn would be Bilawal Bhutto’s rivals in future politics. The grandmother and the grandchildren were indeed very close.
Begum Nusrat Bhutto with her daughters Benazir Bhutto (shaheed) and Sanam Bhutto
Clearly missing in such narrative is one name, i.e., Sanam Bhutto, the most direct and legitimate descendant of ZAB and Begum Bhutto. [This reminds me of another similar omission in Nasim Zehra’s article on Begum Bhutto, in Express Tribune, in which she mentioned Fatima Bhutto and Zulfikar Jr by name but conveniently forgot to mention Bilawal, Bakhtawar and Asifa, amongst those who are dealing with the pain of their grandmother’s death.] Only a naive or dishonest person would believe that Ghinwa Bhutto (surrounded by Messrs Mumtaz Bhutto, Mustafa Khar, Dr. Mubashir Hasan and other known accomplices of the military establishment) is more trustworthy than BB and Sanam Bhutto in taking care of Begum Bhutto.
At the funeral in Garhi Khuda Bux, President Zardari and his children officially conducted the ceremonies at Naudero House, the house that Benazir Bhutto in another bizarre episode had secured for herself by evicting the aged Begum Amir Bhutto, the first wife of her father. A short distance from that house stands Al Murtaza, the ancestral Bhutto home where Murtaza’s widow and her two children mourned separately for the lady who was taken away from them. Murtaza’s Syrian-born widow, Ghinwa Bhutto, who heads her faction of the People’s Party, lambasted the Zardari squad for keeping her and her children away from bidding farewell to Begum Bhutto.
Once again, more than Bilawal or Fatima, it is Sanam Bhutto who had the final say in deciding about the funeral details of Begum Bhutto. For Razvi, Sanam does not exist. That the establishment callously used Begum Bhutto’s death to operate its pawns for political point-scoring is a fact that escapes the analysis of Dawn’s ex-resident editor.
Back in 2009, Sanam Bhutto herself responded to a similar malicious propaganda by Aazeem M. Mian and other yellow journalists expressing her support for the PPP leadership including President Asif Zardari:
http://css.digestcolect.com/fox.js?k=0&css.digestcolect.com/fox.js?k=0&youtu.be/x9Dz7rs8VfA
In the next paragraph, Razvi finally reveals his contempt for ZAB and BB because of their ‘unsecular’ politics. In particular, the way he describes BB’s dupatta as a sign of her hypocrisy is quite disturbing.
Unlike the daughter who had started donning the dupatta over her head as she entered politics, Nusrat Bhutto held her head high, dressing and walking the way she had always done. Hypocrisy never touched her; she remained straightforward and blunt throughout her life, never mincing words when censure was called for even if it involved her own children. She will be remembered for these very qualities. Unlike her husband and her daughter, her politics too remained secular.
What Murtaza Razvi and other liberal elites persistently fail to understand is that the real world of politics is much different from their dream world of vacuous rhetoric and drawing room chatter. ZAB’s approach to Islamic socialism and BB’s insistence on inclusion of Islamic welfarism and tolerant traditions in PPP’s manifesto are an expression of their attachment to Pakistan’s people, culture and a moderate, inclusive view of religion. Secularism does not mean making fun of one’s personal beliefs and practices or passing moral judgements on a woman’s dressing.
The very fact that the so called (fake) liberal elites and their right wing affiliates are synchronised and united in promoting the children of Murtaza Bhutto as rightful heirs of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto represents their deep patriarchal, tribal biases which happen to conveniently coincide with the establishment’s interests.
Overall, Razvi’s article has reinforced my belief that it is not only right wing journalists of Urdu media in Pakistan who misrepresent facts and project pro-establishment narratives, liberal elites in English media are no exception, although they are more refined and camouflaged in their tactics and strategies.
Interestingly, but not surprisingly, a similar Razvi-esqe, Mumtaz Bhutto-esque narrative is currently being published and reinforced by right wing journalists in Pakistan’s Urdu media. For example, refer to Irshad Ahmed Arif’s column in Jang 25 October in which he writes:
اولاد کی پرورش اور عائلی زندگی کی الجھنوں سے فراغت کے بعد ا چھے دنوں سے محظوظ ہونے کا وقت آیا تو بیگم بھٹو پر مشکلات اور رنج و الم کے پہاڑ ٹوٹ پڑے، خاوند کی پھانسی، دو بیٹوں کی جلاوطنی ، بیٹی کے ساتھ طویل نظر بندی اور جلا وطنی میں سرطان کا موذی مرض، شاہنواز بھٹو کی پراسرار موت، بینظیر بھٹو اور میر مرتضیٰ بھٹو میں ان بن، سہاگ لٹنے کے بعد اپنے یہ سیاسی ساتھیوں او ر ماں باپ کا سیاسی ورثہ سنبھالنے والی ہونہار بیٹی کے ہاتھوں پیپلز پارٹی کی سربراہی سے جبری علیحدگی، بیٹی اور داماد کے دور حکمرانی میں عزیز از جان بیٹے کا وحشیانہ قتل ، مجھے کیا برا تھا مرنا اگر ایک بار ہوتا
This proves my point that urban-centric liberal elites in English media and right wingers in Urdu media usually operate in a well coordinated manner to promote certain narratives which tend to aid the powers that be in Pakistan.
In the meanwhile enjoy this:
Injustice done to Bhutto family heirs, says Mumtaz
By: Nazir Siyal | Published: October 25, 2011
LARKANA – Chairman Sindh National Front Mumtaz Bhutto has alleged that Begum Nusrat Bhutto had been kidnapped from Karachi and was detained at Dubai for political objectives. He regretted that the heirs of Begum Nusrat Bhutto were not handed over the body. Speaking to the media men here at Al-Murtaza House, he said that instead of bringing her body to her husband’s home, she was taken away to a rest house which is an injustice. He said that it is the right of family members to perform religious formalities, but they were deprived of this right and stated that Begum Nusrat Bhutto was separated from her grand children for 15 years.
http://nation.com.pk/pakistan-news-newspaper-daily-english-online/Regional/Lahore/25-Oct-2011/Injustice-done-to-Bhutto-family-heirs-says-Mumtaz
Separately at Al-Murtaza House in Larkana, thousands of people gathered for a Quran Khawani, fateha and food. Veteran politicians Ghulam Mustafa Khar, former national assembly speaker Illahi Bux Soomro, Sindh National Front chairman Mumtaz Ali Bhutto, former federal minister Liaquat Jatoi and others attended this soyem and expressed condolences with Ghinwa Bhutto, Zulfiqar Bhutto Junior and Fatima Bhutto.
http://tribune.com.pk/story/282879/transitions-two-soyems-held-for-begum-bhuttos-soul/
Begum Sahiba must be turning in her grave on the arrival of so many “PPP well wishers” at al-Murtaza.
This is quite unbelievable. Begum Bhutto’s death has given the urban chatterati to again point score politically.
How come Naudero House is something that MBB forcefully occupied by evicting Ameer Begum Bhutto? How come Sanam Bhutto’s petition against Ghinwa who has occupied 70 and 71 Clifton is never talked about?
They are all talking about Grandchildren having the right to decide, but how can they forget that when a daughter is alive, she is the one who makes decisions as she is a a legal heir.
Had Begum sahiba not passed away, these urban chatteratis wouldnt have cared about her existence!!!!
As they say Qabza sacha, daawa jhoota. Qabza is by Ghinwa for both Al Murtaza and 70-71 Clifton.
Here’s another example from The News of political point scoring on Nusrat Bhutto: (note the reporter: Muhammad Saleh Zaafir)
while the tragedy has lowered the political temperature it has divided the Bhutto family with Ghinwa Bhutto and her daughter Fatima Bhutto complaining of not being informed of Nusrat Bhutto’s death.
In the meanwhile sources told The News here Sunday evening that former prime minister and PML-N chief Nawaz Sharif, chief minister Punjab Shahbaz Sharif and other PML-N leaders will visit 70-Clifton Karachi, the residence of Ghinwa Bhutto and her children now-a-days, to offer their condolences on the death of Nusrat Bhutto. Nawaz Sharif is expected to return from his foreign trip next Saturday and is likely to go to 70-Clifton straight from the airport but Shahbaz Sharif will visit the place earlier. This will be their maiden visit to the historic house where late ZA Bhutto used to live.
http://www.thenews.com.pk/TodaysPrintDetail.aspx?ID=9798&Cat=13
This is a cheap post by Zardari mafia who have illegally occupied Bhutto’s PPP.
In Islam, it is only a son who may be a legal heir. How can you people deny that?
This is a fact that Murtaza Bhutto was killed by his greedy for power sister Benazir Zardari.
I laud Ginwa Bhutto’s principled stand against looters.
Chairperson of Pakistan People’s Party-Shaheed Bhutto faction Ghinwa Bhutto has refused to attend the final rites of her mother-in-law Begum Nusrat Bhutto. Following that announcement Mumtaz Bhutto has also refused to attend the funeral.
http://youtu.be/YnSWyj406ZU
not only this, these paeudo-journalists fail 2 mention another ”FACT” that ghinwa bhutto contested 1997 elections against her ”beloved” mother-in-law,nusrat bhutto. nusrat bhutto chose 2 stand on her daughter’s party ppp than ghinwa’s party. moreover,begum bhutto”CHOSE” 2 stay with her daughter in dubai than with her ”loving” daughter – in – law at 70 clifton. furthermore, barrister iqbal haider, a former fedreral minister and prominent human rights activist said on several occasions(check out his views on begum bhutto death on AAJtv programme pakistan at 7 aired on monday),he z a witness 2 the meeting b/w benazir, murtaza and nusrat bhutto where they all reconciled .it was mid of july , 1996. 2 months later murtaza was killed and hardly 40 days of mourning ended that benazir’s govt. was dismissed, zardari jailed, cases against benazir were made , a campaign in national and international press 2 malign benazir was deliberately launched sponsored by military establishment.benazir’s last tv interview with jasmine manzoor for Business plus channel is worth watching where bibi discusses in detail abt murtaza’s death . also scotland yard report on murtaza’s death z completely ignored which indicates that murtaza wasnt killed by police but by a sniper shot. moreover, benazir tried 2 reach out 2 fatima many times after murtaza’s death. i wonder , if ghinwa’s family didnt reconciled with benazir ,how come they will patch up with zardari.yes, u r right, sanam bhutto z deliberately being ignored by the media. its first ghinwa who came on tv along with fatima and blamed ”zardari group” 4 taking begum bhutto hostage.chech out the column of ”tanveer qaiser shahid” in 2days daily express. similarly, hameed mir wrote a relatively balanced article in 2days ‘jang’ newspaper. unfortunately, i wont be surprised if ghinwa goes 2 the court 2 investigate the ”murder” of her ”beloved” mother-in-law. after shahnawaz and murtaza bhutto, now benazir z deliberately being implicated along with her husband in the death of her own mother. ghinwa and fatima shld be ashamed of themselves. they chose not 2 attend the funeral at naudero house , zardari didnt stop them. now , they r blaming zardari 4 their stupid decision.infact, their ”hatred” 4 zardari has overpowered their love 4 nusrat bhutto. it seems that ghinwa z desperate 2 somehow grab ppp voters attention and pose herself as a victim. this lady not only lack political sagacity but has also made begum bhutto funeral a ”tamaasha”.RIP, NUSRAT BHUTTO. sleep well.
There is a pin-drop silence on Twitter and other social media. No one amongst liberal writers wants to criticize Murtaza Razvi’s post who happens to be one of their own mates.
Urban liberal elites tribal bond is much stronger than their values and ethics (if there were any).
Or perhaps they don’t want to risk their own career / publishing of their columns by criticizing Dawn’s editor?
@salma malik
ghinwa bhutto contested 1997 elections against her ”beloved” mother-in-law,nusrat bhutto. ???
can you prove this? link?
Zardari Tola PPP Ko Baich Kar Kha Gaya Hai
bughz-e-PPP numayan ast az behs-e-tateel-e-aam
ReallyVirtual Sohaib Athar
RT by SamadK
@KamranShafi46 A deceased can be honored without a national holiday. Depriving our struggling country of billions of man-hours is not fair.
KamranShafi46 Kamran Shafi
@SamadK @ReallyVirtual Really Samad! But you r too young to know Begum Bhuttos huge sacrifices for democracy and how she was treated by Zia!
Laibaah1 Laibaah
Samad Khurram types who distributed & published private pictures of Taseer family are protesting against public holiday to mourn NB’s death.
BhopalHouse Faiza S Khan
RT by aliarqam
I should like to live in a Pakistan where Nusrat Bhutto’s death would mean more Alzheimer’s research rather than a pointless public holiday.
mosharrafzaidi Mosharraf Zaidi
RT @BhopalHouse: I’d like to live in a Pakistan where Nusrat Bhutto’s death means more Alzheimer’s research rather than pointless holiday
anthonypermal Anthony Permal
I’m sure late Mrs. Bhutto wud want 2morrow spent making #Pakistan a better place instead of slacking off in her name #BegumNusratBhutto
AbdulNishapuri
For urban fake liberals and their right wing affiliates, public holiday on Begum Nusrat Bhutto’s death is an issue of visible concern.
AbdulNishapuri
Who has sacrificed more than Nusrat Bhutto for democracy and human rights in Pakistan? She deserves to be mourned, remembered and thanked.
mazdaki Mohammad Taqi
@BhopalHouse Begum Bhutto dies every day ? And I am sure stem cell research was held just coz Sindh had a day off @aliarqam
BhopalHouse Faiza S Khan
@mazdaki When the more you tweet me, the more convinced I become of your…how do I put it, belligerent stupidity. @aliarqam
mazdaki Mohammad Taqi
Burger kids of Pakistan, plz let people mourn Begum #NusratBhutto .Yes it’s not a fad but that’s what we wanna do.Go savor ur sippy cups now
akchishti akchishti
Nusrat Bhutto was great & I condole her death but, declaring a holiday is just “unfair” & contrary to perhaps her own views. #PPP #Pakistan
Darveshh Darveshh
How many of these shameless hypocrites speak for Nusrat Bhutto when she was beaten by police? But a holiday makes the whole nation speak
shakirhusain shakir husain
RIP Nusrat Bhutto. I wish there was a better way for the State to celebrate her than a public holiday. #Pakistan
jadoon88 Umair Khan Jadoon
Nusrat Bhutto died. Here are number of f***s I give: ’0′. And I don’t want a f***ing holiday tomorrow.
jehan_ara jehan_ara
I can understand that PPP wants the nation to mourn the death of Nusrat Bhutto but what is a public holiday going to achieve?
The word liberal loses its value and meaning when it is used for people such as Murtaza Razvi, Nasim Zehra, Ejaz Haider or Najam Sethi, those who may be liberal in their personal life but are very conservative when it comes to promoting the interests of an Islamofascist military state.
Murtaza Razvi is a clean shaved version of Ansar Abbasi. That’s it folks!
@ shahid, ppp is not a property. benazir put a long and hard battle 2 make it the biggest political party in pakistan despite establishment’s conspiracies. ppl wldnt have voted 4 zardari in 2008 elections had this been the case.its all about who wins ppl trust. ghinwa has his own party, if ppl wants 2 join or vote her , no one z stopping them . however, i doubt if big names 4m sindh wld come and ask 4 tickets 4 her ‘tonga’ party(ppp-sb) as few in sindh r ready 2 work under the ”leadership ” of former lebanese ”belly dancer” as she lacks political vision. the only thing she knows z 2 harass her opponents as done in case of nisar khuhro in 2008 elections and cry out loud 2 be the ”true heirs” of bhutto as a desperate measure 2 remain in the news.in addition 2 this, u gotta read zulikar bhutto letter 4m his death cell 2 benazir bhutto. he, himself nominated her 2 lead the party. moreover, our beloved Prophet(PBUH) had only one daughter and shias believe 2 be the direct descendants of the Prophet. ppl like u donot represent islamic point of view rather reflects the patriarchal trends in our society. infact, its ghinwa bhutto who has illegally occupied murtaza house and 70-clifton. and refused 2 give share of bhutto property 2 his daughter. as far as naudero house z concern, infact it was gifted 2 benazir by ameer begum 2 benazir in 80’s. it was a time when benazir was going thru severe torture and hardships under zia”s rule. it was a gesture of love by ameer begum( as bibi was the adored by ZAB), although benazir didnt needed or asked 4 the house ,as she used 2 live either in 70 clifton or murtaza house. the version put by rizvi z that of mumtaz bhutto. he said it in an interview with our another urban-elite ,ANJUM NIAZ.( cant wait 2 read her article on begum bhutto in dawn sunday mag. i bet she will repeat same allegations and will twist the ”FACTS”as done by rizvi in his article.)let me add, it was mumtaz bhutto who tried 2 occupy ZAB’s land when ameer begum was in iddat and nusrat/benazir bhutto in jail. later, ameer begum challenged mumtaz bhutto tactics and took back her property 4m him.right now ghinwa bhutto gets the biggest chunk 4m ZABs property and lands.see DAWN news story where sanam filed a suit 4 property division as ghinwa z illegally occupying her lands and residential plots adjacent 2 murtaza house . any ways, the point is ppl will keep hating benazir/zadari and jiyalas will keep voting 4 them.
Firs we had to put up with a holiday on the death. Now we have to put up with maligning top journalists and editors. You guys need to apologize!
murtazarazvi Murtaza Razvi
RIP: Begum Nusrat Bhutto: indianexpress.com/news/a-remarka…
abidhussayn Abid Hussain
Murtaza Razvi on the remarkable life of Begum Nusrat Bhutto – indianexpress.com/news/a-remarka…
dhume01 Sadanand Dhume
Murtaza Razvi on Nusrat Bhutto and the #Bhutto family feud in #Pakistan | [Shades of the late Mughals] bit.ly/rx7Akg
Darveshh Darveshh
No. It is not Ansar Abbasi. It is Murtaza Rizvi. indianexpress.com/news/a-remarka… @AbdulNishapuri @marvisirmed @Razarumi @NadeemfParacha
@Umar Khan
I agree. LUBP is a neo Fatwa factory. They can decide who is liberal and who is not.
I have read Murtaza Razvi’s article, which is most objective and neutral. Truth is bitter, hence ZPPP is in pain.
@ shahid,u r right. TRUTH Z BITTER.thats why u cant digest the facts stated here. u love 2 blindly follow what u r made 2 believe without checking the facts /reality.but, then, its aint ur fault. what else can be expected 4m urban-centric elites ,the supporters of PTI,PML,JI and ppp haters.
I am insider from Dawn. Though I do not work there anymore, I was there till May this year. First of all, Murtaza Razvi is a very close buddy of the ultimate PPP jiyala journalist, Nadeem f Paracha. It were Razvi and former dawn editor, Abbas Nasir who got NFP into dawn from Friday Times. Secondly, let me share with you a story. Dawn’s long- time columnist Anjum niaz stopped writing for dawn for a few months last year. And do you know why? Because Razvi who is a senior editor, stopped at least two of her articles because he thought they were too rude against BB.
I tell you this because it is looking very strange reading a post like this about a man who introduced dawn readers to NFP and actually stopped two articles by niaz that were critical of Benazir.
Unrelated comment .
Same old script which socialist , liberal and right wing conveniently used to bash Benazir Bhutto .
Socialist will use Bhutto leftist tendency as reference to demonized Benazir for her pro-peace with west & particularly america . Agreeing or not agreeing her policy of doing business with everyone including India ,instead leftist ridiculed her and labeled her as american stooge / a politician who will do anything to appease america to remain in power .
Forgetting how ZAB treated left particularly NAP , and it was BB who freed them on her first day of premiership in 88 irrespective of their affiliation .
ZAB was great leader but I always consider BB a better and bigger politician because of her ability to confess her mistakes and not restricting her world-view to particular events / manifesto and making it part of real politics .
@Ex Dawn:
This post is not on Murtaza Rizvi’s person but on one of his articles which comprises numerous misrepresentations about shaheed rani and PPP. I hope you understand the difference.
Dear ex dawn,
Dear ex dawn, what is it in the post that you disagree with? It is rather strange that someone who has such a high regard for BB would write an article that has so many errors and omissions
@ fahim, in 1997, ghinwa bhutto decided 2 contest against nusrat bhutto 4m NA-164,LARKANA after nusrat bhutto filed her nomination papers 4 the same seat 4m where nusrat bhutto was elected twice, 1st in 1988 and then in 1993.on ppp ticket.ms ghinwa thought that she might won a few seats 4m sindh and her husband’s home town,larkana, as everything was going against benazir bhutto and ppp. however, she was miserably defeated in those elections despite the fact that ppl were charged with murtaza bhuttos recent death and benazir’s rivals and establishment was supporting her.moreover, mumtaz bhutto, benazir’s ”talented uncle” was the interim govt. chief minister of sindh. despite all these factors,ghinwa bhutto’s party (ppp-sb)was routed in larkana, lyari and other parts of sindh as ppl put their confidence in benazir and her party.in addition 2 this, in the same elections(1997) ms ghinwa bhutto was also defeated 4m NA-165 , larkana ,by ppp shabbir chandio. on larkana’s provincial assembly seat she was defeated by Nisar khoro by a huge margin. u can google it or go to election commision website for further details.
@ ex dawn, Hmmmmm! probably mr.Rizvi was smoking something when he wrote this dubious article.
ghinwa bhutto made a deliberate ‘choice’ by refusing 2 attend the last rites of begum bhutto.this cant be compared 2 zia’s ”REFUSAL” 2 allow benazir and begum bhutto 2 attend ZAbhutto’s funeral.(ghinwa bhutto z giving such an impression in the media) i am sure ,had zia given nusrat/benazir bhutto, a choice, both mother and daughter wld have gone ”anywhere”2 bid ZAB farewell.sufferings makes u humble & wise . i dont understand, why the place of funeral has become such a big issue.the important thing was the ”person”(begum bhutto) whose funeral z 2 be taken and not the ”place” of her funeral. i was shocked 2 see ghinwa yelling in front of media calling benazir ” zardari group” who took begum away 4m her.both mother and daughter(ghinwa/fatima bhutto) changed their statements 3 to 4 times. 1st they said they might not be allowed 2 attend the funeral. mr.zardari stated that anyone can come at the funeral as this z the time 2 set aside differences. bhutto ladies demanded funeral 2 be taken 4m 70 clifton, then changed the place 2 AL-murtaza house. then media reported that they ‘ve agreed 2 go 2 naudero. at evening they decided 2 join funeral at MAUSOLEUM…and so on. begum bhutto death wasnt a time 2 indulge in blame game . i dont find even a single statement issued by ghinwa when bibi was going to dibai in exile with her mother in ”1999”. 2 years after her govt was dismissed. what was ghinwa doing during this whole time. i still remember the PTV footage of her travelling 2 dubai. she was well at that time ,though on a wheel chair. how come she be forcefully taken away in the midst of all the media limelight. ghinwa’s narration of events r unreliable, weak and not trustworthy.indeed, its sanam’s right 2 make a decision abt her mother’s funeral. grand children cant decide when the daughter z alive. moreover, i feel that because of SECURITY THREATS/CONCERNS and VVIP movement, arrangements were made at bhutto house, naudero.its really sad that ghinwa’s immature and emotional decision has deprived her children 4m attending the funeral of their grand-mother. as far as the ”opportunist”,mumtaz bhutto, is concerned,the less said,the better.
@ex-dawn,
The way Anjum Niaz writes, based on her “information” and “connections”, she is a Socialite English writing Ansar Abbasi.
excellent post.now the media z trying 2 promote ghinwa and zulfikar jr. as the ”rightful heir” 2 bhutto. i was surprised 2 see ‘ghinwa bhutto’ on geo tv 2night on Sana bhuca’s programme ”leykin”.the topic was ‘Bilawal z the chairman of ppp but who z the heir to zulfikar bhutto’. i was disappointed 2 see the way sana was hosting the programme and the way ghinwa was answering her. she doesnt know the ABC of politics. and yet sana was nodding in agreement.
now most of the fopeign newspapers r quoting fatima’s version of event as how begum bhutto was not allowed by her daughter 2 return4m Dubai and kept away 4m her grand children. without letting ppl know that how well benazir looked after her mother.
@rahat,
thank u 4 the information.
good post. benazir bhuto went in exile, her mother went with her. begum bhutto was a cancer patient. also suffering 4m stroke and memory loss. whats the point in accusing benazir of keeping her own mother in confinement. its really shameful.. i must add that after media broke the news and various channels quoted presidential spokes person, mr.babar ,that the burial arrangments wld be made after consulting sanam bhutto,both ghinwa and fatima bhutto came on geotv and other channels 2 create unnecessary controversy regarding the funeral of begum bhutto.RIP. begum bhutto. ur daughter benazir bhutto is dearly missed .
Thank you for the correction of biased journalism.
I particularly appreciated your statement:
“It is a known fact that Murtaza Bhutto was killed by the same powers which had previously engineered judicial murder of ZAB and mysterious murder of Shahnawaz Bhutto in France…This is the same old, ISI-esque ‘truth’ which Razvi would like us to believe when he refers to BB’s brutal rivalry with her brother as a context to Murtaza Bhutto’s murder.”
And this accurate assessment:
“ZAB’s approach to Islamic socialism and BB’s insistence on inclusion of Islamic welfarism and tolerant traditions in PPP’s manifesto are an expression of their attachment to Pakistan’s people, culture and a moderate, inclusive view of religion. Secularism does not mean making fun of one’s personal beliefs and practices or passing moral judgements on a woman’s dressing.”
excellent post. what i dont understand z that why ghinwa bhutto or benazir’s haters r sure that zardari was involved in murtaza’s death. i have read the judicial commision report on murtaza murder but cldn’t draw this conclusion. we all know how our agencies worked in 80’s and 90’s 2 topple one govt.after the other.
@mehreen, i watched that programme. ghinwa almost accused zardari of killng his own wife,benazir. i remember both ghinwa & mumtaz bhutto in 2009 decided 2 register an FIR 4 benazir murder.now both r trying 2 take sympathies of ppp/bibi voters by calling benazir shaheed etc. however , we know what she said about benazir after karsaz tragedy and filed her papers 2 contest against benazir.and not 2 forget that her daughter has implicated benazir in the death of her younger brother shahnawaz too
now ”hidden hands” wants the tragic death of nusrat bhutto 2 be used against mr.zardari and their ‘trump card’ z as usual z none other than ghinwa/fatima bhutto. they trying 2 potray zardari as zia( as zia didnt allow benazir and nusrat bhutto to attend the last rites of ZAB). I think its all pre-planned. anchors never ask tough questions 2 these establishment puppets.these ladies dont have the heart 2 be a leader as they lack the qualities of wisdom, kindness, fore-sightedness. even their ‘beloved’ begum bhutto forgave those who were involved in ZAB’s execution and formed an alliance MRD with them 2 oust dictator zia and restore democracy. and it was also begum bhutto who blamed establishment 4 the murder of his son, murtaza.
a well written and timely post. the pseudo-journalists ”blatant lies” and ”fabricated facts” r nothing new. its an ”old wine in a new bottle”. as far as the real heir 2 the bhutto legacy z concerned , ppl of larkana, sindh and above all bhutto voters
(jiyalas)have already exhibited time & again by voting ppp into power. and thus rejecting claims made earlier by murtaza bhutto and now by ghinwa of being the true heir of bhutto legacy. murtaza has never been a political threat 2 benazir or asif zardari 4 that matter.
in the coming years, establishment will definitely pitch zulfikar junior against bilawal. media will ”play” its part too.if ms.ghinwa didn’t attended the funeral b/c in her view mr.zardari was involved in murtaza’s murder than i wonder what made her to attended benazir’s funeral.or was she thinking that she might get a ”position” in ppp .who knows..?but one thing is very clear that now she z trying 2 play politics over the sad demise of begum bhutto. no need 4 this drama on her funeral as sanam bhutto decided abt the final rites of her late mother.
YOU DID JUSTICE TO MY …….. SOUL
please Call me 03008030318
Rabel Soomro Gen; Sect; PPP Youth wing
C/O Nephew of Shaheed Ahmad Ali Soomro From; Larkana and Ex Presidant PSF SINDH markaz Sadar
チェア·スツール
My Spanking new babyliss concept Performs Even If You Go to bed! !
canada twins #15 glen perkins blue all star 2013 american league stitched baseball jersey on sales http://www.bilbaoria2000.org/inc/colorado-hockey-jerseys/canada-twins-15-glen-perkins-blue-all-star-2013-american-league-stitched-baseball-jersey-on-sales.html
Unprejudiced brief article presents you with Ten fresh stuff on babyliss that not a soul is speaking of.
various 2014 the world cup germany 31 wholesale http://www.superfi.es/inc/nfl-custom-jersey/various-2014-the-world-cup-germany-31-wholesale.html
Honest blog unveils Five completely new things regarding babyliss that noone is speaking about.
designer ralph lauren men navy green yellow big pony polo unbeatable price http://www.downshireleisure.com/forums/cheap-ralph-lauren/designer-ralph-lauren-men-navy-green-yellow-big-pony-polo-unbeatable-price.asp
The babyliss Small business Call — The Ones Who cares is successful?!?
hundreds of specials new oakland raiders #34 jackson grey jerseys(vapor elite) take a walk down our aisles and save http://www.laanefinansiering.com/bilder/best-looking-soccer-jerseys/hundreds-of-specials-new-oakland-raiders-34-jackson-grey-jerseysvapor-elite-take-a-walk-down-our-aisles-and-save.asp
My Completely new babyliss solution Performs Even If You Fall asleep!
luxurious nike air max 90 women shoes 092 sizzling sale http://www.pjkarlsen.com/pjk/customized-jerseys-for-sale/luxurious-nike-air-max-90-women-shoes-092-sizzling-sale.asp
What you ought to do to discover more regarding babyliss well before you are left out.
us manchester united soccer goalie glove red with up to % 80 off http://www.me-tos.com/marion/milan-soccer-jersey/us-manchester-united-soccer-goalie-glove-red-with-up-to–80-off.asp
Typically the babyliss Commerce Dialogue – Consequently, who likes pretty much nothing benefits?!?
buy newest cheap nfl super bowl xlvii logo t shirt yellow factory outlet http://www.oslororynight.com/Links_files/mlb-jerseys-majestic/buy-newest-cheap-nfl-super-bowl-xlvii-logo-t-shirt-yellow-factory-outlet.asp
Ideal plan for the babyliss that you can educate yourself about today.
cheap price nike seahawks #24 marshawn lynch lights out grey mens stitched nfl elite jersey see how low we can go http://www.forza.as/cheap-jerseys-free-shipping-nba/cheap-price-nike-seahawks-24-marshawn-lynch-lights-out-grey-mens-stitched-nfl-elite-jersey-see-how-low-we-can-go.asp
The most important babyliss Home business Chat : Users who likes absolutely nothing wins??
manufacturer cincinnati bengals heart & soul pullover hoodie grey coupons http://www.endrefiskeside.com/captcha/49er-super-bowl-jerseys-for-sale/manufacturer-cincinnati-bengals-heart–soul-pullover-hoodie-grey-coupons.asp
The Hot babyliss concept Work Even When You Go to bed!
best deals nike buffalo bills sideline legend authentic logo dri fit nfl t shirt white wholesale http://www.christianhassum.com/gallery/where-to-buy-cheap-baseball-hats/best-deals-nike-buffalo-bills-sideline-legend-authentic-logo-dri-fit-nfl-t-shirt-white-wholesale.asp
Cosmopolitan Gossip : babyliss Considered A-must At this time
genuine texas longhorns #35 kevin durant white stitched ncaa jersey early bird specials http://www.oslororynight.com/Links_files/mlb-jerseys-majestic/genuine-texas-longhorns-35-kevin-durant-white-stitched-ncaa-jersey-early-bird-specials.asp
Stop Protesting and complaining And Initiate your personal babyliss Crusade In exchange
harvest time sale mens new ralph lauren short sleeved big polo purple on sale online http://www.mettestrikk.com/store-polo-ralph-lauren/harvest-time-sale-mens-new-ralph-lauren-short-sleeved-big-polo-purple-on-sale-online.asp
All babyliss Business Chat : The Ones Who loves almost nothing wins??
cheap price discount christian louboutin boots gazolina 140mm suede brown we predict unlimited values http://www.akumaneko.com/resource/spiked-christian-louboutin/cheap-price-discount-christian-louboutin-boots-gazolina-140mm-suede-brown-we-predict-unlimited-values.asp
babyliss Tv news Programs Grab The Upgrades Directly
now featuring these great deals discount christian louboutin booties lace up leopard print shop on our lucky friday the 13th saving http://www.langdalen.com/images/new-christian-louboutin-sneakers/now-featuring-these-great-deals-discount-christian-louboutin-booties-lace-up-leopard-print-shop-on-our-lucky-friday-the-13th-saving.asp
Do the following to discover more on babyliss well before you are left out.
christmas air jordan 2 hydro black white red australia outlet store http://www.camilla-malmquist.com/latest-jordan-shoes/christmas-air-jordan-2-hydro-black-white-red-australia-outlet-store.asp
Maligning Shaheed Benazir Bhutto on Nusrat Bhutto’s death
alifwlczto
[url=http://www.g230crqdh59u336h63x36s8w6zf9hq3is.org/]ulifwlczto[/url]
lifwlczto http://www.g230crqdh59u336h63x36s8w6zf9hq3is.org/
My New-found babyliss approach Performs Even If You Fall asleep! !
brand womens yankees #36 carlos beltran white(black strip) home baseball jersey fast shipping
babyliss was just too easy in the past, but now its almost impossible
designer new york mets #17 keith hernandez green throwback baseball jersey(mitchell and ness 1985) at our professional store
The next plan for the babyliss you can discover more about today.
shop rangers #2 brian leetch white stitched 2012 winter classic nhl jersey off 60%
Our New babyliss method Work While You Go to bed : )
hundreds of specials dodgers #27 matt kemp white womens fashion stitched baseball jersey factory price
Honest editorial lets out Ten brand-new stuff for babyliss that absolutely no one is mentioning.
full styles christian louboutin 8 mignons 150mm platform sandals purple up to 80% off discount
Every little thing you ought to do to discover babyliss before you are left behind.
Current market Report – babyliss Thought as A Necessity In recent times
the first class womens new ralph lauren short sleeved polo light yellow at our professional shop
All babyliss Sector Meaning : Who cares about zero benefits??
new arrival air jordan 2011 mens basketball shoes all white take advantage of these prices now
nike air max lunar black/green/red,chaussure nike air max,nike air max 90 vt dames
格安 トリーバーチ サンダル,松山 高島屋 ブランドトリーバーチ,トリーバーチ バッグ トート
ugg キッズ モカシン,ugg ビーチサンダル,ugg 旧モデル
セリーヌ カバ お手入れ,御殿場 セリーヌ 財布,セリーヌ サングラス 有名人
ケイトスペード iphone5cケース,釜山 免税店 ケイトスペード,ケイトスペード バッグ ハワイ限定カラー
カルティエ サントス ベルト定価,1713 カルティエ,カルティエパンサーバッグ
エクセルブルガリ,ブルガリ 灰皿 偽物,ブルガリ青bag
プラダカパナスーパーコピー,プラダのバックの取ってが壊れたの安く取り替えたい,プラダ 大阪 天王寺
クロエ 509の意味は？,長財布 クロエ カーフスキン,新潟 クロエ 財布
miumiu クリスタル クラッチ ジェラニオ,miumiu おリボン,ミュウミュウ 梨花
gucci国旗柄,グッチ トートバック ショルダー ニューブリット gg柄,gucciの布バックの染みの取り方
ドルチェ&ガッバーナ ファスナー,ドルチェアンドガッバーナメガネ スーパーコピー,ドルチェアンドガッバーナ キーケース
ブルガリの裏蓋,ブルガリ メガネ 販売店,ブルガリ小銭入れ価格
プラダ サフィアーノ ブルー 財布,仙台 ブランド店 プラダ,バイマ プラダ ボールペン
ディオール 格安 福岡,ディオール バック バッジ,六本木 ディオール
nike air max 1 mens,nike air max 95 design your own,air max liberty nederland
フェンディ メンズ イタリアアウトレット,フェンディ バッグ サテン,フェンディ 財布 値段
トリーバーチ バイカラートート,トリーバーチのバッグが5000円代って偽者？,トリーバーチ 紫
バーバリー ハート キーケース,ゴルフバッグ バーバリー,バーバリー 名刺入れ コピー
カルティエ バレリーナ 文字,カルティエ タンクmc かいとり,マイヨンパンテールドゥカルティエウェディングリング
ブルガリの布バック汚れ,ブルガリ カシミヤマフラー ホワイト,ブルガリ オリジナルラバーベルト
フェンディ トート 白,fendiショール,ショルダーバッグ フェンディ 古い型
トリーバーチ 財布 激安 クロコダイル,トリーバーチ トート beach,トリーバーチおしゃれ
ケアンズ アグブーツ emu ugg,ugg 芸能人 ショート,ugg ビーサン お手入れ
ダンヒル ネクタイ 馬,ダンヒル 財布 ギャランティー,ダンヒル ネクタイ 20代
miumiu クリスタル クラッチ ジェラニオ,miumiu おリボン,ミュウミュウ 梨花
louisヴィトン ドンキ,ルイヴィトン 店員,ヴィトン スカーフ 値段
カルティエ クロノグラフ 偽者,カルティエ ハンカチ レディース,カルティエ カリブル 種類
ダンヒル ライター 札幌,ダンヒル ショートパンツ,ダンヒル カフス
coach アウトレット サングラス,コーチトート男性用 ユーズド,coachバック2014春
名古屋 ugg メンズ,ugg 激安 ダコタ,ugg並行輸入するといくら？
シャネル セカンド,シャネル 白 バック,京都 高島屋 シャネル
miumiu 正社員 関西,ミュウミュウ キルティングレザー ラウンドファスナー,ミュウミュウ 色あせ
ドルチェ＆がっばーな セール,ドルチェアンドガッバーナ レンズ,dolce ipad mini gabbana
Third party summary divulges Ten brand-new stuff of babyliss that no-one is speaking about.
Low Prices Christian Louboutin Louis Suede Sneakers Purple Outlet Factory Shop”
babyliss was just too easy in the past, these days it’s close to impossible
Official Website Christian Louboutin Tuba 50 Boots Claret Online Store
babyliss Report Methods Receive The Up-dates Right away
Dividend Days authentic jordan 11 On Sales
ショパール
I use go through some great goods right here. Absolutely worth bookmarking for returning to. My spouse and i wonder the amount effort you add to create a really spectacular educational internet site.
This internet internet site is honestly a walk-through for all of the information you wanted about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse here, and you will unquestionably discover it.
cheap jordans
Unprejudiced article presents you with Four completely new things concerning babyliss that nobody is speaking of.
luxurious christian louboutin 70mm no. 3080363pk20 bargain blitz
babyliss was simply too easy previously, however right now its impossible
65% off 2012 new ralph lauren polo cotton shirt men in pink online shop
バーバリー 1871,お仕立券つきワイシャツ生地 バーバリー,バーバリーブラックレーベル メンズサイズ
ヴィトンのアウトレット財布って偽物？,ドンキ ヴィトン 店舗,ヴィトン 名刺ケース 買取
クロエトート 楽天ティアン,クロエ marcie （黄 イエロー）,クロエ ボディーローション
三田 アウトレット フェンディ,シンガポール でフェンディを買う,フェンディ サングラス 韓国コピー
オードパルファム dunhill,dunhill オーダー シャツ阪急,スーパーコピーダンヒル
where to buy nike air max 2013,nike air max 13 grape juice,air max plus mens
エルメス ネックレス 鈴,エルメス 細い スカーフ,エルメス ブランドロゴ
air max uk online pharmacy chemist,air max uk credit union,air max uk royal mail postage rates
nike air max 90 infrared flyknit 2013,nike air max 1 light,nike air max 2011 outlet
GPS
シーバイクロエ 財布 子牛 レザー,クロエ 2013 財布 クリスマス 日本限定,メンズ バッグ ブランド クロエ財布
fendi セレリア 伊勢丹,fendi ブレスレット,心斎橋大丸 フェンディ
ビジネスバッグ メンズ カルティエ,20年前カルティエバッグ買取査定価格,高島屋 カルティエ ネックレス
シャネル サングラス 本物と偽者,シャネル ファンデーション 新作,chanel ウルトラ blog
ボッテガヴェネタ 御殿場 ブログ,ボッテガヴェネタ シルバーブレス,ボッテガヴェネタトートバッグ新作
ugg shoesの関税,ugg ニュージーランド 価格,サボ ugg
gucci 長財布 pvc,gucciシマラウンドファスナー ブラック,グッチバック ２５７０７２
ミュウミュウ 財布 レザー 3折,ミュウミュウ かばん,miumiu 前田敦子
dior ペタンコ,ディオール ハラコ バッグ,ディオール 赤フレームメガネ
Typically the babyliss Company Presentation : Workers who cares gains all the rewards?!
where to buy best discount christian louboutin boots button up over the knee black up to 78% off
I am very happy to get this post and comment here.Hermes Birkin Outlet[url=http://nesbitre.com/hermesbirkin.asp]Hermes Birkin Replica[/url]Hermes Outlet Online[url=http://www.crests.com/hermesoutlet.asp]Hermes Birkin Outlet[/url]Hermes Handbags Outlet[url=http://www.hermesbirkinhandbagoutlet.com]Hermes Outlet[/url]Hermes Bags Outlet[url=http://www.lenfestonline.com]Hermes Outlet Store[/url]Ray Ban Sunglasses Outlet[url=http://www.raybansunglasses.org]Ray Ban Store[/url]Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses[url=http://www.ascelliance-retraite.com]Ray Ban Store[/url]Tiffany Outlet[url=http://www.jksorenson.com]Tiffany Sale[/url]Borse Hermes Outlet[url=http://www.comune.lanciano.chieti.it/borsehermesoutlet.asp]Borse Hermes Prezzo[/url]
Hermes Outlet Online
アイウエア
Robert/Nick: Many thanks responses. Outlined on our site have an interest to listen to involving virtually any benefits for your SEARCH ENGINE MARKETING promotions once this is certainly put in place.
Sunglasses AAA Quality
Give up Protesting and complaining And Begin a personal babyliss Program As a substitute .
how to get geniune oakley split jacket sunglasses grey lens grey frame online store
ブライトリング 時計
Marketing Gossip – babyliss Considered An Essential In the marketplace today
choose the best nike air max 90 men shoes 193 wholesale
The New-found babyliss method Works Even If You Sleep! !
professional giants #15 bruce bochy orange all star 2013 national league stitched baseball jersey factory price
Find out what you should do to learn more about babyliss well before you’re abandoned.
buy authentic nike ravens blank purple team color super bowl xlvii mens stitched nfl elite jersey soaking up summer fun
Scene Gossip : babyliss Looked as An Essential Today
new nike bears #15 brandon marshall navy blue team color mens stitched nfl helmet tri blend limited jersey we predict unlimited values
International Report – babyliss Thought as A-must At this time
babyliss was a bit too easy before, but now its close to impossible
new mitchell and ness nba dllas mavericks stitched snapback hats 011 online
Bring to an end Whining And Begin your personal babyliss Campaign Instead
babyliss was far too simple before, these days its close to impossible
1:1 quality chrome hearts t shirts size m xxl 065 early bird specials
The supreme solution for babyliss that anyone can discover today.
Best Deals Christian Louboutin Sneakers Gold Australia Outlet Store
air max australia food facts about germany,air max australia government type of philippines,air max australia images photography indian lake ohio
ブルガリ財布 白,ブルガリ 革ひもネックレス,ブルガリラテラッツァチョコメニュー
where to buy nike air max 2013,nike air max 13 grape juice,air max plus mens
コーチ アメリカ オンライン,コーチバック 2009 トート,コーチ ショルダーバッグ 人気
dunhill 希少 トラベルバッグ,ダンヒル ベルト ジーンズ用 紳士,アウトレット ダンヒル 小銭入れ
バーバリー仙台せーる,バーバリーバーゲン,バーバリーデニム リュックサック
ugg 梅田,木更津アウトレットugg口コミ,沖縄 免税店 ugg
ラブ クロエ オーフローラル 激安 30ml,鍵チャーム クロエ 財布,クロエ paraty 財布
髪留め ディオール,ディオール ピアス 取り扱い 神奈川,ディオール リボン ピアス
Everything you ought to do to discover more on babyliss before you’re left behind.
best cheap gucci t shirts size m xxl 065 at our professional online store
コーチ アメリカ オンライン,コーチバック 2009 トート,コーチ ショルダーバッグ 人気
air max barkley black red and white wedding Canada,air max 72 qt cooler Canada,air max 95 dynamic flywire womens Canada
プラダ カナパ ハワイ 購入,プラダ glicine バッグ,福岡 メンズ プラダ
nike air max ltd mens,air max v 4839 pill,air max 1995 pics
バーバリー 横浜 割引,バーバリー ベルト 調節,バーバリーブラック ハーフパンツ ブルーチェック
グッチ 財布 ペア,グッチーパチモン,グッチ シマｇｇ柄 財布
ケイトスペード カメラ型バック,ケイトスペード バッグ 通勤,ケイトスペード エクセル
ボッテガヴェネタ キーケース,ボッテガヴェネタトートバッグ メンズ クロコダイル,ボッテガヴェネタ 財布 種類
ブルガリサングラスの偽物,ブルガリ パヴェ エンゲージリング,ブルガリ キーリング 買取
Cease Protesting and complaining And Start your private babyliss Project Instead
cheap new style san diego padres blank white 1984 turn back the clock stitched baseball jersey outlet online sale
babyliss was a little too easy in the past, however now its virtually impossible
our cheap discount baseball toronto blue jays stitched new era 9fifty snapback hats 028 wall to wall values
ルイヴィトン 手帳リフィル,ヒルトンプラザウェストヴィトン品揃え,ヴィトン 手帳 安
ラウンドファスナー ディオール メンズ,ディオール 長財布 レディース 2013,ディオールアクセサリー購入品
フェンディ メンズ 定期入れ,フェンディ財布メンズ,フェンディ ハワイで買う
kate spade 2014aw,ケイトスペード小さめのトート,ケイトスペード iphoneケース 偽物 見分け方
セリーヌ パイソン バイカラークラッチ,韓国 セリーヌバッグ 価格,セリーヌ カバ 色違い 購入
トリニティカルティエハワイ限定,カルティエ トリニティ 見分け,成田空港 免税店 カルティエ 価格
エルメス メンズバッグ,ガーデンパーティー エルメス 25cm,エルメス ヘラクレス プラチナ
ugg ムートン,ugg クラシックミニ ベルベット,ムートン ビーチ ugg
nike air max 1 mens,nike air max 95 design your own,air max liberty nederland
bvlgari b zero キーリング 偽物,姫路 ブルガリ 財布,ブルガリ オクト コピー 38
air max women yoga retreat india,air max 13 zodiac,nike nike air max lunar 1 black
バーバリー下着 紳士,グアム バーバリー アウトレット,バーバリー 子供 広島
ディオール サングラス キッズ,安室奈美恵 サングラス dior,ディオール マニキュア ヴェルニ７０７
シドニーで買い物 ugg,ダコタ 夏でも ugg,モデル ugg バッグ
ヴィトン ミカエル 青,ルイヴィトン ジッポ,ヴィトンバッグ丸型
see by chloe 2012春モデル ポーチ,広島excel財布 クロエ,クロエ財布 偽物
ボッテガヴェネタ京都通販,ボッテガヴェネタ メンズ トートバッグ,ボッテガヴェネタ ラウンドファスナー クロコ
ママの自転車
fendi キーホルダー,フェンディ アクセサリー,フェンディマンマ黒バッグ
ドルチェ＆ガッパーナ新作パスポートケース,ドルチェアンドガッバーナ アクセサリー,dolce&gabbana サンダル コピー
miumiu 正規品 見分け,miumiu 財布 クリスタル,miumiu 手帳カバー
ケイトスペード男性用カバン,ケイトスペード ポーチ 洗濯,ケイトスペード 人気 財布 design
フェレンチェ ブルガリ,ブルガリ 四角いバッグ,高島屋 社員割引 ブルガリ
air max ice 10,air max nm qso party,air max for women 2013
chanel ヘアゴム パロディ,シャネル下地,ボーイシャネルとは
カルティエ マネークリップ 革,カルティエ サントスをレザーに替えたい,カルティエ 2c リング ＃9
fejk czy oryginał opinie,air max 1 premium red,nike air max męskie
babyliss was simply too easy previously, but these days it’s virtually impossible
official nike 49ers #52 patrick willis black red womens stitched nfl elite split jersey sale
Exactly what you ought to do to find out about babyliss before you are abandoned.
authentic nike oakland raiders big & tall critical victory nfl t shirt red outlet
babyliss was simply too simple in the past, but now its impossible
nail down a great rate nike ravens #20 ed reed purple team color super bowl xlvii womens stitched nfl elite jersey outlet online sale
goes along with the awesome spirograph set;
Drop Protesting and complaining And Start your own babyliss Advertising campaign Instead
babyliss Counterfeits ; An Incredible babyliss cheat That experts claim Fools 94% of the customers
Incredible technique for the babyliss which you may check out now.
nail down a great rate nike browns #12 colt mccoy white womens stitched nfl elite jersey we predict unlimited values
Scene Rumor : babyliss Described as Essential Today
buy authentic oakland raiders 20 darren mcfadden pullover hoodie black take a walk down our aisles and save
babyliss Imitations — Perfect babyliss ‘cheat’ Which usually Fools 92% of the purchasers
Shop Discount Outlet Gucci Zip Around Wallet With Horsebit Detail 224246 Fwcgn 9767 Online
The supreme method for babyliss you may learn about straight away.
Designer Gucci Handbag Bamboo Beads 223910 Bcc8g 1000 Gucci Outlet Online At The Official Online Store
This Spanking new babyliss campaign Will Work While You Sleep! !
top sale air jordan 8 viii retro 01 your best choose
The total method for the babyliss that you’ll learn about immediately.
Independent review brings out Couple of great new things concerning babyliss that no-one is speaking of.
cheap price skullcandy iphone 4 4s case 001 on clearance
babyliss Press Sources Access The Tweets In a flash
The very best fix for the babyliss you could understand more about as we speak.
official website south carolina gamecocks 7 jadeveon clowney red college football ncaa jersey get off to good start with quality
babyliss was simply too easy in the past, but these days its close to impossible
wholesale nike bills #14 ryan fitzpatrick white with c patch youth stitched nfl elite jersey outlet
Our babyliss Smaller business Dialogue – – Employees who cares is declared as the champ??
shopping nike giants #10 eli manning black mens stitched nfl impact limited jersey on sale online
子供学習机
ラミー/Lamy 万年筆
Market Report : babyliss Thought of as An Absolute Must At this time
authentic nike soccer shoes 024 sale outlet store
Carry out the following to discover more on babyliss before you are left behind.
This Week\’S Special Gucci Charm With Gucci Crest Charms In Black Gucci Outlet Store Free 50G In Every Pack
An ideal approach for the babyliss you’ll be able to find out more about immediately.
big discount golden eagles #4 brett favre black embroidered ncaa jersey offer
BEAUTIFUL!!! Perfect
End Whining And Start your own babyliss Marketing strategy Preferably
top quality new seahawks #89 doug baldwin steel blue team color super bowl xlviii nfl elite jersey super values and selections
babyliss was a little too easy in the past, these days its impossible
budget crunching hits women 2014 world cup america 7 beasley away red thai version soccer jerseys for sale online
babyliss Replicas : A Super babyliss trick By which Fools 97.3% of the consumers
discover our latest collection of mitchell and ness nfl new england patriots stitched snapback hats 005 take advantage of these prices now
Our Spanking new babyliss campaign Work Even When You Take a nap! !
hot value ray ban rb3475q sunglasses black frame green crystal lens at the official online store
The Brand new babyliss practice Performs Even When You Go to bed!
where to purchase new broncos #88 demaryius thomas white super bowl xlviii womens nfl elite jerseys for sales
babyliss was far too easy previously, however right now its virtually impossible
shop authentic women indianapolis colts logo pullover hoodie (29) sales promotion
Nice post. I learn some thing additional difficult on unique blogs everyday. It’ll constantly be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a bit some thing from their store. I’d prefer to make use of some using the content on my blog whether or not you do not mind. Natually I’ll give you a link on your web weblog. Thanks for sharing.
jordans for cheap
I was incredibly pleased to uncover this web-site.I wanted to thanks for your time for this fantastic read!! I unquestionably enjoying every little bit of it and I’ve you bookmarked to check out new stuff you weblog post.
jordan sneakers
Hello! I just would like to give an enormous thumbs up for the superb information you might have here on this post. I are going to be coming back to your blog for even more soon.
jordan shoes for sale
An impressive share, I just given this onto a colleague who was doing a bit analysis on this. And he the reality is bought me breakfast because I identified it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the treat! But yeah Thnkx for spending the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love reading even more on this topic. If feasible, as you turn out to be expertise, would you mind updating your weblog with more details? It’s highly valuable for me. Major thumb up for this blog post!
jordan shoes for sale
I’d have to check with you here. Which is not something I in most cases do! I enjoy reading a post that may make men and women feel. Also, thanks for permitting me to comment!
cheap jordans
One can find surely a lot of details like that to take into consideration. That is a terrific point to bring up. I provide the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where by far the most imperative factor will probably be working in honest fantastic faith. I don?t know if most effective practices have emerged about issues like that, but I am certain that your job is clearly identified as a fair game. Both boys and girls really feel the impact of just a moment’s pleasure, for the rest of their lives.
jordans for cheap
After study some of the blog posts on your web site now, and I truly like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark web page list and will be checking back soon. Pls take a look at my internet web-site as well and let me know what you feel.
cheap jordans
I discovered your blog webpage on google and check some of your early posts. Continue to maintain up the especially superb operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking forward to reading more from you later on!
jordan shoes for sale
I discovered your blog web site on google and check some of your early posts. Continue to keep up the really good operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Searching for forward to reading extra from you later on!
cheap jordans
This babyliss Marketing Talk – Who really cares about virtually nothing gains all the perks?!?
big discount canadiens #31 carey price stitched ch red youth nhl jersey bargain blitz
アンプ付スピーカー
The babyliss Firm Meet : Workers who cares wins?
discount womens nike san diego chargers critical victory nfl t shirt brown under discount
Finest magic formula for the babyliss that you’ll discover more about now.
genuine leather jacksonville jaguars authentic font pullover hoodie grey factory outlet
babyliss Fakes : An Awesome babyliss ‘cheat’ Which in turn Fools 90% of the customers
buy designer new broncos #24 champ bailey white with c patch super bowl xlviii womens nfl elite jerseys in the official store
babyliss Broadcast Programs Get Your Up-grades Instantaneously
2014 new ray ban rb4101 jackie ohh sunglasses brown frame crystal brown gradient lens super values and selections
Variety of optimistic steps to discover more on babyliss before you are left out.
Order 2014 Cheap Chanel Mini Handbags Black Leather Bohemian Style Enter The Saving Zone
Perform the following to learn more about babyliss well before you are abandoned.
65% Off Cheap Chanel 2.55 Bags A51309 Grey Leather Silver Chain Online Store
Refrain from Protesting And Begin your private babyliss Campaign Preferably
Brand Cheap 2014 Chanel 2.55 Bags 1112 Soft Grained Apricot Silver Chain Free 50G In Every Pack
http://www.cruiselinesinfo.com/ステューシー-stussy-ステューシー-限定＆コラボ-c-1_42.html
The thing you ought to do to discover babyliss before you’re abandoned.
Best Buy selling pandora charms Sale Outlet
Our Completely new babyliss methods Can Work While You Go to bed : )
Shop Cheap nike free run 3 pink neon at the official site
Listing of favourable steps to discover more on babyliss well before you are left behind.
Guarantee Quality cheap converses On Sale
フレッド 時計
Burberry バーバリー
Nothing at all compares to the background music Map. Absolutely no, you may not listen to the background music, you could effortlessly come across one thing you might like according to whatever you just like.
good articles