Why PTI needed to be expelled from Lahore sit-in against Shia genocide – by Zain Gardezi
It is not a nice feeling to be proven wrong. People who have known me all along know that I never like to lose an argument or accept my mistake. Yet, I am forced to accept one of the biggest mistakes of my life i.e., I voted for PTI.
The funny part is that I was not entirely convinced about voting for it in the first place. While Imran Khan the sportsman was my hero, his naivety in politics had always been a big turn off for me. It is a dangerous precedent to allow someone to control fate of your country who after all these years still comes out as somewhat of a rookie with his trivial, clichéd and hollowed solutions to complex problems. So why did I changed my mind? There were two reasons:
1. While Khan had his fair share of problems, it seemed (and still seems) that media turned a blind eye towards incompetence of major two parties, one of which was criminally silent over all the murders in the country, while the other is practically complicit. I had previously written how our elites seemed to make IK their punching bad and scapegoat in order to hide their own continued support to the two failed parties (https://lubpak.com/archives/230170). I still stand by that point.
2. PPP was simply too corrupt, too incompetent and in context of Punjab at least, too irrelevant to be voted in May 2013, While PMLN has a record of links with extremists and sectarian killers. Though IK’s narrative was false he did not seem to be complicit with the killers. Yes I took the lesser evil. Or did I?
Many Shia Muslims voted for PTI in hope that after coming in power, Khan may get to see the reality of the dangerous situation and may realize the faults in his arguments. So far that has not been the case. Khan and his party seem to go on making one blunder after the other without realizing they are losing their supporters. From Pervez Khattak’s frightened appeal of mercy to Taliban declaring they are not their enemy and KPK has no war with them, to IK’s stubborn approach towards bloopers like Taliban office, PTI not only is far from learning quickly, but the total feeling that comes out is of shameless cowardice. Khan has even made loud empty broken record of his own arguments when there was not even necessity. While PMLN government remained mum on key issues, calculating its options, which often gave the feeling of the absentee federal government, it sat back and let Khan make one loud blunder too many to strengthen the already existing thought in media that he is the main hurdle behind national consensus over terrorism policy. And to an extent that statement is right as well because Khan has influence over youth of the country and he has a fair share in spreading the narrative which has confused nation’s thinking. While in practical terms, federal government holds the key to make any decisions, it is the national consensus which is missing in order to conclude the anti terror policy.
So, even though MWM leaders have disassociated themselves from what happened to PTI delegation at Lahore sit-in, it should still be an eye opener for Imran Khan sahab that what happened in one year that the same place and people who welcomed him on last occasion, started fuming at the presence of his party even though it had come as a show of support. PTI leaders claim that Imran has never talked against operation against LeJ, but that just exposes the overall naïve approach of the party towards the problem which is even more dangerous. LeJ, TTP and Alqaeda are not separate entities, but different names of same nexus of ASWJ aka Anjuman Sipah Sahaba (ASS) which has infiltrated our security agencies, media and urban populace. No half baked operation can solve the problem, but there is a need to wipe the whole menace completely. However, IK and PTI still seem to be stuck with same old broken record of how this is not our war. PTI needs to realize that their stance is losing them support and people who voted for them have already begun chanting slogans against them. If Khan sahib wants to become next PM as he so passionately claims so confidently in his private conversations with journalists, he first need to retain the previous voters first. His lack of acknowledgement of the current war that is going on in the country is a disgrace to the memory of all the sacrifices of families of Pakistan from all sections that have lost their loved ones due to the inhuman Takfiri Deobandi threat. Sometimes a huge embarrassment is what we need to look into our ways. The sit-in embarrassment should be a wakeup call for the party. From the look of things, Pakistan will be moving to eventual war against terror in a full scale operation. If at that time Khan’s approach is different than all the rest of the nation, he will find himself sitting alone at some dark corner without anyone missing him.
IK’s recent statements have been somewhat different from his earlier stances. But I am not too much hopeful that he will leave his stubborn approach. Although I hate to be proven wrong, I will be delighted if Khan proves me wrong here, because that is the need of the time for Pakistan.
**************************
Video: Eviction of PTI workers from Lahore Dharna Against Shia Genocide (23 January 2014)
IK body language speaks of lies he spread about other political parties. He sold hope to young generation, which is very easy to sell, accepted him as hero and leader. My question is how many money was spent on election campaign of PTI and who were supporter and what was agenda of IK? Corruption story is old to blame politician and discredit them in the eyes of general public, although nobody is ready to listen moral corruption of IK. PTI cadre is mostly from JI back ground, and appointed on most important positions, why and how? PTI voters enjoy the ride.
I was a dying hard fan of Imran Khan and also hoped that he will perform great as a political leader. But i have lost faith in him. It is not that Imran Khan is not aware of the situation. His party members have convinced him that if they speak against the terrorists then they will loose govt. in KPK. They also convinced him that PTI will perform great in KPK to set an example in the country to win the next general election and it was clear from the various speeches and interviews of Imran Khan. To keep KPK govt. , his party created a slogan of negotiation. On the other hand PTI has failed in performing as a govt. in KPK. They must learn from AAP party of Delhi,India. Whatever promises AAP made were put into action in just four days where PTI has totally failed in KPK. We will see a turning point in Imran Khan stance in the coming days. Imran Khan must realize that making political alliance is damaging his party. In the coming months we will also a rift in PTI . His party members are giving different views on Mastung genocide , it shows a difference of opinion building in the party which will come with more force in the coming months. People of Pakistan must realize that they have to stand for themselves. No Imran Khan, Nawaz Sharif or Bilawal can protect them or bring good life to them. Pakistani nation must stand for their rights.
I made a big mistake voted for this cleaned shave Taliban. Talibans have not only killed the shia muslims, they also killed several people from sect as well. The coward I K (Taliban Khan) turned a blind eye. I am glad that shia brothers expelled his delegation from the protest.
Now many feeling ashamed voting for PTI. At least to me it was clear from the very first day that all are eik hi theli kay chattay battay hain. So now keep on facing the music. TQ of MQI might be making fiery speeches he is also face of same coin. Now this nation needs a Hilakoo Khan in real sense. Less than that do not expect improvement.
imran khan cannot be taken seriously as a politician.His politics is limited to ABC – sorry APC, tsunami and getting people out on street to his song and dance sessions.Every time he disagrees with the governments views or policies,he asks his supporters to come out on the street-vigilante politics?He has no sensible solutions to offer , just bullying tactics.His brand of politics would lead to unrest in the country – a recipe for disaster and the consequence of which would be – a military takeover?Clearly he is a bad loser – what i could not have, nobody else should!He wants to reward the terrorists by calling them “shaheeds” and talk to them peace, and wants them to have an office on pakistani soil where they have slaughtered innocent men, women and children. If he had his way he would even appoint the terrorists to guard the nuclear weapons!He likes to sit on the fence (and jump on the winning side) as he now wants to support the army against his brethren-the taliban!Since he lost the election and after the fall the bump on his head has clouded his judgement.He acts like a PM in waiting-well you can’t stop somebody from day dreaming.
You cannot be on both sides in this war.
Pakistani Taliban is the worst thing ever happened to Pakistan or Pakistani people. They have no religion, no ethics and no values. At the same time did anyone look at the reality that two countries on both side of Iran had been destroyed but not a single shell ever dropped on Iran? Did this scenario tells a story which may have happened behind the scene? This is just a thought? When Shia brothers or sisters get hurt, blame goes to Pakistani Taliban, rightfully, or someone from that group takes the blame. But when a number of AAlims are murdered brutally on the roads, then no one is there to take the blame.
Would this blame should be diverted to Iran sponsored and trained shia taliban terrorists in Pakistan who silently and brutally are killing people of other sections.
The difference between these two types of killing is only that Pakistani Taliban takes blame but Shia taliban do not.
Instead of writing these long stories, should not we think to untie ourselves from these foreigners, no matter who they are, Taliban or their sponsors, or Iran sponsor terrorists? Can we just be Pakistanis?
If we want peace in our country, we will have to be Just Pakistani, neither Pakistani Taliban nor Shia. We do not need Iran which sponsor all shia terrorists and at the same time we do not need any middle eastern who sponsor Pakistani Taliban terrorists.
…Really surprise to read that many shia voted to IK, and as you showing thery support / sympathy for Khan its also surprising me, as mostly well informed people know that original face of IK that he is supporter or Taliban and there allies (Like Jamiat ulma islam and Jamat e Islami) they never condemn of any incident when shia people hit brutally they never said that Taliban did wrong.
Beside of above observation I didnt see any soberness of polotics in IK they just standing on critcism to other all time cirising where is his pormisses to changed the scenario even they coulnd change a province as you supporting IK thoughts about to be come PM as he stated earlier that he likes Maavia and will try to establish the govt as maavia did .
Ms Sara I like your coulmn and articel very much but this time sorry to say i dont agree with you.
Imran Khan is Syed Munawar Hassan without beared . He is a born again MUSLIM who has seen GOD but haven’t found or recognize HIM yet. This is a very dangerous phenomenon worst than TALIBAN. These kind of people get message from GOD but their antenas are screwed up and that is why their message does not make sense. One must rember that word TALIBAN has one “n” but IMRAN KHAN has TWO “n”s
More dangerous than TALIBAN”
We have January 29 coming in 4 days. This day has great importance in the history of Pakistan, This would have been 88th birthday of late Dr.Salam,first MUSLIM NOBEL PRIZE WINNER in THE HISTORY OF MANKIND.. Let us celeberate this they and send a positive message to the rest of the world “WE ARE NORMAL AND CIVILIZED HUMAN BEINGS” What an optimism on my part? Allama Iqbal said
” HAZARON SAL NARGIS APNI BAY NOORI PER ROTI HAI
BAARRI MUSHKIL SE HOTA HAI CHAMAN MAIN DEEDAWER PAIDA”
Good luck my fellow PAKISTANIS.
You spoke my heart. It makes me feel better when I see there still are people with a good vision and analysation.
Make a blog or something. I’ll be your loyal reader.
I already have 🙂
rorolia.wordpress.com
Does anyone else obtain an fault in the browser as soon as this web page
loads making use of the most recent Safari?
This excellent website for no reason used to do this in the past.
Nevertheless, impressive blog post!
Why PTI needed to be expelled from Lahore sit-in against Shia genocide – by Zain Gardezi
Perform the following to discover more about watch well before you’re left behind.
Why PTI needed to be expelled from Lahore sit-in against Shia genocide – by Zain Gardezi