Why is there Increasing Criticism for Malala Yousafzai, and so Little Support for her Cause in Pakistan? – by Rusty Walker
Malala Yousafzai- Why wouldn’t Pakistan’s elites move mountains to support her cause and assure that she receives funds for advanced education- considering such humble origins? This soft-spoken, articulate, attractive, youthful feminine dynamo, could be the next Benazir Bhutto. One that is not part of a wealthy, privileged and “Bhutto-dynasty” background! Why would the government not assure someone with such potential a Pakistan presidential award, or, something like the British Empire does for citizens of exceptional talents? Why the lack of social and press enthusiasm; why the national sleep-walking?
Malala’s show of courage for a worthy cause is a chance for Pakistan to shine in her reflected glory. She has made the cover of American news publications, during Nobel Peace Prize issues. A nation like Pakistan could benefit from some positive press after the unfortunate JI Report some time ago, the Abbottabad Commission Report that reflected a failing state, one would think should start promoting its global stars. Instead it increasingly diminishes this diminutive hero of Pakistan. Malala is a genuine vanguard for Women’s Right to education. What could be wrong about that?
Sarah Khan’s illuminating report shows Pakistanis are increasingly criticizing this principled teenager, with her pure message of the right to education. How does one find fault with that? In Sarah Khan’s report: “Punjabi CM Shahbaz Sharif spearheads hate campaign against Malala Yousafzai” she finds apologists for Taliban that are attempting to ridicule this Pakistan national hero.
https://lubpak.com/archives/274289
Cyber space Tweets in the past diminished Malala’s speech to the UN: Shehbaz Sharif, tweets: a speech made for “global consumption.” So what? Global consumption can be of benefit to nations seeking economic recovery, and a change in global perception.
The intimidated have no real response, so, change the subject:
And there is the false and irrelevant rhetoric that is spewed out about drones! Drones?
Do you fear Malala’s commentary so much as to change the subject? Salman Khan once tweeted: “She’s mukhtaran…”what about those children maimed daily thru drone strikes.”
Exaggerate sensational fake statistics to enrage your audience:
Several Tweets write of “drones killing thousands of innocent kids.” This would be laughable, if it weren’t such a blatant lie about an effective campaign to which your own Pakistani Army privately agrees. Drones have killed more terrorists than the Pakistani Army, or the local authorities in Waziristan, FATA, KP, and the imaginary Pakhtunistan regions across the Durand Line. Malala had nothing to do with drones: can we agree on that?
Women’s Right to Education, sadly dismissed by women:
The following are women’s astonishingly petty and false narrative by those who should be supporting women:
Invent Conspiracy Theories to assure a misinformed public:
The comment about Malala being used by the “politicians and media as a political ploy,” reaches conspiracy theory absurdity: Really?
So, Malala, is a ploy for the following egregious messages: “education for everyone;” her Gandhi-like comment of seeking “no revenge on the Taliban” that shot and disfigured her; her forgiveness for the Taliban, because she only wants the message that she remains the “same person” before and after being shot. Wow…some ploy by the politicians! How terrible of her!
“West supported figure”
This phrase is assumed as a derogatory reference. It shouldn’t be, but it is.
This is quite illuminating, in that Pakistan is a Western ally; it accepts USAID; it has a celebrated Constitution based on Western form (albeit, some Z.Bhutto and Zia religious insertions that sully it up); Pakistan is not a Theocracy (yet); it is more of a Democratic Republic than a military state (so far), not unlike Western models; And, most Pakistanis I see on the streets of Pakistan appreciate Western culture, movies, music, Western comforts of home, and wear Western style clothes- it is not Saudi Arabia (yet).
Why a celebrated female is increasingly maligned, is cause for serious concern within Pakistan. Is this the work of the new government mentality? Is this fake-liberal society, that hides behind middle-class and elitist comforts? Why do those who prosper in Pakistan, and are educated, and hold positions of power, claim to be religious, or, hold religious values of pluralism, still align with far-Right radical elements? This is a question that baffles those in the Western world.
Malala Yousafzai, even at 14 and 15 years of age is a renowned figure that Pakistan should capitalize on her earned world reputation. The West is enamored with this precocious and pure and self-composed victim of a Taliban shooting. The government should sponsor speaking engagements all over the world for women’s rights groups. People often forget, despite Benazir Bhutto’s constant criticism of the United States, she was lauded there and treated like a princess when she would visit to speak. Presidents loved her, and loved being photographed next to her. Had she been protected, she would have been Pakistan’s beautiful and alluring face to the world. An opportunity missed.
Abdus Salam, Pakistan’s only Nobel Laureate was a mathematical genius on a global level. He was driven away from his homeland by religious zealots. What encouragement was there for him to stay, considering the state-approved injustice supported by the Pakistani Constitution declaring Ahmedis as non-Muslims. Unknown to a sympathetic world, with Pakistani leaders appealing to allies, nations could have and may have, come to his defense. Certainly the Human rights Organizations, and World Leaders such as President Obama, who continually attempts to give credit to Muslims in his goal winning hearts and minds in Islamic countries- possibly an opportunity missed, as Dr. Salam has passed away. The Pakistani leadership should have protected him and taken measures to ensure his safety at home. Pakistan will face a brain-drain if the top minds are afraid of Takfiri Salafist’s retaliation. Many of LUBP’s own writers have gone into hiding. A nation must protect its own.
Ramadan:
In this month of Ramadan arrives unlimited blessings: Pakistan! Wake up! Insh’allah!
Rusty Sahib, couldn’t find much to disagree (and where I disagree is not worth discussing here). Very sadly, Pakistan is sinking and sinking deep. Salam Sahib was the greatest Pakistani after its founder Quaid. Why would people who can’t solve a simple algebraic equation respect Salam Sahi. Now soles of both of them are in duress. May God bless peoples of Pakistan.
Rusty Sahib you always do a great job. You are not rusty from anywhere but stainless steel. This argument of drones killing innocent people and blaming USA for this is self defeating. It is very simple. Pakistan eradicates the talabans and militants , USA does not need drones. Pakistan is responsible for the death of innocent people and not USA.
If the heroes are Qadri and A Q Khan, welcome to hell (Pakistan). Bangladesh is way ahead of Pakistan. They know there criminals (Ghulam Azam of JI) and treat them like criminals. In early days of Pakistan we had Late Sir Zafarullah and 30 years later we were fortunate enough to have Prof.Salam to put Pakistan on world stage. Salam was mathematician and according to algebra, two negatives can make positive only in algebra but not in real life. We only have self inflicting wounds and very hard to find cure for these wounds. Churchill said if you think you are in hell keep going. God bless Pakistan
Its really sad to see people, especially the educated ones, abusing Malala openly on social networks. All of these people are stupid and have a soft spot for Taliban. Some guy mentioned that Malala and the west are destroying images of the real Taliban who are actually pious, while fake Talibans actually shot Malala in Pakistan. Bull shit. All talibans should be gathered in a closed room and tortured for eternity. If this is what Pakistan has become, i have no hopes. If the youth of Pakistan doesnt even support Malala, then nobody will, and its sad and disappointing.
Some illiterate people even had the guts to bring in the Illuminati in all this. But yes, if IK makes an official statement to support Malala then i guess all the insafians will quickly join the bandwagon and change ships.
We all, as Pakistanis, should be ashamed of our nation and the citizens. These past few days have been the most difficult ones.
Long live Malala, you have our support and we WILL add to your cause.
PAKISTAN IS NOT A FAILED STATE BUT A FAILING STATE , described by General Shuja Pasha (ex ISI DG). “doob maro gutter main ISLAM ko badnam karne walo” KHUDA ki tum per laanat der laanat. Why are you giving bad name to HOLY PROPHET
(swa). Try to listen to Maulana Azad’s 40’s speech. He predicted everything so true . We should get out of denial and mending ourselves.
Mr Rusty,
Please dont waste your and our on This Malala shite.there are many other issues which you can put some light.
Huumm I can understand pain in your bottom.
I feel pity for this nation…. who is confused and lost… May Allah save them from darkness approaching towards them.. in the shape of Talibanism
The comment: “PAKISTAN IS NOT A FAILED STATE BUT A FAILING STATE”- Re-read my quote from the Commission report, I wrote, “failing,” not “failed.” And, this is not my assessment, it is the Pakistan’s Commission’s.
Your comment: “Why are you giving bad name to HOLY PROPHET (swa).”
Nowhere have I mentioned Mohammed (PBUH). Nowhere have mentioned Allah (SWT).
I am very sorry Rusty Sahib. This comment was for “jahil Mullah” who is destroying Pakistan. I am very sorry for misunderstanding. I have always admired you for your wisdom and realistic view about Pakistan. As you can see in the beginning of my comment that your name should not be rusty but stainless steel. Please accept my appology. May God bless you for all the work you do on behalf of humanity
Daud Munawar, my apologies!
I am sorry that I misunderstood.
God bless you, Daud Bhai!
Allah toom hare sahat reh!
Civilized people; Daud and Rusty!
Takfiris, learn from them.
Rusty, Please keep doing your good work. If someone wants to see the proof that “Pakistan is failing State” read some of the uneducated comments. These are the same people who are against education and agianst the Islam. They need to understand that do they follow the Islam of Prophet Mohommad (S.A.W.W) or Abus Sufiani and Yazidee Islam? May Allah give some light to these uneducated mullah or destroy them for good.
Rusty, Firstly how did Malala know that those who supposedly attacked her were Taliban? Did they give her their business card??? Secondly the army controlled Swat its strange Taliban would enter a heavily militarised area. Thirdly there is no Taliban in Pakistan. You must be a 9 11 fantasist who believed that Twin Towers were brought down by planes and not bombs. If you watch Building 7 coming down at free fall speed which was NOT hit by anything and also twin towers both falling its obvious your media are liars. Dr. Aafia was kidnapped from Pakistan and to this day no evidence has been given as to her kidnap and torture in Afghanistan. The book 3 cups of Tea was also fiction like your whole article. The author never met went to that village and never saw any Taliban in Pakistan. You probably think the American terrorist Raymond Davies was an angel who was blowing up mosques in Pakistan. You are no supporter of Pakistan. Your article is almost as fake as the so called killing of Osama Bin Laden even though he was supposed to be in Afghanistan but your satellites couldnt see him.