The shameful role of Geo TV in Rawalpindi by-poll
Our fellow bloggers at Cafe Pyala have recently exposed the shameful role of Geo TV and Hamid Mir in the recent by-elections in NA-55. Nadeem Paracha too has written an article on this topic, an excerpt from which is being provided below.
Tele vs. Tulli
By Nadeem Paracha
During the Musharraf dictatorship, the country’s leading private news channel clearly became a hybrid of confused ideological notions when it openly gave vent to the reactionary and violent gestures exhibited by the Lal Masjid terrorists as well as to the more democratic manoeuvres of the anti-Musharraf lawyers movement.
Though roundly criticised by the liberal circles for helping trigger anger among extremist organisations incensed by the army’s action against the Lal Masjid culprits, the channel knew it had hit upon the same lucrative and populist model first pioneered by such right-wing TV networks as North America’s FOX News.
Spite sells
Apart from continuing to give prominent exposure to some of the crankiest conspiracy theorists and hate-mongering televangelists, this channel recently let loose a constant barrage of spite against Zardari – all in the name of ‘democracy’ and ‘accountability.’
There are very few Pakistanis who would be willing to defend some of Zaradri’s recent decisions, but the channel in question seemed to have crossed some vital limits while commenting on these decisions.
What causes more concern is the emerging perception that this channel has started to sound more like PMLN’s official channel. Many observers believe that the channel’s two favourites, Nawaz Sharif and the Chief Justice, are actually setting the structure and tone of their rhetoric according to the dictates and perceptions being peddled by the channel.
During the recently concluded by-election in Rawalpindi, the channel gloated that its opinion poll predicted Sheikh Rasheed’s defeat. I overheard a senior producer of the channel at the Karachi Press Club boasting that it was now his channel that was determining the electoral fate of the politicians.
Though there is nothing hidden about this channel’s both pragmatic and maybe even ideological fascination with PMLN, I wanted to tell the same gentleman that his channel has been equally smitten by characters like Imran Khan and Munawar Hussain (of the Jamaat-i-islami). Meaning, if this channel now considers itself to be a king-making machine, then why, in spite of it giving Khan and Hussain so much coverage and vent, did both the men’s parties fare so badly in the Pindi by-elections?
Both Khan and the Jamat, which have been given a tremendous run on this channel to constantly air their anti-Zaradri, anti-America, and (some would even suggest), ‘pro-Taliban’ tirades, together received a mere four per cent of the votes in the by-elections.
So, is the gloating by the channel a case of sheer delusion? Was this also why the same channel suddenly went on a rampage against Sheikh Rasheed the night before the important by-elections, maybe believing the PMLN wouldn’t be able to win without the channel’s help?
This was by far the most blatant and distasteful exhibition of partial and biased journalism, where the host of a popular talk show and his guests made sure to make Rasheed seem like the most unprincipled and dubious politician on the face of the Earth.
The guests also included established journalists, two of whom made not even a pretentious attempt to sound impartial. The worst was when the host, still unsatisfied with the circus he had enacted, invited a controversial mullah of the Lal Masjid, Maulana Aziz, to deliver a sort of fatwa against Mr. Tulli’s politics. (Aziz, if you remember, is the same brave soul who faced the army’s action against the Lal Masjid clerics and extremists by actually trying to escape from the mosque in a black burqa!)
But all was not lost on the show. At the fag end, famous newspaper columnist, Humayun Gohar, seemed to have had enough of all the ‘objective analysis’ ringing around him and was man enough to castigate the host and the channel of committing ‘target killing against the personality of Sheikh Rasheed.’
As to how much this show affected Rasheed’s performance in the election cannot be gauged, but there is no doubt about what the real idea behind the whole façade of ‘objectivity’ enacted by the show was about.
Source: Dawn
it is very unfortunate to note that Jung group is playing anti Pakistan role as it seems is only protecting NAWAZ SHARIF AND GIVING FULL SUPPORT AND COVERAGE TO BOOST HIS POLITICAL CARRIER ,FROM THIS ACT IT IS NOT DIFFICULT TO CONCLUDE THAT NAWAZ SHARIF HAS BUY SHARES IN THIS PUBLICATION GROUP AND IF HAMID MIR IS SO EXCITED TO DEFEND COWARD MULLHA OF LAL MASJID ,I OFFER HIM OPEN CHALLENGE TO DISCUSS WITH ME ON HIS OWN FORUM AND BRING WITH HIM THE PERSONS OF CHOICE I WILL EXPOSE THE CHARACTER OF THESE COWARD MULLHA OF LAL MASJID BUT WILL ALSO EXPOSE THE PARTIALITY OF CHIEF JUSTICE IFTAIKHAR CHAUDHRY
Asslamalaikum.
CriticalPPP should make a team of people from every UC, must be educated to defend PPP and expose those who wanted to malign PPP.
Geo is become Jeto Nawaz Channel. Totally baised, one sided news channel.
We all should watch all news channel to understand the neutral reporting and current affairs.
I was fan of HM, but he is become baised too. They all are bond of geo upper management instruction.
disappointing journalism ,airing news items like Sheikh Rashid has booked a ticket to Dubai day before election was unprecedented even in GEO’s past terrific record.
Kamran Shahid’s take on Geo TV’s biased agenda:
http://express.com.pk/images/NP_LHE/20100224/Sub_Images/1100866231-2.gif
hamid mir is being funded by pml-n.i think we need to boycott this envelope journo and his programme.he has shown the whole country tht he is nawaz sharif’s PUPPET.
The character assassinations of political entities by media outlets are deplorable and especially the attempts to malign the voters on the night of elections can be termed as pre-poll rigging. It’s high time that Pemra takes notice of such programs and penalize them so that some decency is left in the journalistic ethics
Honestly, if you don’t watch GEO Television aka Jew TV, everything seems so routine and normal in the country and you don’t get bouts of frustration and agony and you don’t shudder that Pakistan will be no more in coming some weeks or the country won’t be engulfed in the civil war and we will be cutting each other’s throat.
When all this GEO Terrorism started during the era of Musharraf, many of us didn’t believe and listen to the saner elements who warned us about the propaganda and the lies being churned out by some anchors and the media owners. In the flow, we lost certainty and stability and now as this government tries to fight the same issues in their own way, once again the same media group wants to dictate the terms and policy matters.
A company is known by the company it keeps. Geo certainty deals with some “colorful” characters. Its genesis, consultants, and affiliations leave much to be desired.
All these Shahid Masoods, Hamid Mirs, Shaheen Sehbais, Saleh Zafirs, Kamran Khans of this world were putting huge fear among the nation for some months that the December was coming and the 7th December will be cutoff date for the present regime. That date has long past. Even the expiry of NRO has passed. Even the verdict of NRO has come out. Nothing has changed on national horizon, while the same anchors are still croaking and giving new dates. Now Akram Sheikh in the program of Shahid Masood has given two weeks for the change.
Government should get a heart and just close down this propaganda machine of GEO. Nobody in the masses will shed a tear for them.
I think we are all confused. When Geo covers the campaign for restoration of judiciary, a majority of our countrymen issues a certificate of patriotism and loyalty to the Geo anchor persons. But when they disclose the truth that reveals corruption and bad governance of our beloved leaders, we assume that the TV channel is playing in the hands of mafia. My humble suggestion is that first we should learn how to analyze a news, then issue a certificate of loyalty or Rebellion to the accused channel or its anchor persons. But before blaming we should make sure whether the news is wrong, just blame or bases on facts. This analysis will help us in issuance of certificate in favour or against any channel or anchor person.
no sir, there were many pakistanis who castigated geo for overdoing its coverage of the lawyers movement as well. secondly, you speak as if it was geo that brought back democracy. far from it. as writers like ayaz amir, aysha siddiqua, irfan hussain and nadeem paracha have alredy mentioned in many of their pieces, the media and the civil society had little to do with the movement. the real movers were mainstream political parties like ppp and pml-n.
there is absolutely no way one can defend what hamid mir did with shaikh rasheed. and real democracy is watching very pro-ppp writers like paracha writing for a politician who though is totally against the ppp, but got a raw deal from geo.
GEO Channel is controlled by JEW’s and Punjabis as well, they trying to break Pakistan, JEW and punjabi never want to bear more Sindhi, Baloch and Pukhton any more thts y daily they Propaganda against Sindhi President.
time is coming i m again warn u., when they give same package like balochistan,
Zardari – A burden on PPP or a really indispensable Head
A dilemma for PPP Loyals
PPP workers and loyals can not make moves or comment against Zardari as now by fault (not default) he is heading the party. Due to mistake, passion or compassion, they chose him in critical time. Just due to the …..
Read full article here: http://criticalppp.com/archives/6471
i really much like geo new its work is osuum but i dnt like our politicions.
nd hamara jo zardari hain wo to mind sy hi allah hafiz hai really.
mjy plz es ka zoror btaen k benazir ne aj tak zadari ko moo nai mara tha jo awam q pagal hoe pari hai .zardari u r such aaa cheap person nd i really dnt like uu.
I wanted to post you this little note just to thank you so much again regarding the magnificent tactics you have shared on this site. It is really wonderfully generous with people like you to make unreservedly just what most of us would have made available for an e-book to help make some cash for their own end, certainly given that you could have done it in case you considered necessary. These tricks as well worked as the great way to realize that the rest have similar passion just as mine to see many more around this condition. I am sure there are many more fun instances up front for individuals that examine your blog.