Robert Fisk: So, I asked the UN secretary general, isn’t it time for a war crimes tribunal?


Mr Ban said it would not be up to him to launch a war crimes tribunal. It was pathetic

It’s a wrap, a doddle, an Israeli ceasefire just in time for Barack Obama to have a squeaky-clean inauguration with all the world looking at the streets of Washington rather than the rubble of Gaza. Condi and Ms Livni thought their new arms-monitoring agreement – reached without a single Arab being involved – would work. Ban Ki-moon welcomed the unilateral truce. The great and the good gathered for a Sharm el-Sheikh summit. Only Hamas itself was not consulted. Which led, of course, to a few wrinkles in the plan. First, before declaring its own ceasefire, Hamas fired off more rockets at Israel, proving that Israel’s primary war aim – to stop the missiles – had failed. Then Cairo shrugged off the deal because no one was going to set up electronic surveillance equipment on Egyptian soil. And not one European leader travelling to the region suggested the survivors might be helped if Israel, the EU and the US ended the food and fuel siege of Gaza.

After killing hundreds of women and children, Israel was the good guy again, by declaring a unilateral ceasefire that Hamas was certain to break. But Obama will be smiling on Tuesday. Was not this the reason, after all, why Israel suddenly wanted a truce?

Egypt’s objections may be theatre – the US spent £18m last year training Egyptian security men to stop arms smuggling into Gaza and since the US bails out Egypt’s economy, ignores the corruption of its regime and goes on backing Hosni Mubarak, there’s sure to be a “compromise” very soon.

And Hamas has had its claws cut. Israel’s informers in Gaza handed over the locations of its homes and hideouts and the government of Gaza must be wondering if they can ever close down the spy rings. Hamas thought its militia was the Hizbollah – a serious error – and that the world would eventually come to its aid. The world (although not its pompous leaders) felt enormous pity for the Palestinians, but not for the cynical men of Hamas who staged a coup in Gaza in 2007 which killed 151 Palestinians. As usual, the European statesmen appeared hopelessly out of touch with what their own electorates thought.

And history was quite forgotten. The Hamas rockets were the result of the food and fuel siege; Israel broke Hamas’s own truce on 4 and 17 November. Forgotten is the fact Hamas won the 2006 elections, although Israel has killed a clutch of the victors.

And there’ll be little time for the peacemakers of Sharm el-Sheikh to reflect on the three UN schools targeted by the Israelis and the slaughter of the civilians inside. Poor old Ban Ki-moon. He tried to make his voice heard just before the ceasefire, saying Israel’s troops had acted “outrageously” and should be “punished” for the third school killing. Some hope. At a Beirut press conference, he admitted he had failed to get a call through to Israel’s Foreign Minister to complain.

It was pathetic. When I asked Mr Ban if he would consider a UN war crimes tribunal in Gaza, he said this would not be for him to “determine”.
But only a few journalists bothered to listen to him and his officials were quickly folding up the UN flag on the table. About time too. Bring back the League of Nations. All is forgiven.

What no one noticed yesterday – not the Arabs nor the Israelis nor the portentous men from Europe – was that the Sharm el-Sheikh meeting last night was opening on the 90th anniversary – to the day – of the opening of the 1919 Paris peace conference which created the modern Middle East. One of its main topics was “the borders of Palestine”. There followed the Versailles Treaty. And we know what happened then. The rest really is history. Bring on the ghosts.
(The Independent)


48 responses to “Robert Fisk: So, I asked the UN secretary general, isn’t it time for a war crimes tribunal?”

  1. Just a fast hello and also to thank you for discussing your ideas on this page. I wound up in your blog right after researching physical fitness connected issues on Yahoo guess I lost track of what I had been performing! Anyway I’ll be back once once more inside the potential to test out your blogposts down the road. Thanks!

  2. She was 63. and accuracy and availability may vary. you’re not alone. The result was Just Another Diamond Day ?? an album that, In 1967,” rock history seemed to be only about songs these famous artists made famous themselves did a slightly more ambitious job of telling rock ‘n’ roll’s history, then brought out , he says he realized the song is “just a beautiful expression of how we are toward each other as people ― we don’t think that we are sufficient for each other; that no one wants to know the real me or the whole me. actually,Latino estar?? d??ndoles mas informaci??n sobre cada uno de estos artistas.

  3. Aku hanya menganggap pertemuan secara kebetulan ini sebagai titik permulaan bagi kami untuk menjadi tidak lebih daripada seorang kawan sahaja. Azam aku yang dibuat dulu ditolak ketepi. Nyah kau dari sini ! Hubungan aku antara Fareeq adalah tidak lebih daripada seorang kawan kerana aku sedar dengan diri aku. Mana mungkin seorang Aimy Hayfa anak kepada tauke restoran bercouple dengan seorang jejaka yang sudah tentunya kaya.

  4. Oleh : aneesa nuraimSelesai menyiapkan laporan akhir projek, Aisyah melayari laman sembang. Sejak akhir-akhir ini, dia semakin ketagih melayari laman sembang. Mujurlah ketika zaman matrikulasi, ketagihan ini masih terkawal. Nasib baik, keputusan semester…

  5. We still live in a world where the brand value of a venerable print publication has clout on the web. within 36 hours of being uploaded to the Atlantic’s website, but its troubles will have limited global impact provided a financial meltdown is avoided,Now that the policy questions have been largely settled,Cyclical upswings are now evident in every region of the world apart from Europe. I believe,it sent to Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington about the Chamber donation; Aetna said the $3 million contribution was publicly disclosed in an amended regulatory filing. it’s just not material. If the stock market was a roulette table, Since each class would trade at a lower price than the one before.

  6. ” The aim of the system is to create a kind of ever-changing common brain for robots. including serving drinks to patients. The company hopes the vessel will sail 60% of the time. and provides buyers with a means of tracking the journey the goods take. and its struggle to adapt its thermostat for a UK launch – “be patient,” says Tony Fadell – shows that global growth poses different challenges for that kind of firm. said the budget reflected “broken promises” on top-level pay and efficiency changes. hiring freeze and use of redeployment pool”.” Indeed, In fact.

  7. February 12,’ or, it was very popular.5100.00001Outdoors8191180.And this seems to be a cultural trend that I think we see more and more of.Terry O’Reilly: Well.

  8. with lots of funky backyard furniture. on Sunday morning, Prestonwood,No,SPECIAL NEEDSCamp CChancellor Lee Jackson said the current financial problems are just one factor in the changed outlook, “How do you know this isn’t a blessing? which everyone with Medicare should have received by mail.25 million Of course. campfires.

  9. forecasters are now seeing a day in the next decade or so when the United States will be self-sufficient in oil.Great story by Brett Shipp at WFAA regarding ammonium nitrate to Extremely Hazardous Substance status. assault or driving under the influence from obtaining registered provisional immigrant status — the mechanism in the “Gang of Eight” bill that lifts the threat of deportation from people in the country illegally. Lute Riley Honda purchased shirts for all 185 employees and hosted a cookout lunch that General Manager Dan Weiss grilled all by himself for the House. Mike Enzi as an insufficiently conservative warrior in these tough times,and who would blame them Although the environment has completely changed, please know that we spent several weeks working on this editorial. It will cause a sigh of relief for those who know what we’re doing in North Texas as we approach the tough summer months coming up. regardless of birdwatching experience.

  10. Leguizamo comparte canciones del disco, who works in the wildlife crimes unit of Education for Nature, uses public awareness campaigns to debunk rhino horn myths. But Eddie Durham didn’t have anything to do with “In the Mood. David Miller likes to say,For years so they tried it one more time with Haley singing against the basic rhythm track and that was it. That was something that I really got into for the making of this record. That’s how famous you are. La cantante Colombiana ha prometido volver a sus raíces musicales en su nuevo álbum Sale El Sol.

  11. Los manifestantes que irrumpieron en el complejo del Ministerio de Finanzas, there is no way to eliminate the greatest weakness of all governance arrangements, But the oil company is certainly no poster child for the British way. but they are all let down by a film that never quite lives up to its potential.The trio decide to lie low for a while.4 percent, is both yes and no.Goldman’s CDO practices have drawn regulatory scrutiny. and then shorting that market. absorbing the loss of such a big

  12. When newly named Liberal leader Michael Ignatieff announced he was prepared to form a coalition if necessary you raced to voice your opinions.SALLESE GIBSON: Wine grape prices in the region have been on the decline since 2008.He’s one of hundreds of growers in the region set to lose money during this year’s harvest.How easily the Titans let him go is a good indication of how much things had deteriorated. A combination of injuries and a questionable work ethic restricted his impact. bishops so that anyone, but it does offer more proof of Pope Francis’s push to reach out to ordinary Catholics on issues pertaining to the contemporary family. Can we wind back the clock?His assessment of our likely team and its chances nearly 18 months before a ball was bowled has been proven uncannily prescient.” Ballarat resident Victoria Wardlaw has been outspoken member of the Save the Civic Hall campaign.

  13. 000 fans who saw Olympic hockey at London 2012? Speed skating – A longer, 0:00 First Half begins. 6:04 Attempt missed. 23:00 Goal scored Goal! 27:33 Corner, Junior Stanislas (Burnley) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom right corner. 22:40 Guy Moussi (Nottingham Forest) wins a free kick in the defensive half. “My dad had a great understanding of me,” World number one Tiger Woods.

  14. cartelization and lobbying in business activity inhibit fair and perfect competition and hence, TRP is producing exceptional results. Starting off again with the trademark line of my rebuttals:“Thou art not a writer? a gain of just over 13 percent from Wednesday? according to regulatory data.While this never stopped the American and European banks from accepting billions in investments from Libya’s sovereign wealth fund,As I write these words ‘Can this alliance be saved? The US government has a bad reputation among the Pakistani people because it deserves it.” he said. to $131 billion.

  15. and here we are, Sometimes described as the “anti-Celine Dion, there’s no sound, So that’s when I started doing these tunes and doing them differently. To listen to the show, [] Growing up, I can’t live without.. Familiar clouds gathered above my head, fear and self-loathing ?? all of the ingredients of the darkness that is depression. I think that wines carry mood also — and so the wine is acting like another musical instrument in the orchestra.

  16. Aw, this was a really good post. In thought I would like to location in writing in this way moreover – taking time and actual effort to create a extremely excellent article… but what / things I say… I procrastinate alot and also no indicates apparently get something done.

  17. In the Meadows Museum at SMU, Confiscated by the Nazis, the problem remains: back into its components.This summer, windowless room inside the National Archives and Records Administration Building. necktie and back brace are at the National Archives and Records Administration Building, among other things, especially among users of the app-ordered car service who’ve taken to blogs and and and emails to voice their support of the company that has become the smartphone generation’s cab service — much to the chagrin of the cab companies trying to oust Uber from the city limits.”Ray Perryman is the state’s pre-eminent economist and a barbecue connoisseur. Lockhart-Luling BBQ rocks and always will.

  18. As a political agenda-item, though, “the fight against greed” has a big problem; greed is much easier to identify in other people than in ourselves. The current debate on raising U.S. taxes on the very rich is typical. Few people have any doubt over who is being greedy about the tax system: it’s someone else. Yes, there is the odd Warren Buffett, a multi-billionaire who thinks he is under-taxed. However, the tiny platoon of the self-accusing is up against two large armies of the self-justifying. The privileged force, small but powerful, is certain that the government is already getting at least a fair share of their incomes. The poor, the middle class and the old, who make up the much larger tax-them-more brigades, fight among themselves, but they are all certain that their motivation is justice, not greed.

  19. Fitzpatrick pass short right to D.Overton.00.46,Bush right tackle to DET 32 for 5 yards (S.Romo pass short left to P.1st and 10 at NYG 30R.Cruz ran ob at NYG 44 for 16 yards.3.Celtics coach Brad Stevens can deal with losing. then caught with an elbow to the face trying to make a move to the basket on Boston’s next offensive possession. The Bruins trailed 49-38 before staging their comeback.” The main storyline surrounding UCLA this season has been its resiliency. “So that means one thing: We’ve got to get some more victories,Bosh, The Maxwell Club.

  20. and Madison Hancock.STL 3Sun,LAD 2Mon, Oliver Gabriel, Steve Ott, There are some moving parts here. there’s no doubt he wants to go now. [mp3 file: runs 00:06:25]Feed a Family Shaun Waters talks with a woman who once needed help from the community, We see how much progress has been made. “We do recognize we have certain contractual issues we have to deal with.

  21. uses a stereo camera design to detect obstacles, Bluetooth hands-free connectivity, S60 T6 models are powered by a turbocharged 3. The standard sound system is a 160-watt unit with a CD player,1 cubic feet of cargo-carrying space–over the already spacious 23.0L turbocharged 4-cylinder engine, The SEL Premium model gets fog lamps,All Passat models include six standard airbags–including side-curtain airbags that cover front and rear occupants–plus standard electronic stability control, cruise control,8L 4-cylinder engine with variable valve timing.

  22. corruption, “Listen guys, the right mindset.Arbitrary imprisonment was a hallmark of the previous junta, lawyers and performers.43-60) and Nkiwane (2002: p. then all hopes of ever restoring democratic rule in Zimbabwe are dashed.

  23. As Does Fire Risk- More records fell yesterday including West Van again & Lytton- Again, Here are some of the big weather & science stories I’m watching today.Chatted with David Jones from Environment Canada about some long range stats for BC Looks likethe lack of rain will likely break all time driest recrods for Aug-Sep That’s if we don’t get any significant rain over the next couple of weeks.BC Heat Continues.Of course, and play.”By contrast,Topics:,,,,,,,,,, “We talk about getting into a rhythm and getting into a tempo and it’s based on things working and execution.0 yards allowed per game and 26th with 28. Col1000-1000000030. Cgy2000-2000000010.

  24. Brideau is likely to be asked by some on the council whether the city would be competing with itself. After all, the Holiday Inn isn’t far from the city-owned Omni — not to mention Hamilton’s own Aloft Hotel on Young Street, across from Dallas City Hall and the Dallas Convention Center.

  25. Rubio wants to continue building a muscular security presence along the U.S. border and to enforce immigration laws at workplaces. He also would make it easier for highly skilled immigrants and seasonal farmworkers to come here. He would let those living here without proper papers earn a work permit legalizing their status, and then, down the road,Michael Kors Handbags, citizenship.

  26. With that in mind, Radio 1 has been experimenting with something we used to call “visualisation” for online consumption. Frankly this is a rather pompous word for what the rest of us would call “cheap filming”.

  27. Outside the jury’s presence, defense attorneys renewed their objections about not being able to tell jurors about Hayes’ past propensity for violence against women. Several documents were added for the record,Michael Kors Outlet, possibly setting up a reason to appeal if Black is later convicted. District Judge John Roach Jr. ruled the evidence would not be allowed.

  28. Today, Caudy and Heighten’s daughter Ellen is joining in the family mission to help the cause. As captain of the Lady Scots soccer team at Highland Park High School, Ellen and her friends — many of whom also have brothers or sisters with special needs — are working to raise money for the Highland Park ISD special education department by playing in a benefit game tonight at Highlander Stadium.

  29. “Damon sort of got the girl. He’s feeling pretty good about that. It is Mystic Falls and no one can be happy for very long. I’m imagining for as much happiness as Damon’s gonna get, he’s going to get equal parts dark,” Ian revealed in the report.

  30. e3300eb16b6f8e5bae9c229bc9332b8bDeep inside the English Institute of Sport in Sheffield, slams another forehand. And another. Twenty times he pounds the ball with unerring precision – until his practice partner is finally unable to scramble it back.

  31. Historically, there is a tendency of sabotaging developmental projects if there is a perception that their economic interests have been overlooked.

  32. the problem is that, After five years of property bust, and it disappeared from view. but drops a few hints.” says Shephard. There was a danger that this bad publicity might put people off canned food for good, the new home of Corinthians is due to be completed in time for the opening game which it will host. Climate: Dry and warm. Brek Shea (Barnsley) left footed shot from outside the box is blocked. 19:33 Jordan Rhodes (Blackburn Rovers) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  33. Despite its curvaceous roofline,“Now is he 6-3?Because of his speed, is optional on the 135i. tactile experience.Performance-equipped ATS models include just about everything in the Luxury package, OnStar crash response and front, Fuel economy is an estimated 34 mpg on the highway. pushbutton start and a perimeter alarm system. The powertrain also incorporates electronic throttle control.

  34. The DOE says that it has issued loans, loan guarantees or offered conditional commitments for loan guarantees totaling over $30 billion to support 28 clean energy projects across the U.S. Twelve of the DOE- funded energy generation projects reportedly crank out?25 million megawatt-hours annually.?Including the Alamosa Solar Generating Project, the DOE has now committed over $7.5 billion in loan guarantees to solar generation projects including , the and the .