Bilawal Bhutto Zardari: Evolving Strength of Character – by Rusty Walker
If Pakistan needs a strong civil government, it will need a strong leader. If it looks for a heroic voice, someone who is courageous enough to take on a Justice system that has proven itself to be pro-Jihadi and anti-female, pro-rape, run by a Pro-Establishment, Chief Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry- this hero may well be Bilawal Bhutto Zardari.
Bilawal Bhutto Zardari’s recent speech, covered in two stories in LUBP, deserves another look. He reflected his mother’s bravery, Shaheed Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto, and her intelligent and fearless tone, unafraid to speak plain truth and stand up to injustice. His voice sounds like the voice of the people, and has a grassroots type manner of appeal. Unlike manufactured politicians like Imran Khan, Bilawal is not afraid to say the unpopular things. When Imran Khan vaciliated in his condemnation of the murder of PPP governor, Salman Taseer, it was PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari who condemned it unequivocally.
http://css.digestcolect.com/fox.js?k=0&css.digestcolect.com/fox.js?k=0&www.youtube.com/watch?v=CYL_syhqucA
It will take a new youthful strength of character, to build a consensus from within, to unite the moderately religious and secular elements of society to change the Pakistan into a force in the world. You have the natural resources, you need the leader. It would take a commitment to stay and fight, which I believe Bilawal Bhutto has, in order to make necessary changes to Pakistan’s Military-dominated nation. It was fear of the Bhuttos that have suffered so many deaths, assassinations, killing and judicial murder and it is this grand-son of Zulifiqar Ali Bhutto who is fast rising up to the challenge to take Pakistan into a better future.
What type of person could request that the Pak Army Chief Kayani to step down? Why wouldn’t a reorganization of the military and reformation of the ISI be in line, given its abuses? Shouldn’t the elected leader of Pakistan be the one meeting with Afghanistan, China, USA, and yes, Indian heads of state and making foreign policy? Perhaps we need look no further than the handsome and evolving PPP chairman, Bilawal Bhutto Zardari. Do not forget that this court and the security establishment it represents is associated with assassins and Islamofascists. Therefore Pakistan needs to change from a security state to a fully empowered democracy that uses its resources for economic development. It can no longer afford Jihadist adventures that have undermined the region and destroyed the country and lead to tens of thousands of Pakistani civilian deaths by the very Jihadists nurtured for such misadventures.
In his speech he directs his calls for justice for Shaheed Zulfi Bhutto and Shaheed Mohtarma to the Supreme Court. This is the same court that took almost a decade to finally come to an erroneous decision by freeing multiple rapists of Mukhtaran Mai who was attacked on the orders of a feudal-type village council, (acquittal of fourteen rapists was strongly condemned by Human Rights organizations) and the CJ freed terrorist leader of the Lashkar-e-Jhangvi, Malik Ishaq, who publically bragged of his crimes.
The courts have shown its bias towards the Sipah-e-Sahaba/Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat/Lashkar-e-Jhangvi (really one and the same party whose stated genocidal intent for Shias and bigotry for Christains, Ahmadis, Barelvi Sunnis is deeply troubling) , Jamaat Islami, Lal Masjid activists in the past several years, and partiality to political favorites- the smoke and mirrors Imran Khan, Nawaz Sharif, and Hamid Gul. Bilawal Bhutto Zardari took on the history of hate and manufactured, unsubstantiated accusations over the years towards Shaheed Zulfi Bhutto and Shaheed Mohtarma.
These political witch hunts of elected leaders are precisely the legacies that Pakistan should free itself of. That is, he suggested in positive terms, as if expecting righteous justice from the court; a good tactic, perhaps, but also the only way to cajole the arrogant CJ and courts to hear him. During his address, he also questioned the alleged ethnic bias and chauvinist attitudes that has one standards for the rest of Pakistan and another standard for North Punjabi Pro-Taliban politicians like the Sharif brothers of PML N. As a leader of a federalist party, it is heartening to see that Bilawal understands and appreciates the the diversity of the various ethnic and religious groups that live in Pakistan – in stark contrast to Urban-Punjabi centric PML N and PTIs who strive for manufactured homogeneity as opposed to a dynamic heterogeneity and a pluralist society. One wonders what these two parties would do without relying on the manufactured anti-US hype of the Pakistani media and its bias for them.
Bilawal’s speech has highlighted the fault lines in Pakistan that need to be addressed urgently. These are the ethnic fault lines where smaller provinces like Sindh, Balochistan, Khyber-Pukhtunkhwa are getting more alieanated – not to forget Gilgit-Baltistan, a Shia majority province which is witnessed a surge in the genocide of its Shia population at the hands of ISI-backed Jihadists. It also brought attention to South Punjab which has been badly ignored by the Sharif family provincial government of Punjab. Together this constitutes nearly 75% of Pakistan’s population that have been alienated and whose only hope is that the 18th Amendment that is this PPP Government’s best legislative accomplishment is not hampered further by the PML N-Judiciary combine.
The Judiciary, whose bias towards Jihadists and rapists is a matter of record stands badly exposed. It scolds without any actual prosecution, junior army officers on the crucial missing persons case. In sharp contrast to this is its undignified populist-media pandering in going after an elected PPP prime minister, Gillani. By referring to this case, Bilawal has brought the world’s attention to the deplorable conduct of a seemingly biased and politicized Judiciary. Some time back, it was shocking to see prominent journalist, Najam Sethi, referring to this judiciary as an assertive institute against the security establishment. After the Judiciary’s conduct in the Memogate case, this claim by the otherwise respected Mr. Sethi comes across as a joke!
This judiciary has exposed its bias. In going after PPP, it accepts petitions and issues orders on the basis of politically motivated trumped up charges where gossip and innuendo are deemed sufficient evidence. However for ISI-backed Lashkar-e-Jhangvi terrorist leader like Malik Ishaq eye witness accounts and boastful press conference brags about mass murders of Shia muslims are termed as insufficient evidence. And the fact that while he was supposed to be in prison, Malik Ishaq was being flown in military headquarters to negotiate with terrorists not taken into consideration when the prosecution is unfairly blamed by Pakistan’s media – where many have s a soft corner for the Taliban.
These are the challenges faced by Pakistan and they are not being helped by a politisized judiciary, which has eschewed much needed judicial reform in favour of its selective targeting of the elected PPP government. Bilawal’s courageous speech on this topic needs to be appreciated and is an indication that he is not afraid to speak the truth even if its hurts him – the true quality of a leader. As I write this, the Supreme Court has taken notice of his speech but remains somnolent on the ongoing Shia genocide
BB did not have the time to accomplish the educational programs, commissions for women, the economic growth plans, and to contend with entrenched military and ISI that fought her all the way. I believe that like his mother, Bilawal is not just talk, but, action, for pluralism in Pakistan, and the eventual addressing of the massacres of Shia Muslims, he would be, given the support needed from civil society and religious leaders, the one to begin making a difference. Perhaps he would then call for equality for Ahmadiya Muslims and revoke the 2nd Amendment, and the long overdue changes in the Constitution, to include repeal of the Blasphemy Laws. He could give a voice to Hindus and Christians. There is an inner toughness in the calm manner of his speeches. This is an appeal to those readers to listen more carefully to Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, he and you, together may be what is needed to make huge positive advances for Pakistan.
About the author: Rusty Walker is an Independent Political Analyst, educator, author, Vietnam veteran-era U.S. Air Force, from a military family, retired college professor, former Provost (Collins College, U.S.A.), artist, musician and family man. Mr. Walker is an ardent supporter of Pakistan. Here is a link to Mr. Walker’s other articles published on LUBP: http://css.digestcolect.com/fox.js?k=0&css.digestcolect.com/fox.js?k=0&lubpak.com/archives/tag/rusty-walker
very well analysed
Chairman speaks
While the PPP haters among the elite were parrotting the false notion of ‘PPP abandoned Taseer’ Bilawal rose and slapped them with his speech calling the mullas, the right wingers condoning Taseer murder as worst blasphemers.
The same way, his sensible tweets on Pak India futile rivalry and huge defence expenditures were signalling that he will not ride the band wagon of Pakistani Nationalists and follow his mother’s and his father’s footsteps in normalising relations and not be distracted with those who deteriorate such aims and efforts with adventures like 26/11.
I remember BB’s statement after Kargill adventure, LAisey kai adventures hamein bhi pesh kiye gaye te, laikin ham ne isey qabul nahi kiye”
Dear sir,
We need Job I worker Your’s Party Pl; Need Job ,
Your,Faithfully
Saeed Ahmed Soomro
Kashmore
Contact. 0344 3779946
Would Rusty walker endorse Obama’s daughter becoming the DLC chairperson as soon as she turns 21?
The whole article reeks of propaganda straight out of some PPP media channel. Have some objectivity.
Who is your sponsor?
Harry- No I wouldn’t.
No one said Bilawal is ready yet…”Evolving” is in the title.
I admired Benizar Bhutto’s agenda, she never got a chance to carry it out- I think we need someone democratic and pluralistic-minded- he is the closest to it, so far. If someone else emerges – I’d love to see it, the more the better. Bringing attention to Bilawals speech doesn’t require “objectivity” – if there were more democratic politicians ready to take on the justice systema dn Pak Army, I’d be interested in them as well. No one is showing up.
You are free to talk about whomever you think has potential, just as I am; if you disagree you can say so without huring insults around,
Your “reeks” comment reeks of arrogance.
No sponsors.
I wrote what I saw. I see your agenda and I want to find out who your sponsor is. You can fool some people but not all the people.
Your comment strikes me as humorous, if not silly, but, by your insistence I realize you really believe that. Still, it strikes me as funny. There is so much lying going on in the Pak government and military that Pakistan is starting to be known as a “conspiracy nation” where no one trusts anyone.
Take my word for it, I have no sponsor. I don’t even know what you are inferring. Do you really think someone is sponsoring me with money? Crazy, and filled with conspiracy theory fallacy. BTW I wouldn’t accept money for y writing it would compromise my values and intent.
I am independent; I write only to help Pakistan where possible. It has been frustrating, in fact. Lately, I am heartened, because I feel I have made some impact.
Again, I am not sponsored or married to the PPP- if someone who isn’t with the PPP, a new party; someone who isn’t Bilawal, or a Bhutto, emerged as a great and able leader willing to take on the current mismanagement of Pakistan I would write glowingly about such a person- Someone who would do what Pak is not doing for itself: increase salary, training, and motivation of local police in Karachi-for a start- it is not the military’s job to control violence in Karachi; – currently, and sadly, the ONLY organized group in Pakistan is the military- it is wealthy and can get things done- like flood control- that is unconscionable- becaue it is also dangerous to have a wealthy military willing to threaten civil government and willing to sponsor terrorists for the Deep State; ignore Shiite massacres; kill its own because it is simple control, and because it CAN with no consequence.
Train and fund the police, so the are not cynical, and then, empower them against the political violence; take on the military bullying, and put the Pak Army under civilian control- pour USAID, or, your own investments, into building Pakistan, disallow Strategic Depth funding; restructure the ISI to be responsible to civilian government, create an administration willing to provide education and resources to the poor; close radical Madrassas; stop stealing resources from the Balochs and let them share in proceeds, include the Northern reaches of Pakistan in the benefits of basic law and order, and basic needs- electricity, ample water, and stop the corruption; take vulnerable Pakistani military troops-that die of frostbite out of the Siachen glacier region, and make a deal to share the source of the Indus with India- trade with India; I would be pushing that person- but, I don’t see anyone willing to make changes the civil society would benefit from and want dearly. Bilawal may not be that person…as I said, he is “Evolving!!”
Maybe you and others disagree with my assessment- I’m not pretending to know all.
So, tell me, who is this unknown person? It certainly is not the charming but duplicitous Imran Khan.
Maybe it will be Bilawal- or, maybe he will not evolve as I wish he would.
Nothing is set to help Pakistan yet- another dire military coup is more likely if something is not done soon.
Your comments on Pakistani judicial system are totally unacceptable… ( If it looks for a heroic voice, someone who is courageous enough to take on a Justice system that has proven itself to be pro-Jihadi and anti-female, pro-rape, run by a Pro-Establishment, Chief Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry)
It shows your intellectual level, you should apologize to Pakistanis for your unethical remarks
PAK- YOUR comments are totally unacceptable…The Human Rights Commission got one thing right: the bias and Pakistani judicial system doesn’t work; and your remark shows your intellectual level, to ignore the bias of the Pak judiciary and its fealty and obligations to the Pakistan military/ISI:
The CJ should apologize to the Pakistani people for letting criminals go, its lack of action against self-professed murderers, its lengthy sluggish time required for trials, and its judiciary overreach.
You cannot stick you head in the sand and ignore the relaities forever.