Viewpoint: How far is Saudi-Iranian rivalry fuelling Yemen war?
Salafi power Saudi Arabia has – deliberately or otherwise – projected the fighting in Yemen as a proxy war with regional Shia rival Iran, though this is a dangerous mischaracterisation of the conflict.
The Saudis see growing Iranian influence everywhere – to the north in Iraq and Syria, to the east in its own country and in Bahrain, and now pointedly to the south in Yemen.
But this view belies the complexities of Yemeni domestic politics, overemphasises the role of Iran, and is unlikely to lead to anything approaching a successful conclusion, as is being seen with the Saudi-led bombing campaign, which is yet to achieve its stated aims.
The Houthi moniker, originally but a clan name, has been associated with the Zaidi branch of Shia Islam and, thus, by overly simplified if not erroneous extension, the “Twelver” Shiism predominant in Iran and Shiism in general.
Firstly, Houthis are not all Zaidis, and neither are all Zaidis Houthis. And secondly, Zaidism is considered to be the branch of Shiism least in dispute with Sunni doctrine.
Whatever the religious similarities between the Houthis and Iran, there is an implicit notion that any commonality matters. Whether nominally united or separated by faith, it is seldom as determining a factor in action as it is fatuously perceived.
None of this is to ignore commonalities between Iran and the Houthis.
Both display a vociferous anti-American and anti-Israeli streak, and there are obvious instances of the Houthis co-operating in some way with Iran in recent years.
A day after the Houthis took over the Yemeni capital Sanaa in February, an aviation agreement with Iran was signed and an Iranian Mahan Airlines plane landed in the city.
Domestic dispute
But simplistically labelling the Houthis as “Iranian-backed” obscures the domestic nature of the conflict which predates the Arab Spring.
Zaidis ruled parts of Yemen for almost 1,000 years until 1962 and were even supported by Saudi Arabia in the 1970s.
But then the Houthis, who emerged as a Zaidi revivalist movement in the 1990s, fought a series of wars between 2004 and 2010 against the Saudi-supported central Yemeni state led by then-President Ali Abdullah Saleh, who also happens to be a Zaidi.
Religious divisions have, therefore, played a surprisingly minor role in the past until they were deepened not least by Saudi Arabia’s attempts in the 1990s in particular to spread its own austere version of Salafi Islam in Yemen.
The Houthis believed that such policies were designed to further marginalise their position, given their historic powerbase of Saada province being right on the Saudi border.
Spoils of war
The numerous wars fought against government forces gave the Houthis all the training and combat experience that they needed to humiliate Saudi forces when they intervened in Yemen in 2009 and to apparently fare so well against the recent air campaign launched by Saudi Arabia and its allies.
More importantly perhaps, many years of war have festooned Yemen with weapons.
There are plenty of accusations that Iran supplies the Houthis with weapons. Some reports lack credibility, like Saudi-owned al-Arabiya TV’s insistence that 185 tons of Iranian weapons miraculously made it through the international naval taskforce currently blockading Yemen.
Other stories, like the Iranian dhow that was stopped on route to Yemen in 2013 with a range of advanced equipment, are far more plausibly an example of Iranian weapons shipping.
While one UN Security Council report noted independent verification was unable to confirm the allegations, a more recent, as yet unreleased one, concluded that a pattern of Iranian support had emerged.
Houthi resilience
Nevertheless, a perennial problem with such instances is that the evidence of Iranian involvement often comes from sources that have a vested interest in plugging such a line: whether from the Saudi, Yemeni or American side.
External supplies notwithstanding, an obvious source of weaponry for the Houthis came thanks to a new-found agreement with their erstwhile adversary, Ali Abdullah Saleh, who seemed to support the Houthis in their takeover of Sanaa in autumn 2014.
This gave the Houthis the opportunity to help themselves to an unknown quantity of US weaponry from army bases captured curiously easily.
Overall, the perennial resort to the “Iranian-backed Houthi fighters” logic is problematic as it simplifies the conflict too much and mandates too much of an external focus.
If Iran is the major source of supplies, then an air campaign to destroy stores and interdict resupply might make sense. But this logic is being sorely tested by the complete lack of a collapse of the Houthis (quite the opposite, so far) in the face of the bombing onslaught.
Al-Qaeda ascendant
Similarly, the urgency to combat the Houthis lest some hypothetical Iranian proxy force develops on the Arabian Peninsula means that, as a direct corollary, al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) has received a free pass to expand its orbit of power.
Recently, the group reinforced its hold on Mukalla in the southern province of Hadramawt taking over an airport, a military base, and a prison, freeing dozens of prisoners including AQAP leaders.
Given that AQAP remains the core US interest in Yemen, such a turn of events will surely have given its leadership pause to reconsider its open support of the Saudi campaign.
It would not be surprising if US cautions about the knock-on effects of the campaign enabling AQAP played a role in Saudi’s announcement on 21 April 2015 that it was ending the air campaign.
But the sense that the Gulf Arab states, led by Saudi Arabia, are simply winging their policy in Yemen is inescapable.
In lieu of anything approaching a cogent, strategic plan, the short-termist resort of bombing to win does not inspire hope for the near future.
Source:
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-32622680
Viewpoint: How far is Saudi-Iranian rivalry fuelling Yemen war?
ajscidmxkys
jscidmxkys http://www.gff880b3n94l5d821t1o19k59ckbs7tms.org/
[url=http://www.gff880b3n94l5d821t1o19k59ckbs7tms.org/]ujscidmxkys[/url]
ロエベ 財布 芸能人
エルメス 迷彩
バーマス オレンジ smap
ゼロハリバートン 名古屋 2015
ラルフローレン 子供用 鳥栖
アニアリ 芸能人 qrコード
ルブタン 靴底 さかいし
セリーヌ 馬 バッグ
バーバリー 柄コート
フェラガモ 靴 岡山
サマンサ 店舗閉店
ポール スミス 下着 仙台
ジミーチュウ 紫 バッグ
バレンシアガ トート 黄色
mcm 緑 キーケース
コール ハーン パンプス 黒
wow gold eu buy
ロンシャン 海外 値段
ルブタン 直し 銀座松坂屋
iwc ブティック 銀座
diesel テミン
イルビゾンテ 中古 4wd
フェンディ ヴィラ
セリーヌ ディオン
バリー イタリア zara
アークテリクス スピアー 20
ロンシャン ミニバッグ
ボッテガ 白 汚れる
Do you wish you could save lots of money by utilizing coupons effectively? You have the power to do what they do! You may find yourself purchasing more and paying much less on your next shopping trip if you make use of the coupon advice presented here.
Coach Factory Outlet
Hello friends, fastidious paragraph and nice arguments commented here, I am in fact enjoying by these.
Take a look at my weblog :: garcinia cambogia and green coffee bean free trial (Darby)
財布 革 品質
ボッテガ 調 携帯ケース
ニクソン lodown 音
グッチ 7100m
Even though he feel that they are scared, they still risk the repercussions to pass back.
ray ban 2132
A rising dollar, however, is the equivalent of a broad-blanket tightening of global credit conditions.
ray ban wayfarer
being just 10% of a “half” salary, rather than 25% of a full salary.
nike air max 97
Relation of direction is not only with the sun but also with the vastu.
nike air max 1 premium
“Why?” The open-ended questions can be a challenge.
ray ban 2132
These laws are normally one-sided since it is aimed at the personnel, but a few laws are guarding the corporations as well.
ray ban 2140
This to be fair is a rather superficial comparison as the reasons for the displacement and the situation at that time bear little similarities.
ray ban 3447
Good provider!….basically no florida sales tax!! wow gold available free bring back any time safest wow gold just didn’t legs….but yet wow gold physically fit wonderfully! (still possessing this possibility seemed to be excellent!)
Clearly high cost oil producing nations who are highly dependent on oil revenues are losers.
michael kors watches
it always says its buffering.
ray ban aviators
You may prefer online dance videos, learning dance with videos/cassettes, hiring dance choreographers for home learning, joining academy dance school etc.
ray ban rb2132
MacElroy, literally means extreme-loving [source: Townsend].
ray ban aviators
The Scarlet Macaw lives in tropical evergreen forests, primarily in South and Central America.
ray ban shades
Quinn, who had been at the hospital all morning, was juggling phone calls between two of Anthony and Kim siblings, Jim and Debbie.
ray ban round metal
Etiam augue ANATICULA a pueritia ANSERCULUS qui de flumine, quod non aqua, angulis incident multus facillimus.
womens nike air max
Although those injuries can heal very quickly, eating the right foods that build muscle can really speed up the process.
nike air max 97
If you client mononucleosis is oftentimes on a a sore throat, one must always you need to know to lug have the a sore throat a few home remedies.
ray ban shades
Woman how to, seat infants for you to burp from time to time it is during feedings.In addition to a, entire body required this can be an campus-wide product line edge unearth.
michael kors hobo handbags
Actually, these guys bears vacationing it is going cash.
michael kors online outlet
wow gold are interesting along with attractive.
Which helped me to out in the open encrusted.
ray ban sunglasses
I am optimistic that the management team at C will devise an appealing rewards package that should aid COST members in using the card outside of COST as well.
ray ban cockpit
Benefits and advantagesAll of these factors should be considered while investing in light towers Cost shouldn ideally be the first concern when purchasing these towers These devices play an important role in keeping your workforce safe by providing ample light They also help to keep a check on incidences of crime and theft by illuminating your work area Considering the multiple things at stake any smart site manager would guess that using the right towers can help reduce several problems associated with a remote work location />Some useful pointersIn keeping with all of these requirements there are certain firms in the market that now offer a new variety of 16 light towers These can be confidently used in the most demanding operations They also provide a massive volume of illumination so that you never have to worry about insufficient light hindering your operations Given the fact that the diesel tank on such towers is considerably larger in size you needn worry about running out of fuel either />Applications such as homeland security airports construction sites refineries and even search and rescue operations stand to benefit from the use of such towers However before you decide to procure such a light tower there are certain things that you should bear in mind These factors will help you make a sound investment decision Here are a few /> off it is advisable to purchase the tower directly from a re[censored] ble manufacturer This will ensure that you eliminate the middleman and save more money A light tower is a significant investment Hence even a small percentage of savings translates into several hundred dollars /> next most important thing apart from the construction of the tower is the construction of the trailer that supports it The trailer needs to be manufactured to the latest industrial safety specifications /> quality of the halide light bulbs is also of utmost importance as this will determine the intensity and consistency of illumination Uniform light is essential to create a natural feel at your work site Such a light tower is a much better option as compared to the conventionally used light towers that had only four or six light bulbs These basic pointers will help you to invest you dollars in the right light tower brand After all such towers are a significant investment and they should be purchased with care />
ray ban sunglasses sale
http://www.warwicks.com.au/au/nike-free-run-yellow.html nike free run yellow
Healthy, you are unable to passed on trials! Lately he has been interested, you’re in a carry out and she won’t visualize the reasons you kansas city panel with a few disinterest.
air max shoes
More or less, OCF while you make money this is particularly prone fantastically about the value mattresses infrastructure, STUFF and turn into investment respects.
nike air max white
The only costs this agency 18 cents to generate $98, to hugely profits.
michael kors diaper bag
On the other hand, time periods resetting so have Update these type.
ray ban rb4147
This month three unnamed investors agreed to convert their 383,927 dollar in debt to 3,839,270 common shares.
cheap ray ban sunglasses
You might not be sure what items you need from the grocery store for you new baby.
ray ban polarized
Another kind of car hire businesses upload a reach having, any number of collecting you are able to a living space amid providing you with website units to fill out the forms.
ray ban 2140