سیکولر لبرل دوست اورعاشورہ – علی ناطق
ایک سوال مرے ذہن میں کئی سال سے ہے پر کوئی جواب نہیں ملا. پچھلے سال بھی میں نے یہ سوال دوستوں سے پوچھا پر کوئی خاطر خواہ جواب نہ ملا. سوال ہمارے سیکولر لبرل دوستوں سے ہے. ہر سال مختلف مذاہب اور کمیونٹیز کے اہم دن آتے ہیں جیسے کرسمس، دیوالی، گرپورب، دسہرہ وغیرہ. ہمارے دوست بہت اچھا کرتے ہیں کہ یہ تہوار منانے کیلئے ہندو، مسیحی، سکھ بھائیوں کا یا تو ساتھ دیتے ہیں یا کم سے کم انکو مبارکی پیغام ضرور دیتے ہیں. بہت اچھی بات ہے.
نہ تو کرسمس منانے کیلئے آپکو مسیحی ہونا پڑتا ہے نہ دیوالی کی مبارک کیلئے ہندو مذہب پر یقین لانا پڑتا ہے اور نہ ہی گرپورب یا دسہرہ کا پرساد کھاتے وقت آپ کسی مذہب یا عقیدہ کو تسلیم کرتے ہیں. تو سوال یہ بنتا ہے کہ آپکے ہی ملک کے چار کروڑ لوگوں کے کیلنڈر میں سال کا سب سے اہم دن عاشور ہوتا ہے . اس دن بجائے تعزیتی پیغام اور عزاداری میں ٹوکن شرکت کے بجائے آپ سب کو نام نہاد سیکولرزم، مذہب مخالفت اور عجیب و غریب دانشوری کے دورے کیوں پڑتے ہیں؟
Comment by Abdul Nishapuir: I agree. Moreover, token greeting or condolence is less important than refraining from attacking and criticizing the Ashura rituals of Shias, Sunni Sufis, Hindus, Sikhs and Christians. This is not only a part of faith but also very much a part of local culture which should be appreciated and respected. Those who show humanity and kindness on Divali and Christmas should not lose their humanity on Meelad and Ashura.
I think most of the occasions are that of happineess.It is quite natural to participate in such festivals.Who wants to get involved in grieving for something that happened centuries ago.?
Shia forefathers in kofa in iraq betrayed hazrat imam hussain alaih salam. So now they beat themselves. Best way to remember the prophet and his grandsons is to send darood wo salam as billion of sunni send on ali rasool in prayers. Leave yar these kharafat and bidaat as islam never said to beat yourself since hazrat Adam alaih salam. Many prophets and great companions of prophets got martyrs since hazrat adam but in history no prophet preached to beat yourself and run horses. Is the shahadat of hazrat hussain alaih salam teaches you bidaat. Astaghfirullah. Fana mangta hu shia-teen sai
Dr muhammad shoaib.sb
i am very sorry to address you. but infact it is my responsibly to address.
that we the people of jaffria sect act upon the sunnah of hazrat Muhammad (S.A.W). This is the sunnah of prophet to propitiate the azadari ,any how you you the poeple are using the name of sunnis and i don’t know how omit the sunnah of prophet .
Dr Shoaib, usual nasibi nonsense the sole purpose of your comment is to deflect from the crimes of your real ancestors Yazid and his disgraced father Muavia, Glorious son of Ali (as) left madina in broad daylight with no one willing to stand with him, Hussain (as) lived in Mecca for six months and addressed the ummat everyday at Kaaba and left hajj on 8th zilhaj with only two people joining him. This was the reign of terror perpetrated by the bastard son and grandson of Hinda. Then came Karbala where 100 of 123 shaheeds of Karbala were from Kufa, who broke the siege of the savage sub-human ibné ziyad laeen and made it to Karbala for the nusrat of their Imam (as) every single Muslim living in madina, Mecca or who came to hajj of 60 Hijra bears the responsibility of not joining Rasool Allah’s son. People of Kufa have the glorious distinction of being the first one to repent and stand up against the filthy reign of ummayads. The Kufan movement of “tawwabeens” is a heroic chapter of human consciousness while the rest of the so-called Islamic world was busy licking the feet of Yazid the bastard. Your appalling ignorance of history and derogation of quranic principle of Tauba is only indicative of your not-so-hidden hatred of shia, who to this date remind you and your fellow cowards that how for 1400 yrs you have betrayed Rasool Allah (as) and how you keep inventing these smoke screens to obfuscate your crimes and that of your real ancestors, may Allah curse you for your hypocrisy
exactly
Dada Amir Haedar, Hasan Nasir, Ali Zahir Shiya hotey hoovey inhon ne AASHOORA ke liye Kia kiya ? Mohtaram aaj ka surkha choori khaney wala MAJNOON hae, Zanjir-Zani ki tawaqqo abas hae, Shayad aap ne bhi nahin ki ho gi aaj tak !!!