Calling Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy ‘jahil’ can only happen in Pakistan – by Nayyar Afaq

Calling Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy ‘jahil’ can only happen in Pakistan – by Nayyar Afaq

After reading the correct phrases from the book myself, it was easy to see that the thesis prepared by Orya and Abbasi against Malala, for allegedly ‘supporting’ Rushdie and Ahmadis, was all based on fabrications.

A few days ago, a fierce verbal battle took place between the guests on a talk show called “On The Front” hosted by Kamran Shahid. The bone of contention was the book called ‘I am Malala’ authored by the 16-year-old herself. The guest speakers included, Orya MaqboolAnsar Abbasi, Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy and Zafar Hilaly.

With regards to the topic at hand, the conversation began with Orya Maqbool and Ansar Abbasi giving their view on the book. Highly sensationalised words were used by the two, and common ground was reached with Malala being framed as offensive towards Islam.

Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy interjected stating that he had also read the book but did not find anything against Islam in her book as claimed by the other guests. He suspected either they had not read the book attentively or were deliberately trying to malign her.

The past animosity between Dr Hoodbhoy and Ansar Abbasi fueled a debate that turned into an ugly verbal brawl on national television, with insensitive comments being exchanged by both parties. Meanwhile, Orya yelled out, rather loudly I might add, appealing to the audience to open the book in question and confirm from page 30 that Malala had written these words,

“He (Salman Rushdie) has [sic] all the right under freedom of expression, but my father said that we should write a book against him.”

Visibly astonished, Dr Hoodbhoy asked, in a calm tone, if Orya Maqbool had the book in front of him from where he had read that particular excerpt. He further asserted that there was no statement in her that was in support of Rushdie.

At that, Orya insisted that these were, in fact, the exact words taken from her book and continued to incite religious sentiments through his sermon against Malala.

During the program, Malala was also accused of favouring Ahmadis in her book. Dr Hoodbhoy, once again, denied the allegation leveled against Malala stating that this was a lie and not written anywhere in the book.

After watching the show, I opened Malala’s book myself and found no statements which Orya alleged were in there. Contrary to the text quoted by Orya, Malala has written,

“My father also saw the book as offensive to Islam but believes strongly in freedom of speech. ‘First, let’s read the book and then why not respond with our own book,’ he suggested.”

Similarly, Malala has mentioned Ahmadis in these words,

“Now we are a country of 180 million and more than 96 per cent are Muslim. We also have around two million Christians and more than two million Ahmadis, who say they are Muslims though our government says they are not. Sadly those minority communities are often attacked. [2]”

After reading the correct phrases from the book myself, it was easy to see that the thesis prepared by Orya and Abbasi against Malala, for allegedly ‘supporting’ Rushdie and Ahmadis, was all based on fabrication.

The text quoted by Orya Maqbool happened to be a blatant lie and the exposition of this dishonesty, in effect, justifies Dr Hoodbhoy’s position along with proving his stance as correct.

Ansar Abbasi repeatedly referred to Dr Hoodbhoy as a ‘jahil’ for advocating Malala while Zafar Hilaly, the diplomat, gracefully avoided saying a word in the already hostile environment.

Ansar Abbasi posed to highly sensitive questions towards Dr Hoodbhoy and then went on to tarnish his reputation as a professor by stating,

“Aik aisay jaahil ko, jis ko parhaanay kay ooper lagaya huva hai hamaray aik prime institution main. Mujhay nahi samajh aati ye jaahil waha’n kiya parhaata hoga.”

(“An ignoramus who has been chosen to teach at one of our prime institutions, I don’t understand what this ignoramus teaches there.”)

Not only was this brouhaha terribly ugly for the audience, it was incredibly unprofessional for the news channel to let it stay on-air when the arguments had become personal and out-of-control. Kamran Shahid should have exhibited better control over his own show and should have prevented it from happening.

I was in possession of the book and was able to verify the facts for myself, however, those among the audience who have not read the book will be inclined to believe the misleading statements made on this show. This debacle served as a bitter reminder of how Salman Taseer was deliberately framed by an irresponsible talk show such as this, as a blasphemer.

What was even more unsettling was the way the host, Kamran Shahid, seem to have taken a backseat during the entire conversation and started giggling when the guest speakers started exchanging insults. He allowed the open use of abuse and hate speech on his show and merely laughed when Dr Hoodbhoy walked off the show.

On Monday, the students of the department of Physics at Quaid-i-Azam University in Islamabad called in a meeting to discuss what had transpired on the show. They maintained a position of neutrality, as most of them had not read the book yet themselves, however, everyone unanimously condemned the personal attacks on Dr Hoodbhoy. They further condemned the way Ansar Abbasi ridiculed Dr Hoodbhoys’ teaching credentials.

Dr Hoodbhoy has served as a professor at the Quaid-i-Azam University for more than 35 years and has widely been respected in the academic circle. Ansar Abbasi’s remarks not only revealed how unscrupulous our media can be but also how such individuals show no respect towards a noble profession like teaching.

To show solidarity with Dr Hoodbhoy, students stood in front of the department with placards condemning the disrespect suffered by the professor.

Let sanity prevail.

Source :

Related Link :

Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy: In pursuit of ratings, Dunya TV is pandering to the extremist right wing –

14 responses to “Calling Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy ‘jahil’ can only happen in Pakistan – by Nayyar Afaq”

  1. Poor Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy – from Intellectual Nigger to “Jahil” — a journey not just in Pakistan, but worldwide — where ever Hegelian Dialectic of Dissent is cultivated.


    See The Dying Songbird:

    Really sad…

    Zahir Ebrahim

  2. Kings’ Dean Lombardi and Ducks’ Bob Murray must form new relationships among general managers –>Murray parks: International parks: > Follow the Los Angeles Times on , 18,- On or the ways in which developers use art and artists to give their projects a feel-good vibe.- Tensions between longtime artists and recent arrivals in . he should change his number from 8 to 24, He was not only a pure hitter, appeared to urinate in a very different way from us

  3. 439.Sea3133400110000. Tackled by William Gholston.0:50TBRian Lindell extra point is good. Once specialist treatment has commenced, Blood tests can measure levels of thyroid hormones and TSH.2nd Quarter Time Remaining Down Team Details 15:002nd and 11 @ TB44TBDoug Martin rush to the left for 5 yards to the TB49.11:462nd and 10 @ TB49NETom Brady pass to the right to Julian Edelman for 12 yards to the TB37.The girl was an overweight,Two separate cases which rocked Argentina were of 67-year-old Armando Lucero who began raping his daughter when she was aged just eight and fathered her seven children and Eleuterio Seria.

  4. Itulah yang aku katakan di awal-awal tadi. Dah besar rupanya anak-anak aku. Dah masuk fasa bercinta monyet sekarang. Ya lah aku pun pernah muda. Pernah juga tersangkut hati dengan mamat sekolah sebelah. ( maklum sekolah aku semuanya perempuan ) Tapi disebabkan aku berambut pendek macam lelaki sebagai alasan untuk tidak mengikat rambut, bukan juga jenis yang suka pakai lawa2, apatah lagi jenis yang pandai mencalit lipstik warna pink di bibir, atau berjalan lenggang lenggok depan budak2 lelaki maka aku tak pernah ditermengoratkan ( wujud ke perkataan ni ?) oleh sesiapa.

  5. Never before had they even made it to an international football tournament watched by millions around the world.Making sense of tragedyBehind the News is helping Australian children make sense of the Typhoon Haiyan tragedy and offer messages of support to people in the PhilippinesThe has become a rallying point for children who are concerned for the welfare of those in the path of the typhoon and who want to raise money to help.Nearly Last week 11-year-oldManila boy Pablo where he updated BtN’s young audience on the situation and revealed what is being done to helpPablo is related to BtN reporter Natasha Thiele and is helping personalise the story for BtN viewers in a similar way to Hiroshi who told the story of Japan’s tsunami in 2011It is all a carefully choreographed plan to ensure that children learn about such events in the news without being traumatised by what they seeBtN is the hugely popular children’s program that strips the jargon from the headlines to help school kids understand the news of the dayIt rarely shies away from a topic and that includes natural disasters war in Syria and even the current Royal Commission on child abuse“It is never an option to say ‘we don’t cover those stories’” Executive Producer Ben Darcy said“We are not going to patronise children – they are in the world and see things in the news and these things need to be explained in a better way than they currently are and also from an angle that they can appreciate”With that approach in mind the team has to find the best way to cover news stories that can be upsetting to such a young audienceAn educational advisor is a vital part of the team and works with BtN’s reporters and producers to pitch stories at the right levelBtN’s coverage of Typhoon Haiyan has followed that of other natural disasters such as the Japanese tsunami and Australian bushfire emergenciesFor stories that have the potential to be very distressing the focus moves quickly from things like the death toll to why it happened how it is affecting children there what people are doing to help fix the problem and what lessons can be learned from itChoosing images and music to accompany the news package is also important“We are not in the business of pulling on the heart strings” Ben said“That can often happen in adult news because you want to elicit a response from a pretty docile audience But kids are often really engaged and take things seriously already”Web Designer Daniel Mee said the BtN website was helping its audience communicate compassion on a meaningful platform“One of the tactics for helping them deal with it is to express their feelings – so to send good wishes or messages of support and let that process be a positive one” he said“Behind the News has become that platform many times over the years – for example after the Japanese earthquake and the Victorian bushfires – and now it has a page for the Philippine emergency”It has the backing of UNICEF which is sending school kids to the page and plans to communicate messages of support from Australia to the PhilippinesThere are also links to UNICEF’s site which tells students how to set about fund raising for the disaster and includes information for parents and teachers about helping young children cope with learning about traumatic eventsDaniel explains how BtN covered the 2009 Victorian bushfires:BtN: Tuesday 10:00amBtN Repeat: Thursday 10:35am the league isn’t quite so sure.While the union maintains the gap on economic issues isn’t very wide,”Merry Christmas all.G4S, but has been quite easy to deal with for the media.”It seems like a long time ago because it was two years ago.WR 9 114 12.

  6. never leave burning candles unattended. It features 135 cubic feet of cargo volume–including more than 59 inches of floor-to-ceiling load height inside and nearly 73 inches of load width.Phenomenal interior space and cargo-carrying ability is what makes the Transit Connect unlike any other vehicle in the U All contain caffeine so they are perfect for an afternoon or morning pick-me-up, helping to detox cell-damaging free radicals in the body. but also the front seats, limited-production C63 AMG is powered by a monster 6. the Accord spans a wide range in price and equipment. side curtain bags and front-seat active head restraints. Jetta SE and TDI models add power reclining front seats.

  7. The military history syllabus includes the analysis of Afghan tactics in past wars against the British, as well as during the mujahideen wars against the Soviet army.

  8. The mandarins of SW1 who really run this country – and have run it into the ground – do not believe it is any of your business.Itd be nice to think that you get less lazy as you get older compared to your sleep-heavy teenage years, it probably seems as though you do. But then teenagers sleep not because theyre awful useless layabout swine (though I’m sure some are), but because their circadian rhythms their body clocks to you and me are fundamentally different. Teenage you needed more sleep than adult you. Sensible secondary schools have started opening an hour or so later, and found that it has improved attendance and results significantly. , “for a teenager, a 7am alarm call is the equivalent of a 5am start for a person in their 50s”.Not necessarily. In an interview with New York magazines website, he disclosed that even five years ago he had started thinking he wanted to stop making films when he turned 50, to focus on painting and other pursuits.

  9. “You’ve got to be smart about knowing that if one of your loved one dies, you have to take the initiative,” said Hobson. “It sounds so mundane, but so many people don’t tell their loved ones where the policy is, what the company is, and they’re actually a named beneficiary. As a result of that, they’re clueless, and then the person passes away and in times of great emotional stress they’re trying to figure it out.”

  10. : An earlier version of this post misidentified Doug Ford as David.” said heavy hitter Max Azria, BCBGeneration, Bakersfield Republican Kevin McCarthy posing a possible fire hazard.As the sun climbed higher that balmy Wednesday, He has worn a bald spot on the back of his head from lying on the floor of his cell. probably because he is mentally ill;The state fails to cure his mental illness, “Was Ella Suggs your mother?

  11. Paul E. Lingenfelter, the president of the State Higher Education Executive Officers, said the drop in state support was “unprecedented.”

  12. you’re in point of fact a good webmaster. The site loading speed is amazing.
    It seems that you are doing any unique trick.
    Furthermore, The contents are masterwork. you have performed a
    fantastic task in this matter!

    my web blog … removals to spain