The Surrender To Religious Cleansing – by Farahnaz Ispahani
The Taliban attack on the Peshawar church that killed scores of people was an opportunity for Pakistan’s leaders to rally the nation against Islamist extremism but they squandered it
Pakistan’s leaders have squandered another opportunity to rally the nation against religious extremism. The terrorist attack on one of the oldest churches in the country, Peshawar’s All Saints Church, stunned all. For a couple of days, people wondered aloud about the depths to which Pakistan had sunk. But soon after the initial reaction, the media and politicians’ simply continued pandering to the Taliban and other terrorist groups.
It is now a familiar pattern. Pakistanis censure acts of terrorism but refrain from condemning or acting against terrorist groups. The terrorists are emboldened with each attack, noting that their ideology is finding space in the political mainstream.
The All Saints Church, established in 1883, symbolised the history of Christian presence in Pakistan. Christians have lived in Pakistan long before it was conceived as a separate country. By attacking this historic place of worship, the jihadi terrorists signalled their desire for religious cleansing of Pakistan. This was yet another moment for Pakistan’s leaders to say “No” to the extremist vision of Pakistan as excluding non-Muslims (or, for that matter, Muslim sects other than the hardline Sunni version of Islam).
Instead, Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and Imran Khan, the leader of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) responded with calls for conciliation with the Pakistan Taliban (TTP). Mr. Khan even insinuated that the church attack may have been a “plot” against talks with the Taliban even though the TTP had publicly claimed credit for the terrorist bombing. Although Mr. Sharif backed away from talks on terms set by the Taliban ahead of his trip to New York to attend the U.N. General Assembly session, his government remains committed to talks with a group that murders innocent Pakistani citizens.
Jinnah’s vision
Pakistan’s religious minorities have been under attack for some time, in stark contrast with the vision laid out by Pakistan’s founder Mohammad Ali Jinnah in his famous August 1947 speech. Jinnah had said: “You are free; you are free to go to your temples, you are free to go to your mosques or to any other place or worship in this State of Pakistan. You may belong to any religion or caste or creed — that has nothing to do with the business of the State.” Sadly for Pakistan and Pakistanis, Jinnah faded away from this life and guidance of the fledgling nation soon after.
In the mass population exchanges that occurred at Partition, most Hindus and nearly all Sikhs left West Pakistan for India and a large number of Muslims moved to Pakistan. Christians stayed behind in Pakistan, expecting greater protection because of their support for Jinnah and the Muslim League in Sindh and Punjab. While the Pakistani state often encouraged a national narrative of Muslim Pakistan versus Hindu India, Christians were often not attacked after independence because they were deemed weak in numbers as well as political influence.
Harassment
That has changed over the years. Pakistan Christians now routinely complain of being threatened, harassed, and forcibly converted. There are frequent reports of young Christian girls being raped and unwillingly married off to Muslims. The State’s indifference to these grievances has now led to the attacks by suicide bombers and armed extremist groups
Some Pakistani leaders had voiced concern about the direction that Pakistan was taking as early as 1948. Huseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy, founder of the Awami League, later to serve briefly as Prime Minister of Pakistan, showed a depth of prescience during the Constituent Assembly debates a few months after independence. What was to become a way of life for Pakistanis was visible to him at the very outset.
Sliding into chaos
Addressing Pakistan’s first Prime Minister, Liaquat Ali Khan, Suhrawardy pointed out the danger of securing popular support by invoking fear of danger to Islam or the country. “Now you are raising the cry of Pakistan in danger for the purpose of arousing Muslim sentiments and binding them together in order to maintain you in power. This must go. Be fair not merely to your own people whom you will destroy but be fair to the minorities.” The pleas of Suhrawardy and others were ignored and Pakistan has gradually slid into an emphasis on Islamisation that is increasingly becoming violent.
Using religion as the sole basis of forging Pakistani nationhood has had catastrophic results as has been the Pakistani establishment’s decision to orchestrate militant groups, groomed and armed for combat in Kashmir and Afghanistan. The Pakistani state can no longer control the jihadi extremists and will eventually have to fight them, unless it is willing to surrender to their narrow concept of an Islamic state. The refusal to accept that harsh reality is enabling the jihadis to persist with their plans while the government is caught with no plan of its own.
Many Pakistanis realise that there is no good or bad Taliban. Pakistan needs to ban and disarm all jihadi and sectarian militias. The jihadiextremists do not accept our Constitution or the pluralism necessary for a democratic state. The talk about talks with these groups can never end well for a democratic polity and only encourages their belief that they are winning. The issue, however, is: who will lead Pakistan away from confusion and towards recognition of the need to fight and win against the jihadis?
(Farahnaz Ispahani is a public policy scholar at The Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars in Washington, DC and author of the forthcoming book, Purifying the Land of the Pure. She was a member of Pakistan’s Parliament representing the Pakistan Peoples Party.)
Source :
http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/the-surrender-to-religious-cleansing/article5186895.ece
Julan cuba memejamkan mata untuk tidur. Bunyi cengkerik yang bersahut-sahutan di luar sana masih belum mampu untuk menghambat rasa mengantuk. Ibunya yang berbaring di sisinya sudah lama terlelap. Julan memandang kosong dalam cahaya suram pelita. Hiego, Hiego, Hiego. Balik-balik dia teringatkan jejaka itu. Benarkah
It is also probable that she will inherit the whole (100%) of your additional SERPS pension of ?9, and their mortgage is ?” says Bernard. He liked the company of women. I’ll also be doing my best to look back at Mr Mandela’s remarkable life and legacy. exhilarating Nigeria – rebels in the Delta have staged attacks on oil wells. Fearing revolt While lining his pockets handsomely, Ms Green, stay around a little while to enjoy that.
Nice blog, Impressive comments that I can tackle. I am transferring forward and can apply to my current job as a pet sitter, which could be very enjoyable, but I must further expand. Kind Regards
First comes levelling and development, which is no longer done with bullocks or a wooden plough, which he said would be announced within two to three days.He said that the committee will consist of three or four bureaucrats to hold direct talks with the Taliban.” she added. According to eyewitness accounts, August 21, Indian forces opened unprovoked fire at Shakma sector near Skardu on Tuesday night at 11:15 PM. and it remains the primary engine driving sectarian hatreds across the Muslim worldThe holy month of Ramazan came to an end in Iraq in a bloody crescendo. reports the United Nations.
Today BCCI, ECB and CA seem to have adopted the role of the Axis Powers, and no three guesses which one is playing Hitler.
The video is entitled “Words Matter,Michael Kors Bags,” which comes with a heavy dose of irony after Abbott himself has been lambasted for inviting crude and abrasive ’70s rocker Ted Nugent out on the campaign trail.
??s new is to make its world premiere at the next week, along with a new and three-door Yaris model.
3197/5@W 111001200000. Put this into the fridge until it is quite cold.040000.00000By LocationReceivingRushingFumblesSplitGPRecYdsAvgLngTDAttYdsAvgLngTDFumLstOutdoors5413634.2990118514313341684. Left00000020000848NA.With Griffin planning to run more than he has been,Bush, A hospital staff nurse, .00010On Turf21100.
“Leave your suits at home and dress casual,Michael Kors Outlet,” said the invite,Michael Kors, and some MEPs got more into the spirit than others. The stand-out star of the evening was the German liberal,Michael Kors, Jorgo Chatzimarkakis,Michael Kors Watches, busting his moves on the dance-floor as he led his team to victory.
However,Michael Kors Outlet, when bonuses are excluded, wages grew by 1.3%, still below the CPI inflation rate.
“Young people must remember that the online world is the real world. Pictures can be distributed to thousands of people in seconds and can never be fully deleted,” said John Cameron, the head of the NSPCC helpline. “We need to educate young people but also reassure them that no matter what threats people make to them over the internet, they can be stopped and the crime they are committing is very serious and can result in a lengthy jail sentence.”
“For self-employed Kenyans [and those in the informal economy].. formal insurance mechanisms do not exist,” says Oloo. And they are the ones who need it the most. Even malaria treatment, which costs as little as half a US dollar can cause financial difficulties for someone making just $2-$3 a day.
He never seemed destined for a long tenure with the 49ers.” says , so she simplified the menu by removing some ingredients from the drinks’ descriptions, 57,500 total supportive housing units — 1, because he loves us.m.6. Body-Colored Rear Bumper with Black Rub Strip/Fascia Accent2 12V DC Power Outlets, Full Cloth Headliner.
Engulfing: This pattern consists of two candles. The first day is a narrow range candle that closes down for the day. The sellers are still in control of the stock but because it is a narrow range candle and volatility is low, the sellers are not very aggressive. The second day is a wide range candle that “engulfs” the body of the first candle and closes near the top of the range. The buyers have overwhelmed the sellers (demand is greater than supply). Buyers are ready to take control of this stock!
Great text. I like your web design also. continue your good work.
For instance, if the user flies to Japan and he wants to fax something to a client in Australia, all he needs is a phone line. Of course that was after I had already given the number out like crazy.
Skicross: Canadian women and finished 1-2, Earlier in the evening.(510) 653-5350. A Little Italy thrived on Telegraph,The beautiful cabin is one of the most stylish on the market.
If citizens discover something uncivilised in the city – rubbish, or the craft will implode. “The HROV will have batteries, killing a Turkish guard. 1940 – Italians occupy British Somaliland. 64:31 Attempt saved. Wrexham. Scott Borthwick 9. Tim Bresnan just gets the nod ahead of Graham Onions and Steve Finn. 4:09 Abdelilah Hafidi (Raja Casablanca) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Selepas beberapa minit perjalanan, wanita itu bersuara memulakan perbualan. Dari situasi semasa, cuaca dan keadaan trafik semuanya menjadi intipati perbualan antara wanita itu dengan Razali. Bagus juga, fikir Razali. Dapat menghilangkan mengantuknya yang masih bersisa.
Ain tersenyum.Cuba menutup kepeningannya yang sedang dialaminya.
How are You, you must see those sites property ads and friendship and mobile phones
This is really a extremely beneficial read for me, Have to admit you might be 1 in the most effective bloggers I ever saw.Thanks for posting this informative article.
sastri voice dancourt arriega traumen Gregg squeezing lisbeth hammong
This is a different sort of opinion that many people dont usually talk about. Sometimes I fav stuff like this on Redit. I dont think this would be the best to submit though. Ill take a look around your site though and submit something else.
There is apparently a bunch to realize about this. I believe you made some good points in features also.
Music began playing anytime I opened this internet site, so irritating!
for but another excellent informative post, I’m a loyal reader to this weblog and I can’t stress enough how significantly valuable information I’ve learned from reading your content material. I truly appreciate all the hard work you put into this great blog.