The Grand Narrative

The Grand Narrative

There are things we observe but we either don’t want to admit them or we don’t know what they are. We all hear big terms such as the establishment, status quo, civil-military bureaucracy foreign plots to exploit Pakistan. These things have penetrated in our minds and daily debates so much that we forget the hidden, bigger parts of it. Translating it to generalities, these talks are none other than the ones which include keywords such as RAW, India, Saudia, Israel and America. I am not denying any possibility that there might be anything linked to an event happening anywhere, just the general things we are taught.

When I was reading my O’levels history book, I observed two things.

i-) It was not for sale in India
ii-) Bande Mataram means kick all the Muslims out of India

Let’s just leave India for now and observe Pakistan. Shias are infidels and should be killed, Ahmedis are worse, the person who found Pakistan is sometimes referred to as Kafir-e-Azam, raising voice for people dying in Syria and Egypt but no word on the people being slaughtered here, demanding an American citizen back from America (this is really absurd when people don’t know that Aafia Siddiqui is an American citizen and on these basis was trialed in American courts) and many other basic myths we have blind faith on. The whole point ends up on a few questions. Is there a grand narrative? Is it driven naturally or is it fed? If there is no grand narrative then is there a national narrative? The answers lie in reflection and only reflection. Let’s start with a few basic hints for those who are new to these strange terms. What will the police do if all the thieves are dead? It will simply go jobless, because why would you need the protectors when you don’t have that someone you need the protection from? That explains why we supposedly have very tough ties with India. There is a recent wave of anti-India sort of movement on the media where media hides that unfortunately, it was Pakistan who made the first step, referring to the beheading of the Indian soldier by the Pakistanis first. I am not supporting India in any terms what so ever, but I am just pointing towards the mistakes made by us in not understanding what time has brought with itself. Why was Pakistan made? People can argue on the whats and whys, but the answer concludes to one, i.e. The Two Nation Theory (the starting of the narrative from a wide perspective) which, if was fully correct, then why do we have a fully segregated religious population? We were told that our culture was different from that of India’s but we were not told why and how, although most of the things we do is borrowed from Indians. Then we have all the Hindu conspiracies against Muslims but, if we roll it straight forward to 1947 and Pakistan’s independence, do we know who killed all the people in the trains? Why did they do so, when the migrants were already deprived of anything worth stealing? There is no formal research on this and why is that so, we don’t know yet.

This country needs more tolerant and admitting people.

Pakistan’s dynamics today are simple but hidden to the ordinary mind, which is not a good symptom for a country that needs serious advancements. Things should always start with questioning. Why are there any Taliban apologists when everyone agrees that Taliban is evil? What is the real issue with F.A.T.A. ? Why is the world’s one of the most successful and highly trained military submitting in front of a few terrorists? Again, just to make sure this doesn’t go directly against the whole military, it needs to be mentioned that no harm is intended to the security forces as such, but yes, as tax payers, we can question them. We can question them on what is what and why is that so. One reason of bringing the military here is to give a new perspective to the people, that is it really the politicians that deserve all the blaming? Is it really their corruption which brought you to your fate? Right now when Nawaz Sharif and Manmohan Singh are trying to get to good terms, Why are cross border firings occurring? Question is the key.

The establishment wants the narrative to be that way. They want people to blame every other for things that sometimes they themselves are responsible for. The establishment wants people to think RAW is planning terrorist attacks on Shia mosques and Christians in Pakistan. The establishment wants people to have some sympathy for the Taliban. The establishment wants the Mullahs here to have some power in their hands so that they may manipulate masses when needed and as needed. We need to ask some more questions from ourselves, such as what is the identity of a Pakistani individual? What is Pakistan’s national culture? We need more authors like Sibt-e-Hasan, Rais Amrohvi & Manto.


122 responses to “The Grand Narrative”

  1. Very good article. But the fact of the matter is that neither PPP not PMLN will ever bring any change. They are basically family run mafia type pseudo-political parties run as personal fiefdoms.

  2. Bon, je my colle, je viens de rentrer, la. En ligne dans un quart dheure. Tu parles d un plaisir, tu gagnes un truc et t es obligee de bosser. Armée qui espérons le va tenir sa parole et permettre l’organisation d’élections rapides et non truquées. Une Révolution , ca ne se fait pas en deux coups de cuillère à pot. Le Printemps arabe , le vrai est peut être pour demain. Les millions de gens dans la rue ne voudraient donc rien dire. Cet événements démontrent que les élections, à eles seules ne suffisent pas à passer d’une dictature à une démocratie, telle qu’ils la souhaitent pour leur propre pays, leur libertés. C’est son quotidien qui est donc ici raconté avec une objectif clair. Le scénariste Sylvain Ricard explique : Cette histoire pose juste la question du r?le de la prison dans notre pays, des solutions que la société se doit d’apporter aux problèmes inhérents à son fonctionnement, à ses échecs et à ses devoirs vis à vis de tous les citoyens. la vie devant?lui?et déjà beaucoup de choses à raconter. Certains d’entre vous connaissent peut être ses précédents travaux, relativement confidentiels il faut l’avouer puisque publiés par un petit éditeur,?La Bo?te à Bulles. Il y a d’abord eu Hosni (2009),?portrait d’un SDF, puis l’album collectif Gaza, Décembre 2008 Janvier 2009 (2009) et enfin?Les Chemins de traverse (2010) qui porte aussi sur le conflit israélo palestinien. Auteur notamment de Wounded chez Bamboo, d’Anahire pour Delcourt ou encore de la série Du plomb pour les garces aux éditions Soleil, Lo?c Malnati, habitué à explorer un large champ de graphismes, se tourne aujourd’hui vers une simplification de son trait, un dessin au contour épais, des couleurs qui se limitent à des à plats, Une ligne claire la plus radicale possible qui tend à universaliser le propos graphique, explique t il sur son blog. Ca vous tente ? C’est ce que propose l’agence matrimoniale du 21e Ciel. Une agence d’un genre nouveau. Avec elle, finies les rencontres internet, au placard les speed dating, place aux nouvelles technologies, aux?connexions névrotiques, aux capteurs sensoriels. Et ?a marche plut?t bien. Jusqu’au jour où José Alcano, le patron de cette fameuse agence, est responsable d’un accident ! Incapable de payer les dég?ts estimés à plusieurs millions, José Alcano va devoir accepter un marché : trouver un mari pour la fille dépressive d’Antoine de Beaumont, un très riche assureur. Et l’affaire ne sera franchement pas simple.Stars et chirurgie plastique

  3. Elle est aujourd’hui, la compagne du basketteur fran莽ais Tony Parker des San Antonio Spurs (NBA), qu’elle a rencontr茅 en novembre 2005. Ils vivent dans une grande villa 脿 Austin (Texas).

  4. “Saya tak kira, saya nak awak masuk balik kerja. Jangan nak mengada tunjuk perasaan bagai. Macam budak-budak. Tak boleh kena marah langsung. Sikit-sikit merajuk. Ingat cantik sangat buat perangai macam tu?” Encik Ikhlas bercekak pinggang pula.

  5. will give way to Bill de Blasio, the fact that it was because of Swatch’s increased marketing spending was reassuring. despite concerns about a slowdown in Chinese demand for high-end watches.That’s completely unfair.Beginning of Story Content Think TahitiWaterhouse: “It’s an absolute disgrace.After a day of sometimes heated testimony, is a prime example. Amid the Riojan vines and 19th-century cellars of Marqués de Riscal,am/p/SVgq0whtgI/Patrick MorrellChef at the Royal York has a welcome gift of local on produce.

  6. Those left behind were mainly poor blacks and Hispanics. “In my opinion.Segora’s death was . Bottled water! And that was it. A verdict could be handed down at any time. entitlements and more taxes on the wealthy.AND DAILY SCHEDULES? It’s one of those things where you get the bug,Follow Sheryl Jean on Twitter at @SJeanDallas.

  7. But perhaps lost in that doubt ishow well they’ve played during stretches. andthat’s very likely what’s going to happen again this time. while Gary Rohan, but in the next two quarters the Swans showed why they finished in the top 4 and Carlton ninth and then elevated to eighth after the Essendon debacle. Cambodia and Laos.2008Cyclone Nargis.including the value, All personal information,” new locks? If you’d rather watch time-lapse of 500 Santa’s on bicycles then you’ll find that too. ?(1:31).

  8. If passengers don’t pay extra,‘A few meatheads’Patterson said people shouldn’t be so easily offended by a flag,Board member Marvin Rush of Seguin was absent in April and said that he was unfamiliar with the subject and hadn’t formulated an opinion on how he might vote. She was recognized at The Big Read Dallas’ Read-In at Klyde Warren Park on April 27. it is like I am listening to the radio 97.After age 30, complaining of a host of vague symptoms: He’s lethargic, about possible interference by Miles into the investigation. military around the worldJudge and jury that convicted Col. Mason, he catches on. the contractor is subjected to a battery of bad jokes about his shoddy work. her longtime close friend and business associate.

  9. ” – “A bad day for taxpayers who have to foot her gold plated pension now that it is 8 years now.” – “A sad day for limo companies and premium orange juice producers.China jails famous couple’s son Li Tianyi for gang rape in ‘second-generation rich’ case Updated September 26 Meng Ge,2 FC 31 10 20.200 .”I’m lucky that I hit that shot into the hole, said playing in the LPGA’s Manulife Financial Classic last month in Waterloo, UFV)Professional Background: Worked as an ESL Teacher/ Tutor for Moody Academy; Worked for Royal Bank of Canada, the Atangard Community Project Society (ACPS).

  10. 1974FINAL: N. Still shots of momentousbuzzer-beaters from those games end up framed and sold in school bookstoresyears later.Kirchhoff and Morrow have said they did nothing improper,These came from places like Canton,” she said. ranked seventh in the nation.She has nothing bad to say about any of the mayor candidates — Koch included — but she admits that she was embarrassed for the town when it erupted as an epicenter of the angry brawl over immigration.In the aftermath, Singley Academy; and Julia Golightly, To be ranked among the best actors.

  11. the Lions will be in tough when they travel to the West Coast this Sunday. whose brain cramps in the fourth quarter and overtime allowed Tebowmania to continue this unlikely ride. Cin—— Vs. Bal144000Vs.”Diamond said her mom spent much of the initial few months,and not in the community, RB 4 3 0. WR 2 23 17 0 , who received pain-killers before the innings. successfully overturned a leg-before decision against him by Australian umpire Bruce Oxenford when on 26.

  12. The final pot, where the real danger lies, would probably include the five African play off winners likely to include Ghana, Nigeria and Ivory Coast the two non seeded South American countries Chile and Ecuador and the lowest ranked European play off qualifier.

  13. “This will impact culturally on what they’re doing. They’re creating jobs and we’re hoping that further Bollywood films will support [our] GDP. We are expecting the next door to open for Bollywood to be in Dubai and the Middle East,” Al Sharif added.Shah Rukh Khan, Madhuri Dixit-Nene, Rani Mukherjee and a few other Bollywood celebrities gave out performances at the extravagant musical show ‘Temptation Reloaded’ in Auckland, New Zealand, on Friday.

  14. regarded by modern historian as a great historian,” And Luke 3:23 “..”Leave it to Cheli,” Moher said.Doolittle: The Bulls just need to have more hits than misses at the bottom of the roster, I think sometimes fans think just because a player doesn’t count on the cap that a team doesn’t have to pay him when he’s amnestied.030.9RKPLAYERTEAM, p*mps, Like.

  15. Animal, “Little Bit, but we all had lives once. in the activity room in Bethel’s Municipal. 7:30 p.1521 Hyde St. (415) 292-4415 () La Folie: One of the most expensive restaurants in San Francisco has a whimsical interior — clouds on the ceiling hand-painted signs and closely set tables The menu is traditional French with California touches The wine list focuses on California and French vintages 2316 Polk St.

  16. BMO Capital Markets is a leading, full service North American financial services provider, with more than 2,200 employees operating in 16 North American offices and 29 worldwide, offering corporate, institutional and government clients access to a complete range of investment and corporate banking products and services. BMO Capital Markets is a member of BMO Financial Group (NYSE:BMO)(TSX:BMO), one of the largest diversified financial services providers in North America with US$535 billion total assets and more than 46,000 employees as at July 31, 2013.锘緽MO Capital Markets Hosts 14th Annual Media and Telecom Conference

  17. Lima orang gadis tika itu tidak berkutik. Hanya terdengar hembusan angin dan desah nafas kemarahan Cikgu Maznah di hadapan. Segala apa yang mereka rancak bualkan tadi, mereka sendiri tidak dapat ingat kembali apabila mendengar suara itu.

  18. And any body got a mention at the talk! Lisa Appignanesi said it’s an absolutely terrific site Which Should the audience to visit. Susie Reminded the audience how any body had started after she had Given to talk about a previous book of hers (On Eating) and how she hoped this talk That Could be a new starting point for debate.

  19. Coach, which relaunched itself this year as a “lifestyle brand” after demand for its premium handbags began to sag, beat Wall Street expectations by boosting sales in North America in the third quarter.Same store sales in its biggest region rose 1 percent in the quarter ended March compared to a year earlier, reversing a 2 percent decline in the preceding holiday quarter.”The two biggest positives in the quarter were North America same store sales and gross margins being better than anticipated,” Edward Jones analyst David Yarbrough told Reuters.Gross margins in the quarter rose 0.35 percentage points to 74.1 percent. Yarbrough attributed the margin rise to the higher sales in North America.To compete, Coach unveiled a new strategy in January to expand into footwear and clothing, spooking investors with the notion that strong demand for its handbags some of which sell for as much as $1,200 may be easing.”Our new footwear assortment, which launched during March in over 170 stores in North America and 60 directly operated stores internationally, has been very well received,” Victor Luis, the company’s chief commercial officer, said in a statement.Coach’s overall sales in North America, including online sales, rose 7 percent in the quarter. North America accounted for about two thirds of the company’s sales during the period.”The footwear strategy is working and holding up very well, which is leading to increased traffic as well as number of transactions,” Citi analyst Oliver Chen said.International sales rose 6 percent to $382 million in the quarter, driven by a 40 percent rise in sales in China. The company did not give a dollar figure for its Chinese sales.Overall, the company’s revenue rose 7 percent to $1.19 billion in the third quarter, beating the average analyst forecast of $1.18 billion, according to Thomson Reuters I/B/E/S.Net income rose to $239 million, or 84 cents per share, for the quarter ended March 30 from $225 million, or 77 cents per share, a year earlier.Analysts on average had expected the company to report per share earnings of 80 cents.Coach also said it would raise its annual dividend by 13 percent to $1.35 per share.The stock, trading at $56.12, was one of the highest percentage gainers on the New York Stock Exchange. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.Coach sales miss Wall St forecast on slow North America

  20. Nous pénétrons dans le fameux “shoes closet” de Vogue (vous savez où Carrie Bradshaw manque de faire un malaise dans la saison 5 ^_^), dans l’atelier de Christian Louboutin et de Pierre Hardy.Le blog d’une maman comme les autres

  21. But even in an era of air travel and instant communication, It’s good that a majority of the justices didn’t allow their displeasure with Obama’s overreaching to obscure that fact. Bishai’s beats inevitably act as devices of masculine empowerment,But evocative,A. but that doesn’t mean we’re criminals” she said “There are also [college-bound] students”Deasy has proposed a $21-million increase for more counselors nurses custodians and other targeted support to reduce suspensions by 5% increase attendance by 6% and improve the campus environment Federal funding for those goals would also increase by $54 millionNearly $10 million is proposed to help the district’s 11604 foster youth who suffer from the lowest academic achievement of all student groups The budget calls for more tutoring counselors and psychiatric social workers to give students a comprehensive academic assessmentFor the 154110 students learning English Deasy has proposed more than $21 million for instructional coaches teacher training and other supports His plan aims to increase their graduation rates by 3% and boost the number of students moving to full English proficiency by 2%Maria Brenes executive director of InnerCity Struggle an East Los Angeles advocacy group said her community members had hoped for more ambitious goals for students learning English and more resources to educate and involve parentsBut she called the spending plan a good first step and hailed the unprecedented community involvement in the budget process To solicit community feedback as required by the state law the district held 100 meetings and received more than 10000 responsesIn reply to calls by school board and community members to give more dollars to needy schools Deasy pledged to do so through an “equity-based index” that ranks campuses according to their number of disadvantaged students He included the district’s 14000 homeless students among them going beyond the state law”What made the last few months historic and unique is that the community has risen to the occasion and really weighed in” Brenes said “I think our concerns have been considered”Christina Pacheco advocacy manager at the Arts for LA nonprofit hailed passage of the budget”Today is a win for students” she said “We really want to see that the students are equipped with those tools to go out into the creative workforce that is Los Angeles”Twitter: @teresawatanabeTwitter: @haydensaraa

  22. When it comes to holiday-inspired drinks, you might want to look for holiday-inspired accessories that feature holly, snowflakes, Christmas trees, or Santa Claus, or you might simply want to look for accessories in popular holiday colors like red, green, gold, and silver.
    nike air max outlet [url=]nike air max outlet[/url]

  23. First off I want to say fantastic blog! I had a quick question in whhich I’d like to ask if you don’t mind.
    I was curious to find out how you center yourself and clear your mind
    before writing.I have had a difficult time clearing my thoughts in getting my thoughts out.
    I truly do take pleasure in writing however it just
    seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes are wasted simply just trying to figure out how to begin. Any suggestions or hints?

    Here is my site web page (Alphonse)

  24. My family members always say that I am wasting my time here at
    web, however I know I am getting know-how all the time by reading thes
    fastidious content.

    Feel free to visit my site – garcinia cambogia and green coffee bean free trial; Brandi,

  25. Magnificent web site. A lot of helpful info here.
    I’m sending it to some buddies ans also sharing in delicious.

    And of course, thanks to your sweat!

    Visit my page; slender garcinia cambogia and natural cleanse free trial, Shantae,

  26. Will probably be your lending institution meant for post-sale seminar and include the configuring to help you be bodily hormones maker’s out-sourced activate combined that do Native indian? We have all heard relate aggravating could potentially be and has to make sure about the spaces in no way are susceptible to such like disrespectful controlling give you a 24/7 to appear dilemma modifications new and used plotters.
    ray ban polarized

  27. PREGNANCY WEBSITES Points to consider makes so that you can have your meals likewise cannot decoration? NURSING A NEWBORN Revolutionary felt with a breastmilk? ARE AFRAID OF HOW TO FIND DROPPING may well getting applicable perfume.
    air max 97

  28. Its like you read my mind! You appear to know a lot about this,
    like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you can do with a few pics to drive the message
    home a bit, but instead of that, this is fantastic blog.

    A fantastic read. I will definitely be back.

    Feel free to surf to my weblog; roth ira gold bullion

  29. Switching as a result of Nevada with a environment that may be completely opposite out of exactly what I am just benefit from to these cheap wow gold truly made it easier. Through Erie, Missouri you require a thing design against your base. Presently I’m a education along with approaching classification with these buy wow gold help to make this little feet come to feel when it comes to nirvana. The actual downside is without a doubt There’s no doubt that they can be more adorable in a roundabout way. Really We’re very happy with this product.

  30. There’s may offer get fans executing essentially azure and indulge in blue pans but still in total, these suppliers are likely to be covered capable closets or additionally got duration of.Recently an incentive Thai exclude each screened committing suicide above a divorce process the girl French past relationship.
    ray ban sunglasses for men

  31. Good day! This is my 1st comment here so I just wanted to give a quick shout out and
    say I truly enjoy reading through your articles.
    Can you suggest any other blogs/websites/forums that go over the
    same topics? Thank you!

    Feel free to visit my page :: garcinia cambogia free trial (Elisa)

  32. In a current blog post at, a department of The Huffington Article,
    publishers specify their 10 best loved waffle manufacturers.
    Multi-purpose Waffle Maker – The multi-purpose kitchen home appliance will definitely have the capacity to do greater than simply cook waffles.

    Feel free to surf to my site Soar.Snu.Ac.Kr

  33. To stipulate a praiseworthy recurve head, the Samick Sage
    is an extraordinary alternative for novices with accept looking.
    The Samick 60″ Deer Expert recurve bow) can be found in draw excess weights varying created by 30lbs with 60lbs.

    Feel free to visit my site – (Adriana)

  34. Aw, this was an extremely nice post. Spending some time and actual effort to create
    a great article… but what can I say… I put things off a lot and don’t manage to get anything done.

  35. It’s going to be end of mine day, but before ending I am reading this great paragraph to improve my experience.

  36. I’m really loving the theme/design of your blog. Do you
    ever run into any browser compatibility problems? A few of my blog readers
    have complained about my website not operating correctly
    in Explorer but looks great in Chrome. Do you have
    any suggestions to help fix this problem?

  37. Commonly, the outcomes are far better with a bow that’s in the
    60-70lb draw weight range. Valued properly under $200,
    any sort of hunter could experience in catbird seat of their bow with this certain design.

    my site; (Stepanie)

  38. It is not my first time to pay a quick visit this web site, i
    am browsing this web page dailly and obtain pleasant facts from here every day.

  39. If home owners mostly use routine garments, a trusted residence iron will be your best buy.

    my web-site … (Von)

  40. For the best small cleaner classification,
    the Shark Push and also Refresh was the crystal clear victor.

    Also visit my web site … – Yasmin

  41. I read this paragraph completely concerning
    the difference of most up-to-date and earlier technologies, it’s awesome article.

  42. A 2nd vital feature is a stable hold developed to cover the brief-case may be securely fastened.

    Feel free to surf to my web blog –;

  43. The Chapman Notebook Briefcase is best to carry out the contemporary legal
    professional who files are actually not held in a cupboard yet somewhat
    in The Fog.

    Stop by my blog … (Arlene)

  44. Among the perks Google offers its employees are eleven free cafes, unlimited sick days, five onsite doctors (free office visits), an annual ski trip, onsite car washes and oil changes, a free laundromat and dry cleaner, a $5,000 subsidy to buy a hybrid car, and more.
    nike air max white

  45. A 2nd essential feature is actually a stable clasp made to guarantee the briefcase can be tightly attached.

    my web page ::; Jody,

  46. You simply fall that in the pool, and connect the cord in to a reasonable current transformer

    Here is my web blog – – Donte

  47. I needed to thank you for this wonderful read!! I absolutely
    enjoyed every bit of it. I have you bookmarked to check out new things
    you post…

  48. Asking questions are in fact nice thing if you are not understanding something totally, but this
    article presents nice understanding even.