David Cameron: manners please! -by Bahadar Ali Khan
The British Prime Minister David Cameroon, choose the wrong audience, wrong time and wrong proof to castigate Pakistan in later’s efforts against terrorists and terrorism. Mr. Cameron may have been over charged by the prospects of leveraging its position against Pakistan to seek future business prospects with India. However, a caution must be observed while delivering sweeping statements. International diplomacy requires that certain norms must be respected while addressing a third nation.
The British past glory is an obsolete history now. The fact of the matter is that it is just another tiny island floating in Atlantics and rest of the mainland Europe is trying to keep it as far on the other side of English Channel as possible. UK mired by its complex demographic factors, which also highlights the British adventurism in the past, is not in a position anymore to dictate sovereign nations as per the cravings of its past nostalgia. However, this is certainly not to belittle UK in its entirety but it is also important to put the things in their right perspective.
We are certainly critical of Pakistan’s role in the past, but that is not a fact anymore. With the elected government in place which has achieved consensus against the the extremist elements and waged a war that is practically shaking the whole edifice of extremism. Pakistan also understands that it is no longer obliged by the adventurism of the UK’s home grown terrorists to serve as catalyst for its action against the terrorists at home. Extremism is rust which is eroding the foundations of Pakistan and certainly a vast majority of the public understands that. So pushing Pakistan by giving pious sermons by a foreign dignitary in a hostile territory can serve no purpose but to create a bad taste.
Any such statement is counter productive owing to the fact that it rejuvenates the feelings of nationalism. Nationalism in the times of peace is a good thing however a country at war within itself, the nationalism doesn’t help. The whole attention of general public goes out of borders and the feelings of hostility find a new punching bag, which eventually gives another life-line to the terrorists who also join the chorus. And the extremist apologists get more potency in their rhetoric against the West and they make general Pakistani to believe that their government is the friend of ‘real’ enemy.
The move to win hearts and minds cannot be carried on this way. David Cameron’s political expediency is understandable and also his rightist approach but by issuing such statements he is simply undoing all the efforts so far his predecessors have done to create soft corner in the heart of general Pakistani about the UK and the West. In this respect Mr. Cameron must learn some diplomacy lessons from its ally across the Atlantic, the US, whose foreign minister is setting an example guide of a successful foreign policy with Pakistan, whom Western press regards as a difficult ally. She engages herself with the common man during her trips to Pakistan and is open to admitting the past wrong-doings of US in case of Pakistan. Of course detractors are still open to the criticism however inertly Pakistani’s feel more comfortable with a mix of her frank and formal remarks. These are the ways of passing on the right message and also not offending an already difficult audience.
Wiki-leaks, its timing and consequences requires a more detailed analysis which I would do sometime later as more facts unfold. But again Mr. Cameron had no right to formulate his warnings to Pakistan on the un-authentic and seemingly a multi-faceted intelligence reports.
Update: Please find here the original statments made by British PM David Cameron while addressing InfoSys IT audience in Banglore. Here is the link:
ulta chor kotwaal ko dantay!!! hahaha
What has David Cameron said. It would have been helpful if the author had either quoted his statement or provided a link to his statement.
@Paul.
Fair enough, please find here the details of the statment made by David Cameroon.
BANGALORE: British Prime Minister David Cameron said Wednesday that Pakistan must not “look two ways” in Afghanistan by publicly working to stabilise the country while secretly funding insurgents.
US documents leaked to Internet whistleblower site WikiLeaks this week accuse Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) of secretly helping the Afghan insurgency.
“It’s unacceptable for anything to happen within Pakistan that’s about supporting terrorism elsewhere,” Cameron told BBC radio during a trip to India.
“And it’s well documented that that has been the case in the past and it’s an issue that we have to make sure that the Pakistan authorities are not looking two ways,” he added.
He said there had been “big progress” by Pakistan in fighting militant groups, which had improved relations with Afghanistan, “but we need to see that progress continue.”
India, a regular target for militant groups based in Pakistan, slammed the new evidence of official Pakistan involvement in funding militancy.
“Sponsorship of terrorism, as an instrument of policy, is wholly condemnable and must cease forthwith,” an Indian foreign ministry spokesman said late Tuesday.
India has also long been concerned that billions of dollars of military aid given to Pakistan to help fight militants on its territory is misdirected to insurgents, or funds defence programmes designed to counter India.
“I am going to discuss with Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on the leakage of funds given to Pakistan by the US and UK,” Cameron told reporters in Bangalore.
http://www.dawn.com/wps/wcm/connect/dawn-content-library/dawn/news/pakistan/04-david-cameron-pakistan-qs-04
Thank you for the details. In this case your headline should have read:
Mind your own bloody business Mr. Camreon.
It is clear that the Brits are as much disinterested in a democratic and prosperous Pakistan as the mullahs. All reports on Wiki leaks and elsewhere talk about 2004-2007 or 2008 at max but they were happily dishing out money to the generals. Democratically elected government puts a stop to the double crossing, conducts a success full operation against terrorism and the highest office of Britain makes it a point to rebuke Pakistan in enemy territory. Shameful
I totally agree with David Cameron. Pakistan Army conducted a successful Operation is Swat and Waziristan because of sheer internal pressure and the democratic government, to improve it’s public image which had been tainted by the 10 Year Military rule.
As a matter of fact, Pakistan Army has been ideological as well as strategic supporter of Taliban Government and extremist elements in the tribal areas of Pakistan and now in Southern Punjab too. There is immense pressure on the Democratic Government of Pakistan from within the army ranks and the establishment after the UN Report on Benazir Bhutto’s murder was made public. Though Pakistan’s Government has to save it’s international image by denying the ISI Taliban links, they themselves know the agencies operate independently.,
It is all but sad with the way Pakistan is being treated the world over. We suffer big time with our image. Mr. Cameron can have as many Pakistanis in his cabinet, yet we just cant have the positives of Pakistan overcome the negatives we have.
On a personal note, I applied for a visit visa to canada yesterday. Being a Pakistani, the minimum time required for the same is 2 weeks. Indian and Bangladeshi citizens get it the same day 🙁
@ Usama:
The Brits and Americans were very clear about one thing during the army regime, that they were with their strategic partner Musharraf, Pakistan was used only occasionally. So Pakistan never double crossed them, army did, Most of the money went to the illegitimate dictator they were supporting, who was openly in coalition with the mullahs.
May I suggest Mr Cameroon that he acts against the dictator who was promoting terrorism as he reside in the country he is the prime minister of.
Aik Taraf Sachai dosri taraf Jazba-e-Hubulwatni
ISI ki Moududiazation and Islamization nay hamain na Ezat di na hi Taraqqi .Na yeh Awam ki Awaz hay na Fouj ki ,
Jang-e-Moududi ko Pakistan ki jang kiyon bana rahay hain ?
Iran ,India ,Afghanistan ,Russia ,US ,UK ,Sind ,Punjab ,Balochistan ,Paktoon khawh ,Bainazir ,Nawaz shareef ,Altaf ,Asfandyar wali ,Sidhi ,Balouch sab kay sab ISI per ilazam lagatay hain ,yeh kis ka mandate hay ? Saudi Arabia ka ya Jamaat Islami ka jis per ISI kay generals Taliban aur dehshatgerdon ko suport kertay hain ?
Shocked to see Mr Cameron use such harsh comments for Pakistan just to please some Indians and probably to score some business deals. The truth is that Pakistan knew little about terrorism until Afghanistan and Iraq wars were started, the purpose and output of whom is still unclear to a large number of people. Mr. Cameron probably does not know that in last 5 years alone there have been around 700 terrorist attacks in Pakistan which have claimed more than 10,000 lives! So who is the biggest victim of terrorism then? Who has paid the biggest price for this war on terrorism? who has helped in capturing high profile terrorists? who provided intelligence to Britain which prevented Heathrow attack in 2006? My question to Mr Cameron is that who does he think is responsible for exporting the terrorism to Pakistan in the first place before he blames the country on a day when they expected condolence for the tragic air crash and situation after heavy flood!
It is time for UK Pakistani’s and US Pakistani’s to show their power and make the Kuffar Hindu American Zionists pay for their words and actions. Pakistan is the next superpower and will crush India then Israel and finally we will make America submit to Islam.
David Cameron is a fool and should be afraid to talk ill of Pakistan. UK will burn as my brothers there will make him submit and eat his words. Pandering to Bhindians and than having the gall to call into question the world best Spy Agency deserves no such less a reaction.
THis is intolerable coming from this kuffar fool! It is time for UK Pakistani’s and US Pakistani’s to show their power and make the Kuffar American Zionist Hindus pay for their words and actions. Pakistan is the next superpower and will crush India then Israel and finally we will make America submit to Islam.
David Cameron is a fool and should be afraid to talk ill of Pakistan. UK will burn as my brothers there will make him submit and eat his words. Pandering to Bhindians and than having the gall to call into question the world best Spy Agency deserves no such less a reaction.
The ISI will respond and In’shallah make them pay.
can you please remove the messages where someone has used my name. There is someone who is using my name and writing ridiculous messages on different websites. I have already repoted it to FBI. If you have any information about the person or the email add they have been using, please forward it to me i will appreciate it.
I do not even understand how I stopped up right here, however I assumed this publish used to be good. I do not recognize who you might be but certainly you’re going to a famous blogger if you happen to aren’t already 😉 Cheers!