America has abdicated its guiding role in the middle east to a sectarian Arab military force – James Traub
In the speech on counterterrorism policy that he delivered last year at West Point, President Barack Obama made clear that the United States would no longer try to fight the terrorist threat abroad on its own, but rather would aim to “more effectively partner with countries where terrorist networks seek a foothold.” Last month, the Arab League answered that call by pledging to establish a joint Arab military force to respond to the growing chaos in the region. The Obama administration has given its cautious support to the proposal. A senior State Department official I spoke to said, “We welcome something like this, especially in Syria, but also elsewhere.”
I would say: Be careful what you welcome.
The actual details of this proposed army, including its members, force structure, and location, are to be worked out over the next several months. And as Arab unity — political or military — has often proved to be a mirage, there is good reason to be skeptical that the force will ever come into being. Even if it did, fundamental divisions among Arab states would ensure that a joint force would look more like a shifting coalition of the willing than a collective body like NATO, or even like the African Union’s Peace and Security Council.
Nevertheless, a sense of real danger, combined with a fear of abandonment by the United States, has propelled the idea onto the Arab agenda. Egypt, which has pushed hardest for the joint force, worries that extremist violence in Libya will spill across the border between the two countries. After Islamic State fighters in Libya beheaded 21 Egyptian Copts, President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi called for a U.N.-backed intervention force, or, failing that, the lifting of the arms embargo on the internationally recognized Libyan government in Tobruk. When the United States and Britain opposed both measures, Sisi apparently concluded that he would have to rely on his fellow Arabs, and began sounding the tocsin for a joint force.
The impetus for the force was Egyptian, but it will go nowhere without Saudi Arabia, the paramount political and financial force in the Gulf. The Saudis also see a grave threat on their doorstep, as Yemen has been overrun by Houthi tribesmen allied with Iran. Saudi Arabia has pulled eight other Arab nations, as well as the United States, into its air war against the Houthis. That war has thus become a prototype of a new form of collective regional action with the United States as a supporting player — precisely what Obama suggested at West Point.
The administration defends the Saudis’ resort to force to stem the tide of the takeover of Yemen: The Houthis had placed Scud missiles on the border, while Iran had begun regular flights to Saada, the Houthi stronghold. But the State Department official I spoke to added that the hostilities would have to end soon in order to limit death and destruction, and to bring the Houthis to a political settlement.
There is, unfortunately, no sign that Saudi King Salman bin Abdulaziz agrees with that proposition. His apparent plan is to bomb the Houthis into submission. What’s more, the Saudis are new to the game of military intervention, and they seem bent on reproducing America’s worst mistakes. The air war has caused over 500 civilian deaths and an incipient humanitarian disaster; created new opportunities for al Qaeda, which has seized Mukalla, Yemen’s fifth-largest city; and done nothing to hinder the Houthis’ bid to conquer the strategic southern city of Aden. It’s not a very encouraging prototype.
The fight is only two weeks old and perhaps the tide will turn. The more lasting problem is King Salman’s idea of a political solution. Once he’s evicted the Houthis, he plans to restore to power President Abed Rabbo Mansour Hadi, who was forced to flee Yemen to Saudi Arabia. But it was the Saudis who put Hadi there in the first place; so weak is his writ that his army effectively abandoned him in favor of his widely hated predecessor, Ali Abdullah Saleh. Hadi might survive, but only as a Saudi puppet. What’s more, the Houthis are not Iran’s puppets, as the Saudis insist, but a powerful indigenous force whose demands must be accommodated in a power-sharing agreement.
A comparable situation can be seen in Libya, where Egypt has given political and military support to the Tobruk government in its effort to destroy the rival government based in Tripoli. The former is avowedly “moderate,” the other “Islamist,” but these oversimplified terms disguise the reality of different regions, tribes, and ethnic groups vying for control. Again, the only lasting solution would be a political one. Yet right now the greatest obstacle to a cease-fire is the refusal of the Tobruk government to negotiate with the Islamists. The Tobruk prime minister, Abdullah al-Thinni, has demanded that the Arabs do in Libya what they’re now doing in Yemen. That would be a catastrophe.
The United States has learned the hard way that it cannot simply prop up governments seen as illegitimate by their own people; that’s why Obama has tried to condition military assistance to Iraq on political reform that offers a significant role to Sunnis. Arab autocrats do not accept this principle. Saudi Arabia reacted to political dissent among the Shiite majority in Bahrain by sending in a military force to help the Sunni monarchy in Manama crush the peaceful movement. The Sisi regime treats domestic dissent as a threat to national security; from Cairo’s point of view, members of the Muslim Brotherhood are “terrorists” — a fifth-column version of the Islamic State.
The problem goes deeper still. The West defines African security problems more or less the same way African states do: Failing states, military coups, and aggressive warlords pose a danger beyond their own borders that must be addressed by external actors. That’s why working with the African Union is relatively unproblematic. No such consensus exists with the Arab world.
The Saudis see localized uprisings as manifestations of a relentless Iranian campaign to dominate the Middle East. The central battle is thus not moderate Islam versus violent extremism, as it is for the United States and the West, but Sunni versus Shiite. The joint strike force will be a Sunni, rather than an Arab, instrument; Iraq and Lebanon, where Shiites hold effective control, have shown no enthusiasm for the proposed body. This will have the effect of deepening existing schisms.
The other great regional bugbear is political Islam. The Emiratis and other Gulf states share Egypt’s paranoia on the subject, and have also branded the Brotherhood a terrorist organization. None of them have shown any interest in bolstering Tunisia, a country beset by domestic terrorism. That’s because the Tunisian government includes the Islamist Ennahda party. The United States has an interest in supporting nascent democracies and ending conflict through reconciliation. The Arab army won’t do either.
But the United States also has a very serious interest in rolling back the Islamic State in Iraq, Syria, and Libya, and suppressing al Qaeda and curbing the Houthis in Yemen. Here U.S. and Arab interests converge. The West cannot solve the problem of Islamic extremism; only the Islamic world itself can do that. Obama has said that the United States will henceforward work through partners when it comes to counterterrorism. As one Arab diplomat said to me about the proposed force, “If Obama’s policy is to get the region to take care of its own problems, I think this is a good place to be.” Indeed, from the Arab point of view, it is precisely the American abdication that has necessitated the new Arab activism. “The U.S. is not the 911 for these problems anymore,” the diplomat put it.
When you’re the hegemon, you can tell your partners how to behave; when you’re not, you can’t. The United States can no longer afford to play that role, and in any case doesn’t want to. It must rely on, rather than simply conscript, its partners. And that means it must adapt, more than it has in the past, to its partners’ views. Washington is thus in no position either to oppose the Arab joint strike force or to tell it how and where to act. It really is a lamentable state of affairs. But it’s where we are.
Source:
Once you are sure your plants are suffering from thrip infestation, you must immediately prune them.
nike air max 95 http://www.wholesaleairmaxcheap2.xyz
I won’t guarantee that it’ll work though.
ray ban caravan http://rb3025.sunglassesstoreen2.xyz
Amazing! Its really amazing post, I have got much clear idea
regarding from this piece of writing.
my web page … website (Edwina)
Let this be your day and dress it up with dreams.
nike air max 2014 http://airmax2015.shoeshotsale2.xyz
Since their firstborn toy Happy Worker has added other original action figures, including BossMan – mighty manager, SuperMom – mini mommy heroine, and MoneyMan – your friendly neighborhood financial hero.
ray ban 2140 http://rb4147.hotsunglasses2.xyz
This yields a annual rate of return of 6.
ray ban sunglasses sale http://rb3386.rbshop2.xyz
Some cats prefer smaller spaces alone, while others will yowl all night if not allowed to be near their people, and others are explorers and just want to sniff and look around.
womens nike air max http://www.bestrunnershoes2.xyz
If a firm oor contractor that is iitial integrity and alsoo so I ggo on this line, fundamental human does nnot matter.
Also visit my sitre :: Water Damage Restoration
You can only make income and gain influence to the degree that your awareness will allow you to keep.
cheap nike air max http://airmax2015.shoesstore2.xyz
The topic for her to get provided beginning in The lord’s fall extremely important can lead to tons of difficulties to have.
michael kors handbags on sale http://www.michaelkorsoutletstorez2.xyz
These components is just about the from time to time stable purely natural the historical past put together saw blade personal trainers.Wherever and whenever most companies motor is invariably shaking, on line casinos EOBR will be able to by clicking on what papers the place, the hovering the opportunity, the discontinuing the opportunity, on top of that certificates the facts to as much as various other computers beneath reporting choices.
ray ban rb3025 http://www.raybansunglasseswayfareren2.xyz
America has abdicated its guiding role in the middle east to a sectarian Arab military force – James Traub
alyctetg
lyctetg http://www.g6oj5xae497iu4333vid786n7wvq1e39s.org/
[url=http://www.g6oj5xae497iu4333vid786n7wvq1e39s.org/]ulyctetg[/url]
You’ll need to jack up the car so the tire you are looking at is up off the ground.
michael kors wallet
The best way to treat genital warts and genital herpes is to use the body’s own immune system to take control of and overpower the viruses by suppressing them into dormancy.
ray ban rb3025
Thus it is up to medical professionals to ensure the injury is recognised.
michael kors outlet locations
Last year its real estate arm bought the 2.
ray ban rb3025
A number of international organizations and companies will seek to hire people who speak Chinese along with English.
michael kors outlet
People who are staying in the center place of London if they require such kind of services then they need to spend a small amount of money.
michael kors handbags
LASER, or Light Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation, can target the root cause of acne–the overactive sebaceous gland and the resulting overgrowth of bacteria.
cheap ray ban sunglasses
To some extent the penetration of laminates in to this class of devices depends on Apple.
ray ban canada
For it shouldn’t associated link associated with similarities, which might school of thought very confusing as the 95% of all cash range from United states.
nike air max 1
The ideal option for acquiring ink cartridges is to do so on the world wide web.
ray ban sunglasses
The kit usually contains snap fasteners and plastic holders for the prong and sockets to make it easier for you to use.
cheap ray ban sunglasses
You’ve made some good points there. I looked on the net to learn more about the issue and
found most people will go along with your views on this site.
my site garcinia cambogia free trial uk; Darby,
Your hard plastic who had been the the construction of water lines could take whole lot more 1, 000 many years to completely stop working.
nike air max black
A GREAT AMOUNT OF kid’s sis offered honestly attended various discomfort this individual required his well-known life – span.
nike air max classic bw
Switch you r taken in unit’s generally 12 in check. within just base, (without an anchor they may transit independent of the water).
michael kors makeup bag
We have a tendency to can now not control our lovers, partners, other halves, or husbands.
ray ban 3025
Hence, it is no wonder that average realized price per BoE also fell.
ray ban wayfarer
” The layman’s translation follows.
ray ban sale
Keeping in mind the end goal to send flowers for somebody you think about you have to evaluate what the event is and what sort of relationship you impart to that individual Obviously sending flowers is not limited to any extraordinary event and might be sent whenever Prior sending flowers means gather flowers from the close arrangement or purchasing a bunch and giving it generally to the individual it is implied for It was confined to the nearby region of the zone you live in Then again with the coming of innovation and commonness of the Internet the way we used to send flowers has changed drastically Presently delivering flowers to your dear ones is simply few mouse clicks away Whether you need to send flowers to your girl living in an alternate city or to your closest companion living in an alternate landmass Internet has made it conceivable to deliver the wonderful flower arrangements to any corner on the planet To order any kind of flower bouquets on the web you have to search and find an online store that will offer you online flower delivery in Jalandhar You can then check their item offerings to settle the flower arrangement you need to send Once the item is concluded you can fill an online structure to enter the delivery address your message and afterward at long last make the payment and you are carried out The flower bouquet you have requested will be delivered at the doorstep of your friends and family The great thing is that a large number of these online stores even take into account mid settled time and same day delivery of flowers Thus on the off chance that you need to wish somebody on his or her comfortable you can do that with the assistance of an online flower deliver store Our lives these days is busy to the point that we have a tendency to overlook critical events furthermore the significance of communicating our feelings Thus in the event that you are thinking that it hard to express your feelings it will be the best choice to take eventually out of your occupied timetable and express those concealed sentiments by sending flowers to Jalandhar to your near and dear ones />
ray ban sunglasses for men
An effective form of therapy might be to explore your feelings relating to a particular sphere of emotion.
nike air max white
great post, very informative. I ponder why the opposite specialists of this sector don’t understand
this. You must proceed your writing. I’m confident, you’ve a great readers’
base already!
Stop by my blog post – garcinia cambogia free trial; Erica,
This variation for achieving a variety of rhythms was characteristic of Marlowe’s dramatic verse.
ray ban sunglasses sale
For this, they will be needing beauty and body care products that are not only effective but also subtle to their young skin and will not cause allergies and other unwanted side effects.
ray ban sunglasses outlet
I have read so many posts about the blogger lovers
except this piece of writing is genuinely a nice post,
keep it up.
Persuade folks to reside cardio “now. in depth. Dwell on the last only for enough time tell me should really notice effect, and set student.
ray ban clubmaster
In the event that, their fish articulation tubs right on man made fibre eyeport images provide cleanse deliver you with adding protecting so that i seems like the instances. 5.
michael kors crossbody bags
hi!,I love your writing so so much! percentage we communicate more approximately your post on AOL?
I need an expert in this house to solve my problem. Maybe that is you!
Looking ahead to peer you.
Feel free to surf to my blog garcinia cambogia free trial nz (Reagan)
fastest wow gold‘s are incredibly nice and chic. I really like having your cheap wow gold‘s to university of course, if I’m going by helping cover their our friends. In the wintry weather they’ve been more or less almost all That i provide.