Pakistan’s federal minister for tourism: Right man for the right job – by Irfan Hussain
I became convinced that Asif Zardari had a sense of humour when I first learned of the appointment of Maulana Attaur Rehman as the federal minister for tourism. Who better than this bearded, rotund cleric as the face of Pakistan to attract tourists to our shores?
My conviction that this was truly an inspired choice was confirmed when this newspaper reported on the good maulana`s latest utterances a few days ago. At a recent gathering in Akora Khattak, he said:
“Ulema [clerics] and the Taliban are the true followers of Islamic ideology and America is the biggest terrorist of the world, which is creating hatred against them [the ulema and the Taliban]. US and the world should give equal rights and respect to the Muslims, or terrorism will continue… It is a misconception that ulema and the Taliban are against coexistence of people with different religions. In fact it is America which is against interfaith harmony to maintain its hegemony over the world.”
I`m glad the minister has openly and clearly stated that Pakistan`s religious parties and their supporters are on the same wavelength as the Taliban. No doubt he supports the Taliban`s Stone Age policies while they were in power: executions, floggings and amputations were among the public entertainment Mullah Omar and his gang provided the Afghans.
What they did not provide was education for girls or progress of any kind. Indeed, women were locked up out of sight, and men`s beards were measured for correct length. Having less facial hair than the prescribed length was a serious offence. Pastimes like flying kites or playing chess were naturally banned, as were music and movies.
This, then, is the `Islamic ideology` of the Taliban. So what does that make the millions of Muslims around the world who utterly rejected this barbaric system? Lesser Muslims, or even non-Muslims, in the eyes of the maulana, no doubt. Fortunately for us, Attaur Rehman`s portfolio was split up to accommodate another minister in this bloated cabinet, otherwise he would have been in charge of culture as well. Given his admiration of the Taliban, I can easily imagine him ordering the destruction of the thousands of splendid statues in museums and archaeological sites around the country.
This, of course, would have mimicked the wanton destruction of the famous giant statues of the Buddha in Bamiyan by the Taliban in 2000. When Mullah Omar ordered this act of cultural and religious desecration, the whole world united in condemning it. In fact, this one show of ignorance and insensitivity lost the Taliban regime any residual sympathy, so when they were thrown out of Kabul in the wake of 9/11, no tears were shed for them.
The second part of the minister`s rant referred to the Americans. When he demanded that America and the world should give equal rights to Muslims, he was probably unaware that Muslims living in the West enjoy more rights than they do in their own countries. Which is one reason they migrate, legally or illegally, whenever they get an opportunity.
And when the maulana said that it is a “misconception that the ulema and the Taliban are against coexistence of people with different religions”, he should tell that to Aasia Bibi, the Christian woman sentenced to death for alleged blasphemy. Or to her family that has had to go into hiding after being threatened with death by local clerics.
Considering that this government is allied with, and dependent on, the United States, it is slightly odd for a cabinet minister to denounce America as “the biggest terrorist of the world”. While this could be his personal view, the public statements of sitting ministers are subjected to greater scrutiny than the ravings of some lone nut out there. Normally, if the public views of a minister are so far out of sync with government policy, he is asked to resign. But as far as I can detect, Zardari and his prime minister show no embarrassment at all over this outburst. I wonder what the newly arrived American ambassador makes of it.
When I looked up Attaur Rehman on the government website, I discovered that last May, he had attended the regional conference of UNWTO in Hanoi.
At this gathering of tourism ministers, travel agents and tour operators, he complained that the world media gave a wrong impression of Pakistan through its `travel advisories`. Actually, it is foreign governments that issue these warnings to their citizens in respect of countries where they could be at risk.
But does he really think the foreign media gives the wrong impression of Pakistan as one of the most dangerous places in the world for outsiders? Considering the daily mayhem we face, as well as the deadly suicide bombings of embassies and hotels that have killed so many foreigners, surely the advisories are based on a grim reality.I suspect the maulana`s mediaeval figure at the conference must have confirmed everybody`s worst fears about Pakistan. Once again, I must congratulate Zardari for unerringly picking the right man for the right job. Perhaps he should be given the additional portfolio of culture as well.
Seriously, though, why do we need a tourism ministry at all, apart from giving the job to somebody like Attaur Rehman? We are kidding ourselves if we think that this ministry can or does anything to attract foreign tourists to our country.
The only foreigners who write `tourism` as the purpose of their visit on their visa applications these days probably come to Pakistan for a few weeks of training in the terrorist camps in the tribal areas. Or they arrive on one-way tickets to enrol for a short course in suicide bombing. For these tourists, the maulana is an ideal recommendation.
The tourism minister`s recent utterances simply confirm the deeply schizophrenic country Pakistan has become. We send out simultaneous signals of modernity and mediaevalism, but at the end of the day, the latter drowns out the former.
The anti-West, pro-Taliban sentiment is the abiding image the rest of the world has of Pakistan. And as long as people like Attaur Rehman drive the national agenda, politicians like Zardari and Gilani will continue to cave in.
irfan.husain@gmail.com
Source: Dawn, 27 Nov 2010
Immorality, impotence and other afflictions of the mind
By Salman Rashid
A JUI MNA has recently taken over as the Minister for Tourism. And if anyone sees any irony in that, they had better get their heads inspected by an expert leather worker. At the very outset he in tandem with his parliamentary secretary (who else but a mufti) has pledged to ban alcohol and immoral activities from all Pakistan Tourism Development Corporation (PTDC) motels. In view of this avalanche of immorality that covers these places of evil, I declare all PTDC establishments should henceforth be known by their correct name: Vice Dens.
Wow! Being one of those lesser mortals as compared to the worthy maulanas and not particularly averse to enjoying immoral activities, I am ashamed of my own ignorance. Why, over the past quarter century of masquerading as a travel writer, I have availed of the board and lodge at PTDC Vice Dens from Astore (Rama Lake, actually) to Ziarat and the fun and games have somehow always eluded me.
While even pious maulanas were in the know of the shady carryings-on behind the closed doors of PTDC Vice Dens (God forbid! The mullahs were of course never part of the iniquity), I foolishly spent my free hours in my room twiddling my thumbs. Because of the excellent soundproofing that all Vice Den rooms obviously have, I never heard those squeals of delight emanating from neighbouring rooms. And so, in my utter naiveté I failed to be part of the revelry.
The most fun I ever had was in autumn some years ago in Khaplu when I was the sole occupant of the Vice Den. There I sat on the steps outside my room reading and occasionally gathering up the ripe walnuts as they plonked about all around me, cracking them with a stone and eating the delicious, milky kernels.
Had I not been such a blockhead and only looked around me, I might have discerned movement behind the drapes where all those lovelies were waiting for boring old me to join them in some drunken Bacchanalian revel. But oh woe! I did not know what fun waited to be had. Any smarter and I would have, as the sole occupant of the Vice Den, been a very Raja Inder of legend surrounded by a battalion of beauties.
I suppose the Vice Dens operated under a very strict code of secrecy. Only members initiated to the Cabal of Carnality had access to the proceedings. Since PTDC is a government set-up, I suspect agencies like IB, ISI and FIA stepped in to screen prospective members thereby keeping yahoos like yours truly at arms length. And since Hussain Haqqani has shown in his book on Pakistan that these agencies (as well as the military) and the clergy are actually two sides of the same coin, we know how the maulana and his parliamentary secretary are aware of the super-secret proceedings.
We do not read, even in this age of easy internet access, of such resolve of any other country to rid its tourism industry of lechery. A libertine living outside Pakistan and reading the coverage of our good maulana’s determination to purge PTDC of immorality would therefore not be wrong in believing Pakistan was the ultimate bordello in the world; the bonking-shop to put an end to all others.
In their mind’s eye they would see a land of drunken people lurching from carnality to the most lurid and exhibitionist carnality without let or hindrance. To them Pakistan would be the supreme dream come true of the debauch. That’s how perceptions are formed. In reality, here we are dying for a piece of the action and not getting any.
Nearly three decades ago I lived and worked in Karachi when Pakistan really was another country where foreigners never felt threatened. The firm I worked for routinely got young engineering interns from Germany to come out for their hands-on training at their facility. I became friend with one, a rather insightful young man, who should really have been a writer and not an engineer. Guenther wanted to know everything about Pakistan.
His favourite was wall chalkings. As we drove around Karachi, he made me translate these slogans and carefully noted their meaning in a meticulously kept diary. Then one day we together travelled to Lahore by train. I do not recall what most of the slogans were in Karachi, but I distinctly remember that once we crossed into my native Punjab every other sign screamed about mardana kumzori –impotence.
Now those were days when jihad was still confined to Afghanistan and even south Punjab did not have all those slogans (as it does today) exhorting Muslims to do in the infidels wherever they came upon them. No surprise then that our only national concern in those days was of a priapic nature. From Rahim Yar Khan until we reached Lahore, Guenther had collected the addresses of some three-dozen ‘clinics’ that restored virility. He had also learned an equal number of names of precursors to Viagra — many of which claimed to contain a liberal dose of gold.
What surprised him was that ‘clinics’ from Jhelum, Lala Musa and Gujranwala were advertising their wares in the deep south of Punjab. To Guenther this meant that people were prepared to go long ways to cure their impotence. Similarly, in Lahore not only did he come upon an over-abundance of what Lahoris in those days called ‘sex clinics’, but also ads from Dera Ghazi Khan and Rahim Yar Khan.
Not believing what I had translated, Guenther got me to take him to once such clinic in Multan Road near the orphanage. The shifty ‘doctor’ who did not speak English gave us non-answers for all Guenther’s questions. What we did learn was that most of his clientele were not oldies but young soon-to-be-married men.
Guenther felt that Pakistan’s biggest problem was not poor economy or rampant population growth or lack of education or corruption in government departments or a total absence of work ethic or even a military dictatorship rotten to the core. It was a lack of virility. Pakistan, so my friend concluded, was a nation of impotent men. But what baffled him was how such a nation could have uncontrolled population growth. This, I told him, was one of the inscrutable Lord’s greatest miracles.
The impotence-curing slogans persist to this day. In fact, they have grown in number and the variety of preparations they offer. And now we learn that Pakistan is also beset with the problem of uncontrolled debauchery that the good Minister for Tourism will put an end to. If there was ever a paradox, it is this: the government-owned PTDC operates vice dens for a nation of impotent men.
Maulana Prado Becomes Instant Star
The brother of Maulana Fazl-ur-Rehman (popularly known as Maulana Diesel) Maulana Atta-ur-Rehman, who was recently inducted in the Federal Cabinet as Minister for Tourism has become an instant star in Pakistani Politics.
His controversial debut on the stage of Pakistani Politics started with his elections in 2008, when his results were held by the Election Commission on rigging allegations. During recounting of the votes in his constituency, mysteriously some of the ballot boxes were snatched by unknown people, and he was later declared as a winner, which is widely believed as a result of power-sharing deal between Zardari and Maulana Brothers.
Immediately after joining the Federal Cabinet, he demanded a Toyota Prado that was being used by the Managing Director of Pakistan Tourism Development Corporation (PTDC), Brigadier Retd. Amanullah. After refusal by the MD of PTDC as per the rules, Maulana (Prado) got frustrated and planned to snatch his desired vehicle (Prado) by force.
Maulana requested the MD to send the Prado to receive some guests at the airport, where he and his armed gangsters thrashed the driver out of the vehicle and Maulana (Prado) himself got control of the vehicle and drove away!
The very next day, the MD of PTDC received a letter mentioning that he has been fired by the Minister after consultation with the Prime Minister. Later on, The Prime Minister declared the statement of Maulana (Prado) a blatant lie and denied any consultation on this issue. The PM also confirmed that a Minister has no powers to fire a government officer of this level.
In another episode of his achievements, Maulana (Prado) refused to visit Swat by rejecting the recommendations of the Standing Committee for Tourism in Senate. However he accepted another recommendation by the same committee, with a big smile on his face, to visit the European beaches in order to get some “Unique” ideas for tourism development in Pakistan.
Tourists? No thanks
Editorial: TheNews
Monday, February 09, 2009
Tourism and Pakistan have never enjoyed an entirely easy relationship. This is a country crammed with sites that should attract tourists by the hundred of thousands every year – yet even on a good year we never seem to see more than a trickle, and most of them in the mountain areas to the north. Our coffers should be filled by a steady stream of Forex flowing from the pockets of tourists from other countries here to enjoy our legendary hospitality. Our domestic tourism has nosedived for the same reasons as our foreign tourism – nobody wants to spend a relaxing weekend in a venue that offers public beheading, flogging and dismemberment at the flick of the suicide bombers switch. We also suffer under the stern advice of foreign embassies who tell their citizens not to travel to Pakistan, that it is dangerous and if you really do have to come here make sure you have a security plan in place before you do. As if all this was not enough, successive governments have treated tourism as something akin to an unmentionable social disease that is ever present and not quite curable – and have appointed as ministers of tourism a lacklustre bunch of faceless nobodies who know as much about tourism and its promotion as does the average roadside beggar. On the single occasion in recent years when somebody with an interest in the matter got appointed – Nilofer Bakhtiar – she was swiftly hounded from office by the forces of darkness for an un-Islamic hug of her sky-diving instructor.
We now have a tourism minister, Maulana Ataur Rehman, of the JUI-F – a party well known for its affinity with the Taliban school of thought. Having been in the job for less than a week Mr Rehman has already got his knife well stuck into what is left of the tourist industry. He has railed against the ‘immorality’ of foreigners and declared that the – perfectly legal – sale of alcohol to non-Muslims in hotels should stop forthwith. Presumably singing and dancing by local folk-performers is next on the cards, after all it would not be appropriate for foreigners to witness our rich cultural traditions, would it? And he might as well close all the theatres and cinemas, shut down the KaraFilm festival and ban whistling in the street if he really wants to do the job properly. Of all the nonsensical appointments made by the sitting government this one really does take the prize. Whatever is left of our tourism industry may as well shut-up shop now… and a message to all you immoral hard-drinking foreigners – ‘Don’t come to Pakistan’, signed Maulana Ataur Rehman, Minister for Tourism.
http://mmabbasi.com/2010/02/27/the-rise-of-mullah-atta-ur-rehman/
چند ہی ہفتوں کے دوران ہونے والے یہ واقعات مجھے اس لیے یاد آرہے ہیں کہ ستائیس ستمبر کو دنیا بھر کی طرح پاکستان میں بھی عالمی یومِ سیاحت منایا گیا ہے۔ اور موقع کی مناسبت سے پاکستان کے محکمہ سیاحت نے ایک بین الاقوامی سیمینار کا بھی اہتمام کیا ہے جس میں ملکی و غیرملکی ماہرین پاکستان کی بیس برس پرانی ٹورزم پالیسی کو موثر بنانے کے لیے تجاویز دیں گے تاکہ جمیعت علمائے اسلام کے امیر مولانا فضل الرحمان کے بھائی وفاقی وزیرِ سیاحت مولانا عطا الرحمان کی ماہرانہ قیادت میں پاکستان اپنا نظریاتی تشخص و اقدار برقرار رکھتے ہوئے سیاحت سے اتنے ہی پیسے کما سکے جتنے پیسے بھارت، نیپال، ترکی اور مصر وغیرہ کما لے جاتے ہیں۔
مولانا کی جرات مندانہ تقرری اس امر کا بین ثبوت ہے کہ حکومت سیاحت کے شعبے کو کس قدر اہمیت دیتی ہے۔ جبکہ مولانا کے زیرِ انتظام پاکستان ٹورزم ڈویلپمنٹ کارپوریشن ملکی و غیرملکی سیاحتی حالات و تقاضوں سے کس قدر واقف ہے؟ اس کا ایک ثبوت یہ ہے کہ کارپوریشن کی ویب سائٹ پر گذشتہ ایک برس کے دوران بھی سوات کے علاقے کالام، منگورہ اور سیدو شریف کا پیکیج ٹور پیش کیا جاتا رہا۔ ( غالباً سیاحوں کے بے حد اصرار پر ! )
http://www.bbc.co.uk/urdu/columns/2009/09/090927_baat_say_nj.shtml
Share
وزیر سیاحت سرکاری گاڑی واپس کردیں ورنہ طلب کیا جاسکتا ہے، پی اے سی
اسلام آباد (نمائندہ جنگ) قومی اسمبلی کی پبلک اکاؤنٹس کمیٹی نے تمام وزرا اور سیکرٹریوں کو ہدایت کی ہے کہ وہ زیراستعمال غیرقانونی گاڑیاں حکومت کو واپس کر دیں۔ کمیٹی نے وفاقی وزیر سیاحت مولانا عطا الرحمن کو حکم دیا کہ وہ محکمہ سیاحت کی لگژری پراڈو گاڑی فوراً واپس کر دیں اگر انہوں نے یہ گاڑی محکمے کو واپس نہ کی تو پی اے سی کے اگلے اجلاس میں انہیں طلب کیا جائے گا۔ کمیٹی کا اجلاس پیر کو قائد حزب اختلاف چوہدری نثار علی خان کی زیرصدارت پارلیمنٹ ہاؤس میں منعقد ہوا۔ اجلاس میں وزارت سیاحت کے ایک کروڑ 36 لاکھ روپے سے زائد‘ وزارت خوراک و زراعت کے 7 کروڑ روپے کے آڈٹ اعتراضات اور وزارت اقتصادی امور کی طرف سے غیرملکی قرضوں کی وصولی اور تقسیم کے معاملات کا جائزہ لیا گیا۔ وزارت سیاحت کے حسابات کی جانچ پڑتال کے دوران سیکرٹری سیاحت ایم عارف نے وفاقی وزیر مولانا عطا الرحمن کو محکمہ سیاحت کی اضافی گاڑی فراہم کرنے سے متعلق پی اے سی کے سوالات کے جواب میں بتایا کہ پبلک اکاؤنٹس کمیٹی نے اس حوالے سے جو لیٹر لکھا تھا۔ وفاقی وزیر کو اس سے آگاہ کر دیا گیا ہے۔ چوہدری نثار علی خان نے کہا کہ وزیر سیاحت مولانا عطا الرحمن واضح طور پر قوانین و قواعد کی خلاف ورزی کے مرتکب ہوئے ہیں۔ اس لیے وہ فوراً دوسری گاڑی واپس کریں۔ ورنہ کمیٹی کے اگلے اجلاس میں انہیں طلب کرینگے۔
http://urdunews.net/details.asp?nid=334578
سپریم کورٹ میں مولانا عطا الرحمان کیخلاف انتخابی عذرداری کی درخواستوں کی سماعت آج تک کیلئے ملتوی
اسلام آباد(ثناء نیوز)سپریم کورٹ آف پاکستان نے وفاقی وزیر سیاحت مولانا عطاالرحمان کے خلاف انتخابی عذرداری کے حوالے سے دائر کی گئی درخواستوں کی سماعت آج جمعرات تک کے لئے ملتوی کر دی۔ چیف جسٹس افتخار محمد چوہدری کی سربراہی میں جسٹس طارق پرویز اور جسٹس غلام ربانی پر مشتمل عدالت عظمیٰ کے تین رکنی بینچ نے حبیب اﷲ خان کنڈی اور انجینئر داؤد خان کنڈی کی جانب سے دائر کی گئی درخواستوں کی سماعت کی ۔ سماعت کے دوران حبیب اﷲ خان کنڈی کی جانب سے سینئر وکیل وسیم سجاد ایڈووکیٹ نے موقت اختیار کیا کہ الیکشن کمیشن نے غیر حتمی نتیجہ کو حتمی نتیجہ قرار دیتے ہوئے تنائج کا اعلان کر دیا جبکہ دوبارہ گنتی کیلئے ان کے موکل کو نوٹس نہیں دیا گیا۔ ان کا کہنا تھا کہ مولانا عطاالرحمان کی جانب سے سے انتخابی نتائج کے بارے میں فارم 16صرف سپریم کورٹ میں داخل کر دیا گیا جو کہ درست نہیں تھا اگر یہ فارم انتخابات کے فوراً بعد مکمل کر کے بھیجا گیا تھا تو الیکشن ٹریبونل اور ہائی کورٹ میں پیش کیوں نہیں کیا گیا ۔ سماعت کے دوران انجینئر داؤد خان کی جانب سے دلنواز گنڈا پوری پیش ہوئے ۔ انہوں نے کہا کہ مولانا عطاء الرحمن کی جانب سے سپریم کورٹ میں پیش کیا جانے والا فارم 16جعلی ہے جو کہ اس وقت کے ریڑننگ افسر کی جانب سے جاری نہیں کیا گیا تھا۔ اسی دوران مولانا عطا الرحمان کی جانب سے بتایا گیا کہ ان کے وکیل عبدالحفیظ پیرزادہ آج موجود ہیں ۔ اس لئے سماعت ملتوی کی جائے ۔ تو دلنواز گنڈا کا کہنا تھا کہ عبدالحفیظ پیرزادہ اسی کیس کی سماعت کے دن بیمار کیوں ہو گے ہیں تاہم عدالت نے مقدمہ کی سماعت آج (جمعرات)تک ملتوی کر
http://www.sananews.net/urdu/archives/27901
وزارت کی سرپرستی میں شراب کی فروخت نامنظور، مولانا عطا الرحمن
خواجہ زاہد،ایاز گل | اسلام آباد 29.01.09
حکمران اتحاد میں شامل مذہبی جماعت جمعیت علمااسلام سے تعلق رکھنے والے وفاقی وزیر برائے سیاحت مولانا عطا الرحمن نے شورش زدہ علاقے سوات میں سیاحت کو پہنچنے والے نقصان پر گہری تشویش کا اظہار کیا ہے ۔
وائس آف امریکہ کے ساتھ ایک انٹرویو میں اُنھوں نے کہا کہ سیاحت کے فروغ کے لیے امن کاقیام ضروری ہے اور حکومت سوات سمیت دیگر سیاحتی مقامات پر سیکورٹی کی صورت حال میں بہتر لانے کے ہر ممکن اقدامات کر رہی ہے تاکہ دوبارہ سیاح ان علاقوں کا رخ کر سکیں اوراس شعبے سے وابستہ افراد کا روزگار بحال ہو سکے۔
وفاقی وزیر نے بتایا کہ اُن کی وزارت کے زیر نگرانی کام کرنے والے پاکستان ٹورزم ڈیولپمنٹ کارپوریشن یا ”پی ٹی ڈی سی “ کو غیر ملکی اور غیر مسلموں کو شراب فروخت کرنے سے روکنے کے لیے بھی اقدامات کیے جارہے ہیں کیونکہ نہ تو مذہب اور نہ ہی ملک کا آئین ایسا کرنے کے اجازت دیتا ہے۔
تاہم دوسری طرف ”پی ٹی ڈی سی “ کے عہدیداروں نے نام ظاہر نہ کرنے کی شرط پر وائس آف امریکہ کو بتایا ہے کہ امن وا مان کی ابتر صورت حال کے باعث حالیہ برسوں نہ صرف غیر ملکی بلکہ مقامی سیاحوں نے اُن کے ہوٹلوں کا رخ کرنا چھوڑ دیا ہے جس کے باعث اب ادارے کے اخراجات کو پورا کرنے کا ایک بڑا ذریعہ شراب کی فروخت ہی ہے۔
اُن کا کہنا ہے کہ اس کی اہمیت کا اندازہ اس بات سے لگایا جا سکتا ہے کہ صرف روالپنڈ ی کے تحت ”پی ٹی ڈی سی “ کے ایک اہم ہوٹل ”فلیش مین“ سے روزانہ تقریباً تین لاکھ روپے مالیت کی شراب فروخت کی جاتی ہے
http://www.voanews.com/urdu/news/a-25-2009-01-29-voa11.html?commentSubmitted=y&field=