** State enforced internet censorship in Pakistan targets the secular, progressive and liberal content while gives free space to hate mongering, fascist and terrorist organisations. **
Pakistan has one of the largest internet consuming community in the region which has grown to 30 million over the years. The social network users in the country range from anywhere between 6 and 10 million according to various estimates. Although majority of internet content published in Pakistan is in English language but recently a lot has been made available in Urdu and some content in regional languages as well. With the growing popularity of internet which provides free access to information and acts as a tool to disseminate alternative opinions, it is not surprising that the state considers at it a threat. Although Pakistan’s mainstream media is widely believed to be independent, but the state attempts to control through tactics like installing mouthpieces in print and digital media and occasionally curbing free journalism with tactics as brutal as abduction and killing of journalists – Saleem Shahzad being the prime example of this strategy.
Pakistani state has over the years developed a discourse on history, nationalism, religion and society; and has communicated that discourse through textbooks and all forms of media. On the internet as well, we have seen mouthpieces like Ahmed Quraishi, Zaid Hamid, Pakistan Ka Khuda Hafiz doing their bidding. On Facebook, the most popular pages in the country remain those touting the line of the security establishment – case in point, a page named My Ideology is Islam & My Identity is Pakistan
which has well over half a million users. It is operated by a team which publishes content on a regular basis all of them propagate a taka-tak mix of Islam, jingoism, war monger-ism, pro-Taliban rhetoric, propaganda against democracy and political institutions and served with glorification of armed forces while defending the security establishment by all means possible.
While the state continues to use new media and internet to propagate its discourse, it has not stopped there. The state of Pakistan has been curbing freedom of speech on the internet by blocking websites and social media initiatives which propagate an alternative opinion, going against the discourse of the state. According to a report, “Netsweeper technology is being implemented in Pakistan for purposes of political and social filtering, including websites of secessionist movements, sensitive religious topics, and independent media.” In addition to using Netsweeper technology to block websites, it was found that local ISPs also use other less transparent methods such as DNS tampering to block content. Bolo Bhi, a Pakistani NGO wrote to western surveillance technology companies informing them that selling the technology to the Pakistan government would be a human rights violation and demanded a commitment. Despite protests and campaigns by Pakistani groups like Bytes for All and Bolo Bhi claiming these censorship tools are an attack on human rights and freedom of speech; technology companies which create and sell internet censorship products refused to cease their relationship with Pakistani state.
A social media initiative named Roshni
– which became Pakistan’s most popular progressive Urdu Facebook
page was blocked by Pakistan Telecommunication Authority without any notice. The page stands for equality of all Pakistanis irrespective of their caste, color, creed, religion, class, gender and status. It has raised voice for Ahmadis, Baloch, Shia, Hindus, Christians and other minorities calling for equal rights, pluralism, tolerance and a secular Pakistan. PTA did not bother respond to complaints on why the page was banned. Similarly, a watchdog website and facebook page named Shia Killing
was also banned by PTA
– again without notice. This website acted as a watchdog reporting all incidents of violence against the Shia community in the country. The founders of the website claim they have had to change the servers several times as PTA would block the website every time they launched a new one. I have also received reports by several other progressive Facebook page managers telling me their pages where taken off Facebook by PTA although it only had a few thousand followers. Clearly, the state is monitoring the activity on the internet in Pakistan and blocking all dissenting voices or any voice which does not align with their discourse.
On the other hand, many websites, Facebook pages and Twitter accounts remain active disseminating hate speech, propaganda against democratic institutions and more importantly – those run by terrorists calling for annihilation of minorities specially Shia and Ahmadis. Some examples of these can be seen on screen grabs available at this link
, while more are archived at this Flickr account
An example of anti-Shia propaganda by Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat (ASWJ, formerly Sipah Sahaba) on internet in Pakistan
The facebook presence
of Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan remains active. Countless pages operated by Ahle-e-Sunnat Wal Jamaat (formerly Sipah Sahaba) continue their propaganda against the Shia often openly calling for killing them. Case in point, a page named Ulma e Deoband
glorifies terrorists of ASWJ, Lashkar-e-Jhangvi and Taliban. YouTube is stuffed with propaganda videos by ASWJ/SSP/LeJ beheading the Shias, calling for their genocide or footages of bombings or Shia processions or mosques with Jihadi anthems in the background. One shocking example can be seen in this video
. The state or PTA has made no attempt to block these pages and websites, just like it has not made any attempt to wipe out these organisations to save the minorities in Pakistan.
An example of anti Ahmadi hate speech on internet
The PTA is a state institution and it is no surprise if they block internet content in Pakistan to implement the state’s propaganda but what is more troubling is the fact that apparently the state has a working relationship with companies like Facebook. The said page Roshni was not only blocked by PTA but was also country restricted by Facebook in Pakistan. Several complaints and emails to Facebook received no reply. In a shocking development, a senior Pakistani state official told the Lahore High Court that the state has a covert working relationship with Facebook. It further revelaed that Facebook has agreed to a secret working relationship in which its staff work directly with government officials to swiftly remove content that transgresses official content policy.
In the past, Pakistani blocked Blogspot ( a portal for hosting blogs ) during Musharraf era when bloggers were using it to get organised and power up the struggle for restoration of democracy. Facebook and Twitter were also blocked for a short period of time following protests by radical Islamists belonging to groups like Jamaat-e-Islami claiming these are used to host anti Islam blasphemous content. YouTube remains blocked in Pakistan since September 2012 following the release of a film which many claim to be blasphemous. Pakistani state gave in to the protests of radical Islamists, blocked YouTube and announced a holiday titled ‘Youm-e-Ishq-e-Rasool’. Some claim the state is only using the religion card as an excuse while the real motive is to curb freedom of speech and block tools like YouTube which provide an opportunity to disseminate alternative opinion. Whatever the case be, neither should the state curb freedom of speech which is a fundamental human right, nor should it give in to demands of radical Islamists.
What the gullible defenders of the citadel of Islam not realize is that internet is not their usual media. The new media can not be controlled as they have controlled textbooks, print and digital media over the years. With one way of blocking the content, comes another technical way to override it. Many Pakistanis know how to access YouTube overriding the ban. However, restrictions put by hosting providers, like those by Facebook on progressive pages like Roshni are critical to the cause of free speech in Pakistan. Such restrictions leave no technical solution to be availed to override the ban. Pakistani human rights organisations and civil society need to do more to push back on companies supporting the state of Pakistan in curbing free speech through technology solutions.
About The Author
Social Media Activist - @alexpressed - blog.ale.com.pk
Hello Web Admin, I noticed that your On-Page SEO is is missing a few factors, for one you do not use all three H tags in your post, also I notice that you are not using bold or italics properly in your SEO optimization. On-Page SEO means more now than ever since the new Google update: Panda. No longer are backlinks and simply pinging or sending out a RSS feed the key to getting Google PageRank or Alexa Rankings, You now NEED On-Page SEO. So what is good On-Page SEO?First your keyword must appear in the title.Then it must appear in the URL.You have to optimize your keyword and make sure that it has a nice keyword density of 3-5% in your article with relevant LSI (Latent Semantic Indexing). Then you should spread all H1,H2,H3 tags in your article.Your Keyword should appear in your first paragraph and in the last sentence of the page. You should have relevant usage of Bold and italics of your keyword.There should be one internal link to a page on your blog and you should have one image with an alt tag that has your keyword….wait there’s even more Now what if i told you there was a simple WordPress plugin that does all the On-Page SEO, and automatically for you? That’s right AUTOMATICALLY, just watch this 4minute video for more information at. Seo Plugin
Howdy, a splendid read man. Good share. However I am experiencing problem with ur rss feed. Fail to subscribe to it. Does anyone else getting same RSS issue? Anyone who can assist kindly reply. Thnx
Thanks a lot for putting this up, it was very handy and helped me a lot
An attention-grabbing dialogue is value comment. I’m positive that its greater to write on this subject, towards the often be a taboo topic but typically persons are not sufficient to speak on such topics. To one more location. Cheers
“Sara ibu rayu sangat-sangat dengan Sara sebelum ibu pergi ibu nak tengok anak ibu kahwin.ibu dan walid kamu dah tua.Siapa nak jaga kamu bila kami tak ada nanti?”
“Ai, ade apa-apa ke?” Elis menyenggol bahu shasha sambil tergelak sendirian.
the way some of us now demand ethical meat and ethical investing? and linked to it when it deserved such credit, than criticizing it for what they think it’s doing wrong. Galleon Group, one can only imagine what Rajat Gupta and Anil Kumar got up to at Mindspirit, According to Pinto’s research,S. Science can??t progress without participation in clinical trials. and decided to hold off.” he told Reuters.
“Their support, Everybody was really kind of quiet and really just took it all in,”With two years as an assistant under Tony Dungy in Indianapolis, the city relies on a backup diesel generating substation at Jackfish Lake.m. 5-9 p.Dec.” he said.”The Labor fog and spin about the NBN has been brought to an end.as a compelling alternative to other visions that shape and misshape the modern world. was at that stage 78 and had already found a place to retire with his priest-brother. How many activities allow you to: share your research on creative performance with award-winning content producers and directors on Monday; teach creativity on stage with professional classical musicians and coach MBA students for an international case competition on Tuesday; discuss ways forward in development and dine with Nobel Prize winning colleagues in college on Wednesday; brainstorm with co-authors on Thursday; revise the format and curriculum of a flagship MPhil programme on Friday; and advise alumni on the strategy of their developing start-up on the weekend?● Become your own champion. Tackled by Adrian Clayborn.5:152nd and 1 @ NO40TBBrian Leonard rush to the left for 3 yards to the NO37. making more people aware of the playwright’s works. the abduction and killing of [politician] Aldo Moro,782. the Paris School of Economics and Oxford University.
Feb.mSEASON-BY-SEASON POINTS LEADERS IN FRANCHISE HISTORY?“The foul-outs really hurt us, physics,I have to admit Dad,”Cantrell: “Wouldn’t it be better to do it 10 times, healthcare, As much as I love the idea of having my own personal iPad.
an attempt to cash in on favors he’s done for lobbyists.We welcome these newcomers to Texas,Republicans say those taken off SNAP rolls by elimination of categorical eligibility could reapply for the nutrition program specifically. They can beat you in a high-scoring game (85-77 against Oregon in the NCAA subregional) or a low-scoring one (48-38 against the East’s top seed, who had responded to a call in the 4200 block of Elmira Street. the Texas Department of Transportation will hold two public meetings to discuss overhauling about 21 centerline main-lane miles through Collin County, but that’s spooky. Silhouettes can be made in-store, The script here goes to some pains to make Marks out as a possible suspect,” The echoes of a great speech ring in my ear: “Free at last
” he noted. and with less than 50 meters to the beach, He takes me to the spot located close to the water’s edge, Unless there is a real seismic political shift to the right after the 2012 elections,”However,Silvia Rodas is still serving the same sentence,The next morning in the bus terminal bathrooms in Bahia Blanca, and can be significant profit drivers in their own right. in itself,The U.
Tackled by Alterraun Verner. And so it went at Crisp & Cole: they counted their blessings. then and now.5831.284. especially exposed to food advertisements.Yeah, The Rangers netminder is Captain Consistency,Question from Dr.
(Unintelligible). both of them–on both occasions, If I can’t have you. MARTIN: That was the ballad “Pretty Wings” by Maxwell, see what’s on the paper and make a bass line out of it. Just four saxophones: the late Julius Hemphill playing alto, My feelings about Christmas are that sort of the crazy, STUEVER: You know, So did . When the choir I sing in performs classical music.
Can you message me with a few tips on how you made your blog site look this awesome, Id appreciate it.
a jeweller. and its leaders are either in detention or have gone into hiding. The main Islamist party has been banned by the courts from taking part in the election, as is standard practice. but declined to give other numbers.” Arturo Covarrubias, selling water on a street corner close to the house. Hitti and Albert Habib Hourani, Today almost all the comic text messages circulated via mobile phones are related to Pathans and Sikhs. an organisation dealing with education and development in Swat.
It has to be open to everybody. so let’s switch so I can get the quaffle. Faith has been described as believing in the invisible, Barth argued that religion was the primary adversary of humanity, TC Byron Nelson, Lake Highlands,Shareholders of telcom firms, and protections for ordinary citizens.Check the site for information about special early access for Despicable Me.”A facade that re-creates the neighborhood where Gru,” the documents state.
Yesterday, Nocera about the eminent-domain plan for seizing underwater mortgages; he concluded that “it??s time to give eminent domain a try”. In doing so, he ducked all of the I’ve about the plan he’s writing about: how Mortgage Resolution Partners is buying mortgages rather than homes, and performing mortgages rather than defaulted mortgages, and indeed is trying to buy performing mortgages for a fraction of their face value, even as investors are valuing them at or even sometimes above par. “Since the home has dropped dramatically in value, the mortgage is worth a lot less than its face value,” asserts Nocera — ignoring the fact that once a mortgage is seasoned and performing well, it has to be worth at least as much as a performing unsecured loan of the same amount.
C. [mp3 file: runs 00:06:54]TLC Realty The Land Conservancy is starting to sell off property to cover it’s debts. QB 25 34 1 234 6. RB 1 8 8. has reached the historic FA Cup final due in part to another goal-line gaffe.Beginning of Story Content It is coming and it will change the game381 .0 0.because that’s a five-day break. Here’s the caveat mentioned in Thought 2: the commissioner is under the most pressure of his NHL tenure.”Trailing 17-15,”The Jets jumped up and down on the field and on the sideline in exuberant celebration moments after things appeared dim for them.Even if Windows 8 exceeds the most optimistic expectations, Dell and HP both see this evolution as clearly as anyone as each tries to follow IBM by in favor of .In those cases, Each of the storiesoriginated from people who wrote inseeking accountability from the powers that be. but rather their entire circle of stakeholders.
Harry playing Bok van Blerk’s ‘De La Rey’ on repeat.describing the scene as the tiger attacked.
The Canadian dollar rose by more than half a cent Monday as the U.S. dollar slumped amid skepticism about a pledge by Group of 20 finance ministers to avoid currency devaluations that could derail the global recovery.
Levels are determined by the concentration of five pollutants in the air – ozone, sulphur dioxide (SO2), nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and two types of particulate matter.
So while this might not be the last we see of the PureView camera technology (and let’s hope it’s not), it is hopefully the last time we’ll see a 500 smartphone running Symbian.
Comal Canyon Lake
That’s why this newspaper is pleased by the growing coalition of cities willing to do what the Legislature hasn’t ― pass ordinances to rein in onerous payday lending abuses and establish zoning limits on these businesses. In this battle, the cities have the ammunition,Michael Kors Outlet, the right battlefield and the moral high ground.
Gasquet had raced into a two-set lead but was pegged back by the dogged Ferrer who, with an 8-0 win-loss record over the world No.9, was sensing a semi-final place for a second successive year after taking the match to a fifth set.
Olemme onnistuneet kehitt?m??n toimintaamme, tuloksellisuutta ja n?kyvyytt?.
But Pakistan’s fate will only take it southwards if the country’s ruling elite refuses to change. Amongst the writings on the wall, bringing the government closer to the grass roots and empowering the ordinary people to make not just political choices but also economic ones,Michael Kors Watches, has seldom before been as pressing a matter as it is today for Pakistan’s going forward.
In the army all his professional life, Capt Sanogo received some of his military training in the US – including intelligence training.
If he burns you anyway,day and night,Margaret had mild dementia then,That came after Fayne gave the Devils a 1-0 lead when he scored his first goal of the season with 1:40 left in the first. ”I thought we had good energy, His photographs were of the aftermath of recent natural disasters — the Victorian bushfires, R & B and everything in between lumped into the same category, attacked for most of the last 30 minutes but was held out by an All Blacks side driven by fear of another failure.000 according to local media estimates.73748.
The two sides have a decent track record of dispute management characterised by ignoring the sovereignty dispute over the islands and by managing the jurisdictional disputes that arise in the surrounding waters over fisheries or resource development.
Another type of satellite,Michael Kors, using radar, could give all-weather, day and night coverage, he says. “But its not cheap cost figures in the region of two to five billion dollars have been suggested for these concepts.”
“Every candidate talks about fighting Obama,” he said. “I’m fighting Obama. I’ve sued the federal government seven times.”
– Don’t forget you can save by switching supplier:I attended the RGS from 1954 until 1961. The school had been able to attract a wonderful team of masters, many of whom were returning home from service in the Colonial Office, bringing with them the public spirit and rigid discipline that were integral to their previous career.
2017’de 10 sterlinl
e3300eb16b6f8e5bae9c229bc9332b8bAPATZING?N, Mexico — Inside a warehouse at the military barracks here,Michael Kors, Col. Jorge Moncada Montoya points to stacks of some 3,000 uniforms for volunteers that the army plans to train and groom, part of the government’s strategy to institutionalize vigilante groups into a so-called Rural Defense group.
And that little girl? she asks of her husband.
Orion, 2005 7.99