A legal framework for fighting terrorism – by Nadir Hassan
Everyone can agree that in the legal realm, the fight against militancy has been failing. Too many cases against alleged terrorists end up with acquittals. In recent months, the government has tried to come up with legislative fixes for this problem, first by passing and signing the Investigation for Fair Trial Bill and then voting on the National Counterterrorism Authority Bill. Now parliament has approved an amendment to the Anti-Terrorism Bill.
First, the positives. Setting up the National Counterterrorism Authority, which includes the prime minister, chief ministers and intelligence and police chiefs, finally creates a centralised body that will be able to ensure that all measures relating to terrorism are implemented. It should also allow for better coordination between factions that ought to be working together but are often engaged in turf wars. Intelligence-sharing, one of the keys to counterterrorism, should become more common if this agency exists. And with so much terrorism now transcending borders, it will be helpful to have a body that is not exclusively military in nature and which can coordinate with international intelligence agencies.
The Investigation for Fair Trial Bill has been slightly more controversial since it deals with the issue of the government spying on its own citizens. There are even some who see the name of the bill as an ironic commentary — like the Patriot Act in the US — on its distinctly unfair nature. The criticism has been overblown. The government, in theory, has a right to spy on the electronic communications of suspected terrorists and this bill lays down a process, involving judicial warrants and time limits, for doing so. This bill on its own won’t end illegal government surveillance but at least now there will be a legal mechanism, which should reduce the need for resorting to spying without judicial oversight.
This doesn’t mean that the bill is perfect. There was no need to provide indemnity to the government and private companies that conduct the surveillance so long as they comply with the bill’s provisions. Citizens who feel they have unfairly been spied on should always have the right to confront their government in court. It is also a bit rich that parliamentarians, both at the federal and provincial levels, cannot be spied on without approval from the speaker, especially at a time when there are indications that the PML-N may be forming an alliance with the ASWJ.
The amendment to the Anti-Terrorism Act is the most disappointing in how limited its scope is. It deals with the financial dealings of terrorist organisations and while most of the changes are sensible, one can’t help but feel that this amendment exists only to mollify the intergovernmental Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering, which had blacklisted Pakistan.
There has been no legislative effort to improve the functioning of the anti-terrorism courts which, thanks to the expansive definition of terrorism under the act, very rarely deal with cases that involve terrorism as we have come to understand it. Instead, the courts are bogged down with kidnapping, murder and even celebratory firing cases that are better handled by regular courts.
There has also been no effort to create a witness protection programme although it is briefly mentioned in the original act. Right now, only Sindh has allocated money for witness protection, despite the fact that most acquittals are caused by a lack of witnesses. Judges and lawyers, too, need protection since they are also threatened, sometimes in open court, by accused terrorists.
Source: http://tribune.com.pk/story/513931/a-legal-framework-for-fighting-terrorism/
Ahsan Butt
Correlation is not causation to be sure, but it is quite striking the extent to which LeJ’s activities picked up after Malik Ishaq’s release in the summer of 2011. So some may consider just killing the main leaders of LeJ. The cross-national evidence on the effectiveness of leadership targeting is decidedly mixed. Personally, I’d much rather see Malik Ishaq and his ilk in jail than with a bullet in their head in an “encounter”. It’s not as if the state has been unable to arrest him in the past. The problem has proved to be convicting him, not getting him in court. Which leads me to…
Witness/judge protection
At least in the LeJ case, witness murder is a major stumbling block to securing convictions against militant leaders. It may be advisable to examine other contexts in which witness intimidation/disappearance is a serious problem. For instance, how did the FBI deal with witness protection over the years? What about the Italian state? I recall reading (here, for those interested) that judges dealing with Mafia cases would wear masks when handing down sentences. Might Pakistan practice the same, not just for judges but also for witnesses? And allow witnesses to make video-taped testimony outside the court-room?
nike air force i 145141 mac danmark 303154 isabel marant sneakers bloomingdales 523502 donna hogan kelley obituary 133004 sito ufficiale hogan borse 035330
mac cosmetics history 340103
[url=http://www.museoblaisten.com/00cuadros/maccosmetics/mac_cosmetics_history_340103.asp]mac cosmetics history 340103[/url]
oakley sunglasses 051131 nike shox nz 111035 nike air max command le 310140 isabel marant wedge sneakers nyc 333332 prezzo hogan parallele 312222
fitflop mens sandals 123341
nike free fun 301240 nike air command 505322 discounted mac makeup uk 153043 hogan polacchino uomo prezzo 423505 fitflop due black leather womens shoes 523524
negozi hogan originali on line 004551
http://lemongrass-cafe.com/iepngfix/chanel/coco-chanel-sale.aspcoco chanel sale
where can i buy chanel bags online
nike tanio 332310 mac lipstick up the amp 523434 isabel marant sneakers bloomingdales 245541 hogan sicilia fashion village 455414 fitflop sko brenner american collection services 244541
nike air force women 014041
Some truly interesting information , well written and loosely user genial .
nike air max turbulence 17 nike plus
The next time I come to this blog I will be sure to make better points.
nike air max r4 mens
isabel marantz sneakers free online radio stations 040552
full set of mac brushes 000034
mac lipstick craving 241314 isabel marant sneakers bloomingdales 204555 hogan modello new interactive h flock 215444 hogan rebel junior 37 113443 fitflop uk official site 341044
mac lipstick patisserie 412413
http://english.konyveles-konyvelo.hu/wp-content/uploads/2014/chanel/handbags-and-gladrags.phphandbags and gladrags
discount handbags
Men Nike Roshe Run Anti Fur Mid
http://oldstagesawmill.com/slideshow/beats/beats-by-dre-customize.aspbeats by dre customize
wireless headphones 2.0
http://bellssilver.com/images/canadagoose/20730703173855.aspthe canada goose
goose poop
Some genuinely good and utilitarian info on this internet web site , likewise I feel the layout has great capabilities.
red and black jordan retro
Great post! Im surely sharing this with my friends! Had fun reading it indeed.
latest nike shoes india
http://runwv.com/Colleges/chanel/chanel-sale-2012.aspchanel sale 2012
chanel flap bags
ロレックス デイトナコピー時計:http://www.canot-kayak.qc.ca/rolexwatch.html
フランクミュラーコピー時計:http://www.iconsinmed.org/cir/franckmullerwatch.html
オメガコピー時計:http://oiltechinvest.com/omegawatch.html
http://www.womacksofbawtry.com/index//wp-content/uploads/2014/nb/20140729221536.phpm1400 レディース
http://tmdivisiona.org/ugg/cheap-kids-uggs.aspcheap kids uggs
ugg botts
http://oumnia.org//templates/chanel/chanel-handbags-2013.aspchanel handbags 2013
classic chanel purses
http://www.swedishinspirations.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/nb/20140729222750.phpnew balance 996 classic
http://www.swedishinspirations.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/nb/20140729190137.phpニューバランス 996
new balance abc
http://dawgsled.com/MarchMadness/cl/20140816214607.aspChristian Louboutin Love Me 85mm Escarpins Noir
christian louboutin contrefaçon
http://storehousewest.org/swh/cl/20140816221137.aspchristian louboutin zalando
christian louboutin replica
nike air max skyline sklep 134220 mac eyeshadow discount 241145 isabel marant sneakers bloomingdales 531141 hogan psychometric uk 052020 fitflop manyano leather wedge sandals 012511
scarpe hogan originali femminili 443011
oakley sunglasses 135101 nike free run blue 555344 nike danmark store 202024 etoile isabel marant uk 130021 catalogo scarpe hogan uomo 2013 505114
air max 90 essential 431513
http://thehappyhostessonline.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/nb/20140729191512.phpメンズ ニューバランス
1300 ニューバランス
Your site is also very interesting, very calming effect just reading it. Will spend more time with certain areas. Well done and good luck with your work.
air jordan cp3 7
Thanks for your share, very good understanding. Your blog is good! I am pleased by the info that you have on this blog. It shows how well you comprehend this subject. Added this page, will come back for more. You, my friend, ARE INSANE! so thank you
nike air jordan retro 4 black red
http://onthemarksolutions.net/Components/canadagoose/20140816230522.aspdoudoune fashion
canada goose femme pas cher
http://meadowhills.com/canadagoose/20140817000607.aspcanada goose 2012
canada goose in toronto
http://www.tamachart.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/nb/20140729212441.phpニューバランス 安く
new balance993
nike air max pink and gray 313010 nike air max priser 454041 nike shox nz dame 232055 nike air max 90 essential blue 345502 oakley sunglasses 423403
mac shop 203525
nike free run no support 204333 nike air max 90 og herren 051200 etax for mac 514412 hogan outlet milano 225354 hogan outlet milano 304522
nike roshe men 403223
http://traffictickets.to//images/lv/20730717163628.asplouis vuitton sverige pris
outlet canada goose
http://factsnotfantasy.com//fnf_images/chanel/20140817063917.aspchanel 5 homme
Sac Chanel Rue Cambon A66956
48 year-old Specialist Managers Harlan Oley from Tillsonburg, spends time with hobbies and interests including computers, nike free and dumpster diving. Is stimulated how big the earth is after likely to Archaeological Site of Sabratha.
40 year old Regional Education Manager Jasper from Newton, likes to spend time frisbee golf (frolf), nike free and storytelling. that included visiting Great Mosque and Hospital of Divrigi.
The Nike LeBron 12 returns with a new grade school exclusive for 5/13. Dubbed Buckets, this LeBron release is focused not on the metaphorical buckets poured in on the basketball court but instead the literal buckets of water used to cool off from the summer heat. The silhouette features a familiar color scheme on the LeBron 12, as a Clearwater Blue and Total Orange remind us of the 90s Cavs aesthetic. The posite overlay gets a heavy graphic of cartoonishly painted splashing water while an icy outsole adds another dimension to the theme of cooling off. Check out a better view of the latest LeBron 12 GS exclusive after the break.