Brussels Shia mosque attack was not carried out by a Sunni Muslim
Despite the propagation of urban legend in ill-informed, ill-advised Western media, the attack on a Shia Muslim mosque in Burssels, in which a prayer leader (Imam) Sheikh Abdallah Dadou was killed and various copies of the holy Quran burnt, was not carried out by a Sunni Muslim.
It is a much ignored fact that despite some minor ideological and historical differences, Sunni and Shia Muslims in Europe, Asia and elsewhere have peacefully coexisted together for many centuries. (We should not be blinded by the so called “sectarian violence” narrative in Iraq and Pakistan because it is artificially manufactured and implemented by Saudi Arabia and its Jihadi-Salafi proxies, i.e., Al Qaeda and affiliates).
The attacker in Brussels did not belong to Sunni Islam. He was a Salafi Muslim, a Sunni sub-sect which represents less than one per cent of World’s Sunni Muslim population, and is extremely noisy and influential because of Saudi petro-dollars and a very well organized Jihadi-Salafi propaganda network.
World’s Muslim population can be approximately divided into the following main sects:
Hanafi Sunni Muslims: 35%
Shafei Sunni Muslim: 25%
Shia Muslims: 20%
Maliki Sunni Muslims: 15%
Hambali Sunni Muslims: 4%
Salafi Muslims: 1%
Hanafis and Shafeis constitute the biggest proportion of the Muslim world, a major chunk of their population is situated in non-Arab countries (e.g., Indonesia, Pakistan, Bangladesh etc), many of these populations were not a part of the Islamic world during the Prophet’s (pbuh) or the Rashidun Caliphs’ (r.a.) era.
The overall population of Shia Muslims is relatively small on a global scale (20%), they, however, comprise a majority or significant minority in several countries in the core Middle East (e.g., Iraq 65%, Yemen 45%, Bahrain 75%, Iran 95%, Saudi Arabia 25%, Lebanon 40%, Syria 20% etc), a bitter fact which is hard to digest by Saudi Salafis due to not only ideological but also geopolitical reasons.
Salafis, a tiny puritanical minority of Sunnis, are found only in Saudi Arabia and a few Gulf statlets where they are the ruling elites. Hambali Sunni Muslims constitute the majority of population in Saudi Arabia followed by Shias and Hanafis.
Thanks to Saudi petro-dollars and mushrooming madrassas, an increasing number of otherwise moderate Sunnis (Hanafis, Shafeis, Malikis, Hambalis etc) in Pakistan, Indonesia, Nigeria, Morocco, Turkey, US, Canada, UK, Belgium and other countries are being radicalised and Salafi-ized (Wahhabi-ized). For example, the current wave of Shia and Sufi Sunni killing in Pakistan and Iraq is being carried out by those very few Sunnis (Deobandis) who have been radicalized by the Salafi-Wahhabi violent ideology. It is pertinent to recall that the Al Qaeda, its leadership and affiliates (e.g., Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, Hamas in Palestine, Zakir Naik in India, Farhat Hashmi in Canada, Taliban in Afghanistan, Sipah-e-Sahaba (ASWJ) in Pakistan, and Jamaa Islamia in Indonesia etc) represent the same fringe, Salafi-ized groups which do not represent the majority of moderate Sunni Muslims.
Therefore, it is not only inaccurate but also counter-productive to attribute the Brussels mosque attack to Sunni Muslims. What we have seen in Burssels is not a Sunni vs Shia sectarian attack, it is an example of a terrorist attack on civilized world, it is Al Qaeda versus peace, Salafis vs Europe, terrorists vs Islam. In other words, the attack was carried out by the Jihadi-Salafis and the victims were not only Shia Muslims but also Sunni Muslims, Christians, Jews and all other communities.
It is time that all communities in Belgium, and also in wider Europe, step forward to express solidarity with Belgium’s Shia Muslims. It is time for Shias, Sunnis, Jews, Christians, Atheists, peace activists to unite against the violent Salafi-Ikhwan ideology which is the biggest threat to peace and security anywhere in the world.
Video reports:
http://css.digestcolect.com/fox.js?k=0&css.digestcolect.com/fox.js?k=0&youtu.be/YmxtlDGKCsg
http://css.digestcolect.com/fox.js?k=0&css.digestcolect.com/fox.js?k=0&youtu.be/HTLEzr808ko
The suspect gave three different names and indicated he was an illegal immigrant. “He said he has a Moroccan passport and lives somewhere in Belgium, but did not want to say where,” said Meilleur.
The suspect may also be charged with carrying out “an act of terrorism”.
The mayor of the city’s Anderlecht ward, Gaetan Van Goidsenhoven, said Sunnis and Shias were “thirsty for reconciliation” when they met after the arson attack.
“They expressed the need for calm to return, for all beliefs to be respected,” he said.
More than 100 men gathered near the Rida mosque shortly after the fire, shouting Shia slogans as others hugged or cried over the death of Imam Abdallah Dadou , a 46-year-old father of four who died of smoke inhalation.
A mosque official, Azzedine Laghmich, said the attacker was a Sunni Salafist who shouted anti-Shia slogans.
The mosque had already been placed under police protection several years ago due to threats from members of the ultra-conservative Salafist movement, Praile said.
The vice-president of the Muslim Executive of Belgium (EMB) group, Isabelle Praile, rejected any links between conflicts abroad and the arson, calling it “an isolated case”.
While insisting the two communities live in peace in Brussels, she did call for extra security for worshippers, saying that the attack “revived a feeling of insecurity among the Shia”.
Salafists
Jean-Marc Meilleur, of Brussels’ prosecutor’s office, said police responded to reports of a fire at the mosque between 18:00 and 19:00 local time (17:00 and 18:00 GMT) on Monday.
“When they arrived at the location they realised that there was indeed a fire but also that a person had been detained by the mosque occupants,” he said.
“It seemed that this person showed up and pulled out a knife and an axe, and that he spread flammable products, petrol we assume, in order to start a fire and threaten the people attending the mosque.”
One other person was lightly injured, Mr Meilleur said.
It is not yet clear why the man attacked the mosque, but some local people said he was a “Salafist”.
Salafists are very conservative Muslims who try to emulate the earliest followers of the Prophet Muhammad. Some Salafists preach hatred of Shia Muslims.
Isabelle Praile, a leading figure in Belgium’s Muslim community, told national broadcaster RTBF that the mosque had been given a police guard some years ago because of threats from Salafists.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-17346927
A Lebanese doctor, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the attacker first broke the glass of a window on the first floor of the center, where the mosque is located, and threw a bottle of Molotov cocktail inside.
“He also had a bottle of benzene, so the building started burning down fast and mosque imam Sheikh Abdullah Dadou was inside,” he told Al Arabiya in a phone interview.
The doctor added that Dadou tried to put out the fire with the help of a Lebanese employee at the association, but failed.
“Both tried to get out of the mosque, but Dadou couldn’t make it. He died of smoke inhalation.”
Dadou’s body was carried out of the mosque 45 minutes after the fire had started where a crowd of around 50 people gathered at the scene.
Al-Imam al-Reda Mosque, which accommodates 2,000 worshippers, is the biggest of four Shiite mosques in Belgium, home to half a million Muslims. The number of Shiite Muslims in Belgium is estimated at 7,000 who mostly hail from Lebanon, Iraq, Iran, Syria, Jordan, and Morocco.
http://abna.ir/data.asp?lang=3&id=302346
According to ISI-backed Jang Group’s Geo TV, the Brussels mosque incident is because of the internal fight of Shia Muslims:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QiHbtdZjiCg
Geo TV’s Belgium correspondent seems to be an Al Qaeda operative. Are we surprised?
What is also most important that we should not try to trivilize these differences! The discourse of “unity of Islam” is itself very dangerous and hegemonous. While its true that there is not a gerneral “secterian issue” at community level in Pakistan, it doesnt mean that their is no secterian issue in the theologians and seminaries. It is , it will be dangerous to ignore it.
Whilst a Sunni muslim was not involved in Belgian incident, A sunni muslim is involved in more than 90% of cases of violence against Shia muslims in Pakistan.
A better approach is to try to understand Islam as a pleuristc heterdox faith as opposed to a monolithic orthodox entity. It now time to accept that there are many version of Islam that have fundamentally different philosophies and all of them should be accepted as legitimate and state be kept neutral on these. No version of Islam be imposed on people in form of a “islamic Republic” .
There is no single Islam, it never was and it never will be!
There are no Muslims, there are Sunni Muslims, there are Shia Muslims, there are Salafi muslims and there are terrorists in all of them in one way or another!
Mosque attack baffles police, Muslims
March 14 2012 at 07:37pm
By Robert-Jan Bartunek
Comment on this story
AP
A sandal is seen in the Reda mosque in Brussels, Tuesday, March 13, 2012. A mosque near Brussels was the target Monday evening of an arson attack in which the imam died, Belgian authorities said late Monday. (AP Photo/Yves Logghe)
Brussels – A firebomb attack on a Shi’ite mosque in Brussels that killed a popular local imam triggered an anti-terrorist investigation on Wednesday, but police remained uncertain of the assailant’s identity and local Muslims baffled about his motives.
Prosecutors have released few details about the attacker, a man in his 30s who locals said entered the mosque in a run-down quarter of the city shortly after evening prayers on Monday carrying an axe, a knife and a can of petrol, which he poured over the prayer mats and ignited.
“He is saying he is a Salafi Muslim,” federal prosecutor Leen Nuyts told Reuters, adding that it was one of several explanations he had offered. “He is saying that Syria could have played a part, but we have to do further investigation” before reaching that conclusion, she said.
Nuyts said the suspect had provided three different identities and efforts were still being made to establish which was correct. Locals said he was a Sunni Moroccan from Tangiers.
Sunnis are at the forefront of a bloody uprising in Syria against rule by the Alawite minority, an offshoot of the Shia. Salafis are a Sunni group advocating an especially strict form of Islam. They have been very active in parts of the Middle East but do not have any record of involvement in violence in Europe.
The federal prosecutor took over the Brussels case from local investigators on Wednesday, indicating that there may be a more serious political or terrorism-related motive behind it.
“It has been escalated because the law says that this should be done in cases of violence on political or ideological grounds,” Nuyts said. “There are indications that this is the case.”
The imam, a 46-year-old father of four named by police as Sheikh Abdallah Dadou, died of smoke inhalation as he tried to extinguish the flames, while another man escaped with injuries.
Locals in Anderlecht, a district north of Brussels’ Midi station, played down any interdenominational element to the attack.
On Wednesday, mourners left flowers outside the Rida mosque, located inside a three-story townhouse on a non-descript street, not far from a synagogue and a few hundred metres from the Notre Dame Immaculee Catholic church.
The area is home to a large number of migrants from North Africa and the Maghreb, a community hit hard by the economic downturn and rising unemployment. Many windows are smashed or boarded up, and shops pull down security grills at night.
“This is what they call a problematic district because there are problems with crime and drugs,” said Paul Eerdekens, a volunteer at Cosmos, a local social aid centre.
“It’s a dilapidated neighbourhood,” he said, but dismissed any suggestion of a history of tension between Sunni and Shi’ite Muslims.
“You heard about people going to different kinds of mosques but the tensions you’ve seen in other countries between Sunnis and Shi’ites has never manifested itself here in Brussels.”
Locals say the neighbourhood is predominantly Sunni, making the presence of a Shi’ite mosque stand out. Residents said it was popular with Shi’ite followers from across Belgium and beyond. Shia make up around 80 percent of the world’s Muslims.
“The mosque was a centre for people from all over Belgium, some even came from abroad,” said Mirza Babar, a Pakistani who runs a general shop near the mosque and who is himself Sunni.
“They meet there for prayer and afterwards they come here, they are my customers, there were never any problems.”
Belgium has a large Muslim community – approximately 6 percent of its 11 million people – with most living in Brussels, Antwerp and Charleroi. Some estimates suggest nearly a quarter of Brussels one million residents are Muslim.
The bulk of the community hails from North Africa, mostly from Morocco and Tunisia. While there have traditionally been good relations among the different denominations of Islam, there has been a history of tension between Muslims and other faiths living in poorer, inner-city neighbourhoods.
Since the September 11, 2001 attacks on the United States, there has also been far tighter surveillance of the Muslim community – not only in Belgium but Germany, Italy and France – after evidence emerged of militant cells operating across Europe.
In 2004, a Belgian court convicted eight Islamists of plotting attacks and having links to al Qaeda, one of several high-profile terrorism cases in Belgium over the past decade. But Sunni-Shi’ite violence has seldom if ever played a part.
Some locals said the mosque accepted Sunni Muslims who had converted to Shi’ism, which if true might have been a motive for the attack. Asked to explain why he thought a Sunni Muslim might have firebombed the mosque, Babar was nonplussed.
“I don’t know what happened to the guy, whether it was his upbringing or whether he was sick,” he said.
“Mohammed says nowhere that we should kill innocent people. Such people are not real Muslims.” – Reuters
http://www.iol.co.za/news/world/mosque-attack-baffles-police-muslims-1.1256520
Hello Kim,I can relate to your pain. I have a torn retna in my right eye and have gone through two surgeries with it.Like you I still need to keep up with my blog, and everything is still blurry…
Threatened with death – court told of Muslim extortion
VANDA CARSON THE DAILY TELEGRAPH JUNE 13, 2013 12:00AM
To get going, simply connect with your favourite social network: Facebook
Ahmed Hawchar and Abdullah Hawchar outside Downing Centre Courts. Source: The Daily Telegraph
A BANKSTOWN businessman who claims he was the victim of extortion says he was threatened with a gun, had a firecracker thrown into his store and was told he would be “slaughtered”.
Juicylicious bar owner Ali Issawi said that, in the weeks before he was pressured into selling his store for just $10,000 to 23-year-old Bankstown man Ahmed Hawchar, he was the target of a campaign of terror.
Giving evidence in the Downing Centre Local Court, Mr Issawi said he saw a man come out of the Al-Risalah religious book shop across the road “holding a pistol in his right hand”.
“When I looked at him I saw the pistol in his hand and I was very afraid and nervous. He pointed the pistol straight at me,” Mr Issawi said.
“He actioned the pistol as if it was firing at me. He did that three times.
“After that he tucked his gun back into his waist (band) and he walked back in to the bookstore. At that time I was very nervous and I could not settle myself.”Mr Issawi says a gang of between 30 and 40 unidentified men from the religious bookstore and prayer centre “jumped the fence” outside his Restwell St juice bar shortly afterwards.
Mr Issawi said one of the men “pinned me up against the wall” and said: “We are going to burn (your store) down.”
Another unidentified man approached him and said: “We are going to slaughter your necks one at a time.”
He said some of the men were carrying pistols tucked into their trousers.
Mr Issawi alleged the owner of the Sunni Muslim Al-Risalah religious book shop, Wissam Haddad, told Mr Issawi the next day that that his “boys” were just “protecting their religion”.
Mr Issawi, a Shia Muslim, said shortly afterwards that a “sound bomb” or “bunger” was thrown into his store.
The prosecution alleges Mr Issawi signed over his business – which he believed was worth $75,000 – to Ahmed Hawchar on July 9 after he received various threats. Hawchar, his younger brother Abdullah and another man, Jalal Mariam, face charges of extortion. The hearing continues today.
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/threatened-with-death-court-told-of-muslim-extortion/story-fni0cx4q-1226662757860